Rookie
Greetings
- Feb 8, 2005
- 12,324
How long have they got remaining on their contracts? If only 1 year your lot might decide to cash in especially if we are offering silly money.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Jon-Paul McGovern
- Thread starter Mowgli
- Start date
How long have they got remaining on their contracts? If only 1 year your lot might decide to cash in especially if we are offering silly money.
- Thread starter
- #22
YOU think it's a sideways move, the players however may not.
Smythe
Active member
especially when they see the stadium they'll be playing at in 1 seasons time.
- Jul 7, 2003
- 47,501
If you were a neutral looking in on this debate, of course you'd think it was a sideways move.
Two medium sized clubs as League One goes, one with a larger ground as it stands, but essentially a crap one, one with a quite appalling ground but a shiny new one due in a year's time. Similar sized crowds, probably similar sized wage bills, neither with any particularly glorious history, and both with fairly loaded owners (that don't necessarily throw money at the team in a Southampton style). Swindon exceeded expectations last season, but probably won't do so again this year, the Albion were far below expectation last season, but probably won't do so again this year.
So if you take off your blue or red spectacles, the truth is that it'll probably come down to who offers these players the most money, or whether Greer and McGovern (if any of this is even true) believe Swindon can challenge for promotion to any greater degree than the Albion can.
And yes, Falmer looks lovely, but it's still a YEAR away, and football is a short career.
Two medium sized clubs as League One goes, one with a larger ground as it stands, but essentially a crap one, one with a quite appalling ground but a shiny new one due in a year's time. Similar sized crowds, probably similar sized wage bills, neither with any particularly glorious history, and both with fairly loaded owners (that don't necessarily throw money at the team in a Southampton style). Swindon exceeded expectations last season, but probably won't do so again this year, the Albion were far below expectation last season, but probably won't do so again this year.
So if you take off your blue or red spectacles, the truth is that it'll probably come down to who offers these players the most money, or whether Greer and McGovern (if any of this is even true) believe Swindon can challenge for promotion to any greater degree than the Albion can.
And yes, Falmer looks lovely, but it's still a YEAR away, and football is a short career.
shoreham moonraker
New member
- Apr 11, 2009
- 1,374
Right this is the last time im biting, I enjoy this forum and as a sussex supporter and a resident of shoreham I dont want to get into petty name calling.
Swindon is currently arguably the most financially sound club in the division, the county ground is about to undergo redevelopment which will be finished within 3 years by the same people that did deep dale, we have a manager who has a fantastic relationship with his chairman and they both have long term goals for the club, which is championship football within 3 years of wilsons appointment, so we have 2 more seasons to go to achieve that. As for history, ours is as rich as Brightons, in fact we have very similar history and our attendances are on a par too. we have both made an appearence in the top flight, we have both made a mjor final (1969 we beat arsenal 3-1) we both have similar catchment areas and we both have new people in charge of their clubs that seem to know what they are doing.
Both clubs have sets of fans that have ideas above their station but thats football,
the only thing i would say about you lot is if you do start off well what will happen if a premier league team comes in for poyet? He is a "face" and would placate many an armchair premiership fans idea of a manager, so if a fulham or west ham come knocking would he stay?
I honestly think we are on a level playing field and as you get to falmer we will be playing in a redevloped county ground that will hold 22,000 or thereabouts.
Swindon is currently arguably the most financially sound club in the division, the county ground is about to undergo redevelopment which will be finished within 3 years by the same people that did deep dale, we have a manager who has a fantastic relationship with his chairman and they both have long term goals for the club, which is championship football within 3 years of wilsons appointment, so we have 2 more seasons to go to achieve that. As for history, ours is as rich as Brightons, in fact we have very similar history and our attendances are on a par too. we have both made an appearence in the top flight, we have both made a mjor final (1969 we beat arsenal 3-1) we both have similar catchment areas and we both have new people in charge of their clubs that seem to know what they are doing.
Both clubs have sets of fans that have ideas above their station but thats football,
the only thing i would say about you lot is if you do start off well what will happen if a premier league team comes in for poyet? He is a "face" and would placate many an armchair premiership fans idea of a manager, so if a fulham or west ham come knocking would he stay?
I honestly think we are on a level playing field and as you get to falmer we will be playing in a redevloped county ground that will hold 22,000 or thereabouts.
shoreham moonraker
New member
- Apr 11, 2009
- 1,374
oh and edna, jp mcgovern leads the league 1 assists chart, he is a right midfielder.
Forster's Armband
Well-known member
Totally agree, of course the other factor could be working under Poyet or having fallen out with Wilson or up for new challenge.
Mendoza
NSC's Most Stalked
McGovern and Greer want to board the
___________________
[_|__|__|__|__|__|__\
[__THE GUS BUS_|__|_\
[_@___|||_____|||_@_]
___________________
[_|__|__|__|__|__|__\
[__THE GUS BUS_|__|_\
[_@___|||_____|||_@_]
Withdean Wanderer
Banned
If he's a right midfielder then we should stick with Bennett and spend the money on priority positions.
