Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[News] New Orleans Incident







Professor Plum

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 27, 2024
882
I'm one of your liberals, and there is clearly a problem. Terrorism can't be defended. Where you and I may differ then is what to do about it. You may want to round up all Muslims preemptively, I believe that goes against human rights. and tarring them all with the same brush is likely to exacerbate the problem in the first place. You may think we need to bomb them more in the middle east, wipe out Gaza and Iran and so on, I think this would be war crimes and again, would just exacerbate the problem.

I believe all this is linked to the single issue in the middle east, Israel, and if we are serious about reducing Islamic terrorism in the west we should withdraw all support for Israel. Some may see this as giving in to terrorists. But these people really care.

But I really don't want to get into another Israel debate. Just want to point out that we do care and do recognise the problem. It's awful what is happening and what people are doing in the name of their cause
No sane person is advocating “rounding up all Muslims” nor tarring them all with the same brush. But Militant Islam needs to be called out far more overtly — including (or especially) within the Muslim community itself. In the UK, even highly aggressive Islamism, like the school gates protests that send innocent teachers into hiding, needs to be called out at the highest levels. We send people to jail for nasty, ill-judged social media posts but seem to walk on eggshells around the dreadful intolerance found at the fringes of the Muslim community. These double standards are a source of great frustration for many people, and go a long way towards explaining the growing strength of groups like Reform.
 


Kalimantan Gull

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2003
13,644
Central Borneo / the Lizard
This is Israel's fault?
Isis, Manchester bombing, 7.7, 9.11, Iranian sponsored terror, the rest. Israel's fault?
I'm pretty liberal too but f***ing hell ..
I didn't say exactly that. But support for Israel is the wedge issue between the West and sections of the Muslim world. Would there be this conflict if the Jewish homeland was elsewhere? It's THE flashpoint for so much that has gone on.
 


Kalimantan Gull

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2003
13,644
Central Borneo / the Lizard
No sane person is advocating “rounding up all Muslims” nor tarring them all with the same brush. But Militant Islam needs to be called out far more overtly — including (or especially) within the Muslim community itself. In the UK, even highly aggressive Islamism, like the school gates protests that send innocent teachers into hiding, needs to be called out at the highest levels. We send people to jail for nasty, ill-judged social media posts but seem to walk on eggshells around the dreadful intolerance found at the fringes of the Muslim community. These double standards are a source of great frustration for many people, and go a long way towards explaining the growing strength of groups like Reform.
Well I agree, militant islamisim does need to be called out more, but the right, and by this I'm describing much of that wing of the Tory party, not just the Tommy Robinson lot, blame Muslims as a whole, and don't bother with the nuances.

I would obviously support online hatred being dealt with firmly, but I don't have any evidence that it's not?
 


nevergoagain

Well-known member
Jul 28, 2005
1,651
nowhere near Burgess Hill
@jcdenton08 also used the recent Far Right Christmas Market attack as an opportunity to spread Islamophobia. He's nothing but consistent tbf although he looked a bit stupid when it turned out the assailant was on his side.
His side ?, that's a hell of a statement.

The Magdeburg attack is a really strange one, yes he has posted far right views and protested against islam but at the same time was working to get more refugees into Germany. I don't understand why he would target a Christmas market if he's anti-islam and reports suggest he has tested positive for drugs on the night and has a history of mental health issues. There's a lot of detail to come out on this one I think.
 




aolstudios

Well-known member
Nov 30, 2011
5,529
brighton
No sane person is advocating “rounding up all Muslims” nor tarring them all with the same brush. But Militant Islam needs to be called out far more overtly — including (or especially) within the Muslim community itself. In the UK, even highly aggressive Islamism, like the school gates protests that send innocent teachers into hiding, needs to be called out at the highest levels. We send people to jail for nasty, ill-judged social media posts but seem to walk on eggshells around the dreadful intolerance found at the fringes of the Muslim community. These double standards are a source of great frustration for many people, and go a long way towards explaining the growing strength of groups like Reform.
This ^
All of it
 


aolstudios

Well-known member
Nov 30, 2011
5,529
brighton
I didn't say exactly that. But support for Israel is the wedge issue between the West and sections of the Muslim world. Would there be this conflict if the Jewish homeland was elsewhere? It's THE flashpoint for so much that has gone on.
So no responsibility for the perpetrators of militant islamist massacres? That's the racism of tiny expectations, surely? Billions of Muslims & their multiple, super rich, super abusive to their subjects states can't cope with a nation the size of Wales, that was there millennia before they were in the area existing? So they have to bomb Arianna Grande concerts? & Christmas markets? & the regular rest. They just can't help themselves?
Wow.
Just f***ing wow
 


The Antikythera Mechanism

The oldest known computer
NSC Patron
Aug 7, 2003
8,152
What is going on is that someone has placed more speculated crap online as fact, using the video as 'evidence'. It's really irritating.

