The reputation thing: keep it or bin it?

[madinthehead]

Dont think it really gives much.. Bin it..

 

[Hatterlovesbrighton]

I say keep it, but interested by the liking or disliking individual postings idea.

 

[Sussex Nomad]

A like/dislike individual posts would get the thumbs up from me

 

[little al]

It would make more sense if you keep it, not to have to guess what posts you have been repped for. You should be able to click a button and your last 20 or so reps are on a list, stating who repped, what post they repped and any comment. That's what we have on the BBS and it works fine.

 

[Twinkle Toes]

I say bin the bloody thing.

For those who don't agree with me: I'll bombard you with anonymous negative rep issit.

 

[Waynflete]

Think it just increases cliquiness, or perceptions/accusations of cliquiness. Bin it.

Edit: P.S. Thanks for asking Bozza (can I have a positive rep?)

 

[Husty]

Get rid, I'm tired of getting called a **** e.t.c. and it's just getting abused.

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

If you keep it then people should be accountable for their comments.

I guess the original idea was that it would flag up people who could generally be regarded as credible (or not credible) posters, but seems that it's not being used correctly. For me, good try but bin it.

 

[Silent Bob]

It would make more sense if you keep it, not to have to guess what posts you have been repped for. You should be able to click a button and your last 20 or so reps are on a list, stating who repped, what post they repped and any comment. That's what we have on the BBS and it works fine.

They do have that don't they?

I agree about the like/dislike post button maybe being better.

 

[shaolinpunk]

It only works if people treat it with a pinch of salt and don't take it to heart.

 

[Surrey Seagull]

In the words of the great philosopher Superintendent Chalmers;

"It's just a damn popularity contest with you kids!"

Bin it.

 

[Commander]

I like it.

 

[Simster]

Keep it, but make visible the user giving the rep, even if this means starting again.



Actually, I've changed my mind. Bin it. It's shit. The fact that the Palace BBS uses it says it all.

 

[Racek]

Would prefer a 'Like' or 'Dislike' button on individual posts, rather than individual posters. We know who the dickheads are already.

Some the comments are just puerile, and the keyboard warriors - because of their anonymity - can bollocks up an otherwise half-decent idea.

Bin it.

Agree

 

[8ace]

I'm a bit meh, but if I had to choose bin it.

 

[sam86]

Bin it.

 

[Twente2]

How do u view u rep lol

 

[Lord Bracknell]

I am aware that could add a ridiculous amount of work for the mods...

It's getting busy enough, without encouraging more.

 

[brunswick]

get rid.....i got bad rep for having a different opinion to the majority of a thread....eh? good idea, but doesnt quite work.

just stick to "ban him!!!!!!" if someone steps well out of line.

 

[rool]

Keep it, I had to do some serious ass licking to get my four positive reps