Hillian1
( . ) ( . )
Agreed, but the history books will only say France 9 Wales 8.
Wales did not score more points than France and therefore deserved to lose.
And I say that as a Welshman.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
RWC Semi-Final Wales v France
- Thread starter Beach Hut
- Start date
Agreed, but the history books will only say France 9 Wales 8.
Wales did not score more points than France and therefore deserved to lose.
And I say that as a Welshman.
pork pie
New member
It was certainly a red - it would have been in any club match. The taffy lovers appear to be saying that the outrageous spear tackle should be excused because it was in a World Cup Semi. How does that work? Surely, it is the very place that everyone should see that dangerous tackles will not be tolerated?
I think that the Welsh should be very proud of their efforts with 14 men. A few better decisions, and kicks would have seen them win.
I think that the Welsh should be very proud of their efforts with 14 men. A few better decisions, and kicks would have seen them win.
D
Deleted member 18477
Guest
why? arsenal never win the champions league, wales never win the world cup... kind of similar. both pretty to watch, both losers!
Gus is god
Banned
- Sep 9, 2011
- 1,637
Twinkle Toes
Growing old disgracefully
Hillian1
( . ) ( . )
I don't think it was certainly a red, Warburton realised he had taken him up and let go, he certainly didn't drive him into the ground which is the definition of a spear tackle.
As i said in a previous post France scored more points so desrved to win. I am gutted but thats sport.
As i said in a previous post France scored more points so desrved to win. I am gutted but thats sport.
Gus is god
Banned
- Sep 9, 2011
- 1,637
they do but that usually happens when the ref does not see it, the ref saw this and sent him off.
As i said the letter of the law says Red Card, this is the semi final of the World cup, while it looked very very harsh, clearly ya want the ref to follow the rules of the game to the letter?
pork pie
New member
It was a Spear Tackle, It you lift a player with his feet above his head, it is your responsibility to ensure he lands safely - not f***ing dump him on his head. Letting go is not acceptable.
Common as Mook
Not Posh as Fook
- Jul 26, 2004
- 5,636
Which is my point entirely. Why the Welsh grizzling? It's like the English football team FFS having to have a target to blame rather than looking at your own exuberance and ill-discipline.
You obviously don't watch much rugby.
Unbiased ex- players in the studio thought it was a disgraceful decision, one of the worst in the history of the World Cup but you know best!
Hillian1
( . ) ( . )
And has to contain malicious intent.
Any way, I'm gutted but accept the referee's decision. Sport, gotta love it.
Common as Mook
Not Posh as Fook
- Jul 26, 2004
- 5,636
Do me a favour. Dropping/dumping someone on their head is unacceptable.
Unbiased
The whole ITV premise was to big up Wales from the start.
Gus is god
Banned
- Sep 9, 2011
- 1,637
I watch rugby every week and go and played for 19+years the current letter of the law says that tackle was a red card, like i said though i dont think it was malicious at all, it looked more momentum to me but if ya going to play to the rules then it was red, even the coach said it was 100% a yellow card. But appears the ref felt it was a red.
Buffalo Seagull
Active member
Well pork pie's opinion is certainly in line with the IRB's ruling on dangerous tackles. Taken from the IRB website...
Ruling of the Designated Members of the Rugby Committee
1. The act of lifting an opponent off his feet in a tackle AND dropping or 'spearing' that player so that his head and/or upper body comes into contact with the ground first, is a dangerous tackle.
2. The dangerous play described in 1. above is considered dangerous play no matter where it occurs in the game.
The French player was dropped so that his upper body came into contact with the ground first...but you know best!
Common as Mook
Not Posh as Fook
- Jul 26, 2004
- 5,636
Maybe the Welsh should also look at the standard of some of their goal kicking. Hook missed two very kickable pens. Smokescreen
pork pie
New member
You could not be more wrong. I certainly watch more rugby that football at the moment. Indeed, I will be watching it this afternoon.
Hardly unbiased - they are on British TV. I wonder what was said on French TV?
Paddy Power just announced that all losing bets on Wales to be refunded as loss attributed to a wrong referee decision.
Ex-players and people who know what they are talking about = wrong decision
NSC posters with petty hatred of Wales = right decision
Really, some people's brains turn to poo when they get all emotional.
Ex-players and people who know what they are talking about = wrong decision
NSC posters with petty hatred of Wales = right decision
Really, some people's brains turn to poo when they get all emotional.
Common as Mook
Not Posh as Fook
- Jul 26, 2004
- 5,636
Did you not read the rules posted earlier. In the main I couldn't give a toss about rugby, but blaming a referees decision for your own failings when all he has done is apply the letter of the law is mildly irritating.
pork pie
New member
Thank you for that. I am afraid that spear tackles are one of my pet hates. Rugby is an inherently dangerous game, forwards charging around tackling wingers like that cannot be tolerated.
