The reputation thing: keep it or bin it?

[NMH]

(Names included (if I remember rightly) Hart's Shirt, Simster, Chappers (to name a few). Soon along came Lord Bracknell, Roz, TLO, Lush, Uncle Spielberg, Ken Livingston Seagull, London Irish, Yorkie, Ricky Marlowe's Hair Piece (respects), and it rolled on rather well from there)

Thinking back, there's been a variety of posters come and gone or taken breaks and whatever else.
dwayne, Watford O, laughing bluebird, spireite, taff, Berkshire (mmmmmm lookout I'm well 'ard and will pm everyone with mmmmm threats), Simon Jordan's Leprosy Mentor (aka SJLM), brightonbird, safeway seagull (invalid), Slartibartfast, and some weird kid from Battle.

 

[Icy Gull]

that would then result in tit for tat.


the idea is good but open for abuse

You make a good point but if we are sinking to kindergarten stuff then maybe we should just bin it.

 

[NMH]

If anyone is genuinely too scared to say what they really think because the little green dot next to their name on a football messageboard might turn red, then I have no interest in what their real view is anyway.

That.

 

[otk]

I vote for it's removal as a feature...

 

[matthew]

Keep it

 

[NMH]

The old reverse psychology trick eh? ;-)

Hmm - you might be right, as my reputation just went up about 20 points since stating that.

It won't work, my reputation will never get high and I'll make sure to get enough negs to keep my climate comfortably breathable without use of oxygen tanks.

 

[matthew]

No f*** that bin it! Why's mine so low?!

 

[Durlston]

Sitting on the fence with this one.

 

[DanielT]

Even if my rep went up by several green notches, I'd still vote to remove it.

Please don't test my resolve!

 

[Marc1901]

Keep it, although mine won't go up.

 

[Mr deez]

The one time I tried to give positive rep I couldn't figure out how to so it's already dead to me.

 

[7:18]

The one time I tried to give positive rep I couldn't figure out how to so it's already dead to me.

just click the 6 point star, beside the "report" button under the persons post count on the left hand side of the post...hope that helps

 

[Rowdey]

Bin it - it's got to the point where people are even saying 'i've repped you' on a reply to a thread; it's just more chaff amongst the wheat.

If you have to, a like/dislike instead.

 

[Fef]

Nah. Feedback is the Breakfast of Kings, but anonymous feedback is worthless. Although some NSCers reveal their true selves, most (like me) prefer to remain anonymous behind a username - thus making any feedback more akin to a bowl of Special K rather than a full English.

In its current form it serves little use. A like/dislike button - or even just a like button - on each post would be more useful; afterall, somebody might agree with my viewpoint on one topic, and disagree with me on another. Repping posts rather than an individual is, I feel, the way forward.

 

[Garage_Doors]

Where is it ? looked in profiles but cant see it, can someone give me a link ?

 

[Sergei's Celebration]

[MENTION=14198]HovaGirl[/MENTION] just read some of the comments on your rep, it was like going back in a time machine! They are well out of order.

I voted to keep it, now i have read those comments i think we should bin it. [MENTION=6886]Bozza[/MENTION] take one off for and add to against please for the above reason.

 

[Taybha]

[yt]-6Pbc8SQwV8&feature=related[/yt]

 

[1066familyman]

Bin it, along with all the other bells and whistles. Less is more.

 

[bristolseagull]

Bin, I have a bad rep for absolutely no reason.

 

[Garage_Doors]

Where is it ? looked in profiles but cant see it, can someone give me a link ?

Gone around the NSC for the past hour and still not got a clue whats it is, or where to find anything about it. Am i the only one who has not got a clue what its about