'Police have yet to confirm the incident was caused by a bomb or fireworks, but two sources with knowledge of the investigation told the BBC's US partner CBS News that investigators were working to determine whether fireworks were responsible for the truck explosion'

In other words, they don't know but are looking at different scenarios
Cybertruck filled with fuel and fireworks explodes at Trump's Las Vegas hotel https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cz7qd97eyp0o

Fuel canisters and firework mortars.
 




Kalimantan Gull

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2003
13,644
Central Borneo / the Lizard
So no responsibility for the perpetrators of militant islamist massacres? That's the racism of tiny expectations, surely? Billions of Muslims & their multiple, super rich, super abusive to their subjects states can't cope with a nation the size of Wales, that was there millennia before they were in the area existing? So they have to bomb Arianna Grande concerts? & Christmas markets? & the regular rest. They just can't help themselves?
Wow.
Just f***ing wow
Of course they are f***ing responsible, of course they are all evil bastards who should all rot in hell for eternity. But what are we talking about here? We're talking about stopping more of these from happening, because as sure as night follows day they are GOING TO KEEP HAPPENING and more poor innocents are going to die. So let's focus on why they are happening. All I ever hear are politiciana and people talking about how they are going to deal with it by locking the extremists up and chucking some bombs in the middle east and increasing police presence, and hey, it works to a point. But some always get through. I would quite like to remove the reason for them hating us in the first place.
 


Springal

Well-known member
Feb 12, 2005
24,970
GOSBTS


nevergoagain

Well-known member
Jul 28, 2005
1,651
nowhere near Burgess Hill
Of course they are f***ing responsible, of course they are all evil bastards who should all rot in hell for eternity. But what are we talking about here? We're talking about stopping more of these from happening, because as sure as night follows day they are GOING TO KEEP HAPPENING and more poor innocents are going to die. So let's focus on why they are happening. All I ever hear are politiciana and people talking about how they are going to deal with it by locking the extremists up and chucking some bombs in the middle east and increasing police presence, and hey, it works to a point. But some always get through. I would quite like to remove the reason for them hating us in the first place.
I agree that Israel/Palestine is the kindling for a lot of extremists but I don't think that's why ISIS etc. sprang to life, it's much more to do with promoting their own twisted view of Islam that is completely intolerant of anything else. Thankfully it is a small minority but you don't need a majority to push a vile agenda and encourage those of a weak mind to follow.
 




Kalimantan Gull

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2003
13,644
Central Borneo / the Lizard
I agree that Israel/Palestine is the kindling for a lot of extremists but I don't think that's why ISIS etc. sprang to life, it's much more to do with promoting their own twisted view of Islam that is completely intolerant of anything else. Thankfully it is a small minority but you don't need a majority to push a vile agenda and encourage those of a weak mind to follow.
ISIS and their ilk spring to life because they think their nationa leaders are decadent heretics who don't follow true Islam and are in the pockets of the Americans. It could be seen a a regional issue which we don't need to get involved in, if it wasn't for the fact that some of these nations sell us a lot of oil, and hatred of Israel and the west is a rallying call. Unpicking this is indeed hard because it's become established facts in their mindset
 


jcdenton08

Offended Liver Sausage
NSC Patron
Oct 17, 2008
15,275
@jcdenton08 also used the recent Far Right Christmas Market attack as an opportunity to spread Islamophobia. He's nothing but consistent tbf although he looked a bit stupid when it turned out the assailant was on his side.
See, this is what always happens.

There is a huge problem with Islamic terrorism. Just like there is a huge problem with far right extremism, gun toting American incels committing heinous school shootings.

But everyone is so quick to scream racism rather than look at the serious underlying issues. There’s a problem with Muslim communities not doing enough to root out Islamic extremism? “You racist!”.

Your post is factually incorrect (and would be libellous if I had posted my real name and said post hurt my reputation/job).

No assailant/murderer/terrorist is ever “on my side”. I have repeatedly denounced people from all backgrounds for committing atrocities such as this in my 17 years on this forum, as everyone should.

And now I’m being outed as a skinhead racist yeah?

Oh and for the record, there’s just as much evidence of the perpetrator of the Magdeburg being mentally ill as being “right wing”. "Germany is persecuting Saudi asylum seekers inside and outside Germany in order to destroy their lives".
 


Herr Tubthumper

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 11, 2003
63,311
The Fatherland
See, this is what always happens.

There is a huge problem with Islamic terrorism. Just like there is a huge problem with far right extremism, gun toting American incels committing heinous school shootings.

But everyone is so quick to scream racism rather than look at the serious underlying issues. There’s a problem with Muslim communities not doing enough to root out Islamic extremism? “You racist!”.

Your post is factually incorrect (and would be libellous if I had posted my real name and said post hurt my reputation/job).

No assailant/murderer/terrorist is ever “on my side”. I have repeatedly denounced people from all backgrounds for committing atrocities such as this in my 17 years on this forum, as everyone should.

And now I’m being outed as a skinhead racist yeah?

