Mark McGhee expects to keep his job if we go down

[Uncle Buck]

Funnily enough I do not tend to personally attack people and I accept that others might think differently. I also disagree with McGhee's decisions sometimes. However, making mistakes is human not a sackable offence in my book.

If you want to start getting personal then fine. I was honest about going tomorrow when I could have lied because what is the point in that.

The problem I have with this board is the people who will not accept our situation. The people who type 'blah blah blah' as a post when you argue that our circumstances are a factor in our league position. That is not an argument, it is pointless.

But this is the thing, the squad in September had enough about it to hold its place in this league, but due to tactics and other factors from the top we are in a downward spiral and that is down to McGhee.

 

[Uncle Buck]

Yes as I have yet to see someone who under these circumstances would do a better job and is available.

Stan Ternant.

 

[Black Country Seagull]

Yes as I have yet to see someone who under these circumstances would do a better job and is available.

Statistically even though he would be albions worst manager, he should still keep his job?

So if that is based on the resources arguement, surely hinslewood should feel hard done by when he was sacked, especially as Mcghee has had more money than he did.

 

[blockhseagull]

Stan Ternant.

Yeah i see he has been suggested but he did well at Burnley when they had money.... when it dried up and had to work with a limited squad he struggled.

Wouldn't think he would do any better than McGhee under these circumstances

 

[Uncle Buck]

Yeah i see he has been suggested but he did well at Burnley when they had money.... when it dried up and had to work with a limited squad he struggled.

Wouldn't think he would do any better than McGhee under these circumstances

Not sure they had any money to speak of.

He did well to keep them up and like Coppell with us, last season at Gillingham if he had come in 5 games earlier he may well have kept them up.

 

[blockhseagull]

Not sure they had any money to speak of.

He did well to keep them up and like Coppell with us, last season at Gillingham if he had come in 5 games earlier he may well have kept them up.

He had big money to spend at Burnley..he spent over 1mill on Ian Moore and also paid big wages to Ian Wright and Gazza when they were doing well.

 

[Uncle Buck]

He had big money to spend at Burnley..he spent over 1mill on Ian Moore and also paid big wages to Ian Wright and Gazza when they were doing well.

The Moore money was during the ITV Digital bubble and on Gazza and Wright they were shot term contracts.

I would say he has worked with limited squads and got the best out them, something that is not happening with us at present.

 

[blockhseagull]

The Moore money was during the ITV Digital bubble and on Gazza and Wright they were shot term contracts.

I would say he has worked with limited squads and got the best out them, something that is not happening with us at present.

No when the TV money dried up thats when he had to cut the squad size and that was when he began to struggle and eventually Burnley got rid

 

[Uncle Buck]

No when the TV money dried up thats when he had to cut the squad size and that was when he began to struggle and eventually Burnley got rid

But they still did enough, that season when players were offloaded, to stay up.

More than McGhee is likely to do this year.

 

[blockhseagull]

But they still did enough, that season when players were offloaded, to stay up.

More than McGhee is likely to do this year.

McGhee did it last year.... so could say they are much of a muchness really

 

[Uncle Buck]

McGhee did it last year.... so could say they are much of a muchness really

Burnley went up automatically and he kept them up in his 2 or 3 seasons at this level, so not much of a muchness.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

But after the players where off loaded in the summer lookis like failing at it this time.

 

[blockhseagull]

Burnley went up automatically and he kept them up in his 2 or 3 seasons at this level, so not much of a muchness.

Yeah but what i'm saying is he took them up when they had money...and the first season they stayed up they had cash to spend also....he didn't do as well on a limited budget as alot of people think.

When the cash dried up he struggled...and they still had more money than we have now

 

[Uncle Buck]

Yeah but what i'm saying is he took them up when they had money...and the first season they stayed up they had cash to spend also....he didn't do as well on a limited budget as alot of people think.

When the cash dried up he struggled...and they still had more money than we have now

But he still did not take them down, ran out of ideas a bit, but then at least he had some ideas to start with.

 

[blockhseagull]

I'm not saying he is shit.... but hardly a miricle worker and not a wonder manager on limited funds

He is out of work and has been for a while now....that tends to tell you something maybe ?

 

[blockhseagull]

But he still did not take them down, ran out of ideas a bit, but then at least he had some ideas to start with.

Neither has McGhee as of yet.

I'm just saying there is no proof he will do that much better than McGhee...if better at all

 

[Uncle Buck]

I'm not saying he is shit.... but hardly a miricle worker and not a wonder manager on limited funds

He is out of work and has been for a while now....that tends to tell you something maybe ?

So getting Gillingham, who had a pants squad last season to the last game with a chance of staying up is not a good effort.

He has been out of work since May, that is hardly a while.

 

[Uncle Buck]

Neither has McGhee as of yet.

I'm just saying there is no proof he will do that much better than McGhee...if better at all

Most things would be better for McGhee.

Kinky riding a goat in the centre circle would be more entertaining than the pish that McGhee manages to produce.

 

[blockhseagull]

So getting Gillingham, who had a pants squad last season to the last game with a chance of staying up is not a good effort.

He has been out of work since May, that is hardly a while.

But Gillingham spent money also did they not ?

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Neither has McGhee as of yet.

I'm just saying there is no proof he will do that much better than McGhee...if better at all

There isnt going to be any proof he could do better is there, due to the fact He would not have had the same squad etc as mcghee has had this year.