I know what you are saying but a quiet word to Naylor would have been enough.I bet Naylor is looking at nsc and laughing to himself that Attila posted that on here for support.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
An open letter to Andy Naylor
- Thread starter attila
- Start date
I know what you are saying but a quiet word to Naylor would have been enough.I bet Naylor is looking at nsc and laughing to himself that Attila posted that on here for support.
- Aug 8, 2005
- 26,976
If he is, hello Mr Naylor. You get a lot of unjustified abuse on here, but this time I'm with the majority, you f***ed up big time!
When are you going to run the proper story about why Dean Wilkins was sacked? That would actually be worth reading, and would enlighten the 95% of fans who haven't got a clue why.
Brighton Breezy
New member
Can you please play Boxers by Morrisey before the game on Saturday?
or
Left, Right and Centre by Lord Large featuring Dean Parish.
or
Left, Right and Centre by Lord Large featuring Dean Parish.
NS Herald
Well-known member
Attila is perfectly justified in defending himself through this or any other medium he chooses.
For goodness sake he was making a completely justified comment on the phone in and as to whether/how the club react is up to them and Naylor's article is poor.
Anyone suggesting Attila is looking for 15 minutes of fame needs to get a reality check and they are missing the validity of what what, when, why and how he said at the time and on here - well done
For goodness sake he was making a completely justified comment on the phone in and as to whether/how the club react is up to them and Naylor's article is poor.
Anyone suggesting Attila is looking for 15 minutes of fame needs to get a reality check and they are missing the validity of what what, when, why and how he said at the time and on here - well done
liam82
Onwards and Upwards
Great article, well said and TRUE
Barrel of Fun
Abort, retry, fail
Enough for who? You? Seriously, would you ONLY have a quiet word with, Mr Naylor in this case, in private, if he called for your resignation, via a public forum?
Taybha
Whalewhine
I know where i stand on this,i stopped buying the argus.
that is all.
that is all.
Lord Bracknell
On fire
I can't follow the logic of those people who think "a quiet word with Mr Naylor" is the way to deal with the scurrilous article that got printed in the Argus.
I think most people who read the Naylor piece would come away with the impression that Attila was being accused of trying to stir up trouble at the club by behaving in a way that was inappropriate. Hence Naylor's demand that Attila should stand down from his role as PA announcer.
Since the Argus is read by many more thousands of people than visit NSC, all that a "quiet word with Mr Naylor" would achieve is that those thousands of people might still think that Attila's behaviour was inappropriate - because the Argus had told them so and no-one had challenged that view.
My opinion is that Naylor is shit stirring. I don't know what his agenda is. But he should be told publicly that he's got it wrong. I'll leave it to him to decide whether a gaffe like he's made should lead him to step down as the Argus match-day reporter.
I think most people who read the Naylor piece would come away with the impression that Attila was being accused of trying to stir up trouble at the club by behaving in a way that was inappropriate. Hence Naylor's demand that Attila should stand down from his role as PA announcer.
Since the Argus is read by many more thousands of people than visit NSC, all that a "quiet word with Mr Naylor" would achieve is that those thousands of people might still think that Attila's behaviour was inappropriate - because the Argus had told them so and no-one had challenged that view.
My opinion is that Naylor is shit stirring. I don't know what his agenda is. But he should be told publicly that he's got it wrong. I'll leave it to him to decide whether a gaffe like he's made should lead him to step down as the Argus match-day reporter.
clapham_gull
Legacy Fan
- Aug 20, 2003
- 25,738
Sorry Atilla, although I disagree with Naylor and think what you said was a heart felt response to a rubbish performance, you said what you said and after listening to the recording again - there's been a little bit of revisionism
"I've just about had it.."
"Harty in the old days, if this had been 15 years ago, we would have been on his case months ago.."
"I know rubbish when I see it.."
"To a very very tiny degree I am still prepared to give Micky Adams all the benefit of the doubt, but unfortunately it isn't just the performances that worry me it's his post match presence.."