Oh and for the record, there’s just as much evidence of the perpetrator of the Magdeburg being mentally ill as being “right wing”. "Germany is persecuting Saudi asylum seekers inside and outside Germany in order to destroy their lives".
Who is "screaming racism" at you?
 






Bakero

Languidly clinical
Oct 9, 2010
15,054
Almería
See, this is what always happens.

There is a huge problem with Islamic terrorism. Just like there is a huge problem with far right extremism, gun toting American incels committing heinous school shootings.

But everyone is so quick to scream racism rather than look at the serious underlying issues. There’s a problem with Muslim communities not doing enough to root out Islamic extremism? “You racist!”.

Your post is factually incorrect (and would be libellous if I had posted my real name and said post hurt my reputation/job).

No assailant/murderer/terrorist is ever “on my side”. I have repeatedly denounced people from all backgrounds for committing atrocities such as this in my 17 years on this forum, as everyone should.

And now I’m being outed as a skinhead racist yeah?

Oh and for the record, there’s just as much evidence of the perpetrator of the Magdeburg being mentally ill as being “right wing”. "Germany is persecuting Saudi asylum seekers inside and outside Germany in order to destroy their lives".

In the clear light of day, would you still "love to hear (someone's) defence of terroristic mass murder"?
 


jcdenton08

Offended Liver Sausage
NSC Patron
Oct 17, 2008
15,275
In the clear light of day, would you still "love to hear (someone's) defence of terroristic mass murder"?
I’m still seeing it, with a poster above blaming the situation in Israel and the West alternately for anger amongst Muslims committing these atrocities. It’s not a defence, but certainly a deflection of moral culpability.

This specific attack is a Muslim issue. It needs to be stamped out within Islamic communities. End of. If the attacks had been committed in the name of “religion” by extremist Jews, Christians, Hindus or Sikhs it would be the moral responsibility of people in those communities to actively condemn and root out the kind of rhetoric which “inspires” people to commit these kind of atrocities.
 


cunning fergus

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jan 18, 2009
4,914
No sane person is advocating “rounding up all Muslims” nor tarring them all with the same brush. But Militant Islam needs to be called out far more overtly — including (or especially) within the Muslim community itself. In the UK, even highly aggressive Islamism, like the school gates protests that send innocent teachers into hiding, needs to be called out at the highest levels. We send people to jail for nasty, ill-judged social media posts but seem to walk on eggshells around the dreadful intolerance found at the fringes of the Muslim community. These double standards are a source of great frustration for many people, and go a long way towards explaining the growing strength of groups like Reform.

Indeed, we’ve come a long way since the mid 80s when for many in this country aggressive Islam and its adherents living in our midst stepped into the limelight with their penchant for book burning and supporting fatwas from clerics based in the Middle East.

Since that point, in both the U.K. and wider west there has been an inevitable slide into the multi cultural mess that we now have to live with where increasing secularism and liberalism simply cannot be squared with Islamic doctrine.

Terrorist attacks are merely the sharp pointy end of that social fissure, and it’s way too convenient to lay that at the door of tension in Palestine. The lower level frictions in this country include the harassment of teachers and the grooming gangs.

Our liberal leaders (Tory and Labour) with the establishment will need to confront the tragic reality that the very values that they support as western values are not supported by many in the Islamic community, and that tension is not going to go away any time soon, arguably its going to get worse.

So far the tactic has been to ignore it or deny the problem exists. I note Jess Phillps (minister for safeguarding women and girls) is not supporting a Govt enquiry into grooming in Oldham following a request by the council.


If they continue like this Reform will fill the vacuum.
 




Springal

Well-known member
Feb 12, 2005
24,970
GOSBTS
I’m still seeing it, with a poster above blaming the situation in Israel and the West alternately for anger amongst Muslims committing these atrocities. It’s not a defence, but certainly a deflection of moral culpability.

This specific attack is a Muslim issue. It needs to be stamped out within Islamic communities. End of. It the attacks had been committed in the name of “religion” by extremist Jews, Christians, Hindus or Sikhs it would be the moral responsibility of people in those communities to actively condemn and root out the kind of rhetoric which “inspires” people to commit these kind of atrocities.
That’s a bit of a nonsense really isn’t it.
 


aolstudios

Well-known member
Nov 30, 2011
5,529
brighton
Of course they are f***ing responsible, of course they are all evil bastards who should all rot in hell for eternity. But what are we talking about here? We're talking about stopping more of these from happening, because as sure as night follows day they are GOING TO KEEP HAPPENING and more poor innocents are going to die. So let's focus on why they are happening. All I ever hear are politiciana and people talking about how they are going to deal with it by locking the extremists up and chucking some bombs in the middle east and increasing police presence, and hey, it works to a point. But some always get through. I would quite like to remove the reason for them hating us in the first place.
So we reward the "evil bastards" for all they've done by removing/annihilating the only tiny democratic state in the region? The only safe place for Jews in the region they're indigenous to?
Not only does that seem a little wrong headed but do you you seriously think the militant Islamists will immediately stop hating us & live in harmony with the west & each other & begin to treat their own subjects less savagely?
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here