Forster's Armband
Well-known member
Another reasoned post like Edna's. Poyet has started something serious at The Albion is big on loyalty so I would expect him to stay for a bit despite possible interest from bigger clubs. You miss the point RE: Falmer it is going to be one of the most state of the art stadiums in the country (despite lower capacity than prem grounds). Still not a nailed on your players wont come to us.
murraymints4brighton
Well-known member
All that means f*** all, if they want to go, they will go. Whether they are on a lengthy contract or not, if they want to come and live by the sea side they will and I am sure we can offer them more money than you.
And they may be playing regularly and enjoying it yet they will be hard pushed to find a club outside the Premiership with ambition like us, an exiting manager and coaching team, a fantastic chairman and a magnificent stadium
Meanwhile IN Swindon you have the delights of the "magic roundabout" (not the one with the dog and the springy thing) and that building with the clock. Plus I am sure Greer and Mcgovern will enjoy their football even more playing for the mighty SEAGULLS
Arrogant enough...
supaseagull
Well-known member
Ok let's break that down:
"Swindon is currently arguably the most financially sound club in the division" - Erm no you're not we are
"the county ground is about to undergo redevelopment which will be finished within 3 years"
Brighton & Hove Albion, based in, probably & currently, the most affluent part of the country open their state of the art 23,500 all seater stadium in September 2011 the facilities of which will be unrivalled. If you were a professional football would you choose Brighton & Hove or Swindon?
"we have a manager who has a fantastic relationship with his chairman and they both have long term goals for the club"
Snap - But you also have a manager who is a Brighton legend and who has never has never hid his desire to one day manage us. If Poyet left then it's likely Wilson would be high on the list to take over.
"is championship football within 3 years of wilsons appointment, so we have 2 more seasons to go to achieve that"
We want to achieve promotion next year not in 3 years time and whilst you had a good season last year - you were one of the favourites to be relegated.
I agree with your other comments - However, despite your recent history, I would question your view of Swindon Town as a club of the size of Brighton. If you spoke to many neutral fans who they consider to be a "bigger" club and I'm confident - without wanting to be arrogant that most with a decent knowledge of football would say Brighton.
shoreham moonraker
New member
- Apr 11, 2009
- 1,374
really dont want to get into a dick waving contest, but supa seagull you should really look at our board of directors, or just google sir martyn arrib and andrew black. right im now ducking out of this thread
Publius Ovidius
Well-known member
comparing a team that finished mid table and struggled at the beginning of the season to one that was consistently in the top half of the table and came to within 90 minutes of promotion via the playoffs to the Championship is hardly a sideways move, its a downward move surely?
Why would a player look at us for a ground a season away! Crofts and Calderon obviously thought that Falmer was not a draw.
JJ McClure
Go Jags
Good job no-one on here is doing similar about them.
manilaseagull
Used to be Swindonseagull
Not Until its approved
“There is one stand that is likely to stay at Swindon - the Don Rogers Stand. But without wanting to slavishly copy what that looks like with the others, we will try to do something a bit different.
“It is early days in the design phase, and nothing will be available for quite a while.
“Instead, right now we will look at viability and feasibility as well as helping to locate what will also be at the ground.
“This stage should last around two to three months. By the beginning of the next season, when hopefully Swindon are in the Championship, we can start to give people a bit of feedback.”
SWINDON TOWN: Project chief reveals County Ground plans From Swindon Advertiser)
May 6th 2010
supaseagull
Well-known member
I don't dispute the wealth of your board of directors. In fact, when he took over our club, Bill Archer was the 6th richest businessman in the United Kingdom. He offered to build a stadium at King George V Avenue and look where that ended up but that wasn't what you said...You said that you were the most financially secure club in the division, which IMHO - you're not.
mikeyjh
Well-known member
Can you honestly imagine a players thought process being along these lines? "Hello they're in the most affulent part of the country (BS by the way, but that's another story), and they've got a nice stadium in a year or so time, I'm deffo going to sign for them"?
Or is it "30 % pay rise and a 5 year contract?, thanks, I'll have a bit of that" In which case you're p****g in the wind, cos I'm not sure you why you think that Brighton could outdo Swindon along those lines.
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
We really are not as big an attraction as some of you seem to think. Falmer is a year away and we have yet to show any real intent to put together a team that is in with a chance of promotion.
We need to make a couple of excellent signings, which means spending proper money, to signal our intent and make other decent players want to come here. We seem to be better at losing players than gaining them at the moment.
We need to make a couple of excellent signings, which means spending proper money, to signal our intent and make other decent players want to come here. We seem to be better at losing players than gaining them at the moment.