"If we lose on Saturday the balloon goes up, it's got to otherwise we are sleep walking into the lower divisions.."
It's not quite the "call to arms" that it has been subsequently represented as... merely the sort of thing that we all say after experiencing a pile of trash.
Having said that quite why Naylor thinks you should go after saying the above is frankly bizarre. A personal opinion, but if he thinks it's ok or constructive to write a column like that about someone like yourself (who has worked tirelessly for the club for nothing) , then quite frankly Naylor's opinion isn't worth even reading.
He's gone way way down in my opinion, I won't be bothering reading anything he writes again since all I'll be thinking about is - what's the mans agenda ?
"I've just about had it.."
"Harty in the old days, if this had been 15 years ago, we would have been on his case months ago.."
"I know rubbish when I see it.."
"To a very very tiny degree I am still prepared to give Micky Adams all the benefit of the doubt, but unfortunately it isn't just the performances that worry me it's his post match presence.."
"If we lose on Saturday the balloon goes up, it's got to otherwise we are sleep walking into the lower divisions.."
It's not quite the "call to arms" that it has been subsequently represented as... merely the sort of thing that we all say after experiencing a pile of trash.
Having said that quite why Naylor thinks you should go after saying the above is frankly bizarre. A personal opinion, but if he thinks it's ok or constructive to write a column like that about someone like yourself (who has worked tirelessly for the club for nothing) , then quite frankly Naylor's opinion isn't worth even reading.
He's gone way way down in my opinion, I won't be bothering reading anything he writes again since all I'll be thinking about is - what's the mans agenda ?
Last edited:
Lord Bracknell
On fire
Clapham ... we didn't "lose on Saturday". Therefore the balloon hasn't gone up.
But it was a damned close thing.
But it was a damned close thing.
clapham_gull
Legacy Fan
- Aug 20, 2003
- 25,738
Irrelevant, really.
I'm glad he said what he did, but for it to be subsequently represented as a call to arms for everyone to get behind the team, is like suggesting Lehman Brothers end of year financial report was "disappointing.."
Although possibly it worked like that
, but that was never the intention.
Last edited:
Yawn all f***ing round. Good job it's bed time. Two people with inflated egos of themselves having a pathetic spat in public. Who gives a monkeys. 3 points on Saturday is all that matters. Atilla you voiced your opinion, and Naylor is entitled to voice his own. He writes about Brighton and what is going on at the club. That's his job. He does his job. You do yours. Get over it.
clapham_gull
Legacy Fan
- Aug 20, 2003
- 25,738
Did you get that job with Relate ?
Hannibal smith
New member
As your 35000 posts suggest you have an opinion on everything that has ever been written about on here. So it a bit f***ing rich for you to suggest that they should sort it out in private. You would be the first to spout off on here.
British Bulldog
The great escape
- Feb 6, 2006
- 10,971
I've got no idea if atilla is looking for support or not but he's certainly got a right to reply, Having a quiet word in someone's ear means nothing in Naylors world.
BensGrandad
New member
For what it is worth my opinion is that John Baine replied in the only manner that he could, in an attempt to rectify his position which had been reported inaccurately. As anybody who has written to The Argus knows perfectly well, they edit any letter as they see fit and as has happened to me in the past a letter has been edited to such an extent, just by dropping a few words here and there, that the whole context of the letter is changed.
Well done John, not your favourite supporter or like your choice of music but in this case you were right to voice your opinion which coincides with the opinion of more supporters than actually want MA sacked, I would think.
Well done John, not your favourite supporter or like your choice of music but in this case you were right to voice your opinion which coincides with the opinion of more supporters than actually want MA sacked, I would think.
king Wombat
Well-known member
made me chuckle that did.. personally think its a bit dull. get over it. move on.
Beach Hut
Brighton Bhuna Boy
Not really, perhaps I would not make such a prat of myself by having the emotional rant in the first place having heard this type of crap before.
Plus there are many other "activists" around who never crave as much attention.