what would you have as brightons best ever line up?

[Rookie]

Keeley

Stevens
Cullip
Lawrenson
Chapman

Hart
Sidwell
Wilkins
Jones (just for the step over thing that he does)

Zamora
Nelson

Subs:
Beeney
Foster
Codner
Knight

Manager: Peter Taylor

 

[CHAPPERS]

Beeney

Chapman (standard)
Foster
Bisset
Chivers

Sidwell
Case
Codner

Gotsmanov

Nelson
Zamora

 

[Dave the OAP]

My second team would be:

Grummitt

Stevens Rollings Winstanley Cattlin


Penney Wilson Ryan


Robinson G Smith

managed by Peter taylor ( the 1970's version)

 

[Icy Gull]

I stand corrected...he was shit

Don't be such a......girl

 

[Dave the OAP]

Don't be such a......girl

"flounce"

 

[Lokki 7]

That is about right. Maybe Clive Walker instead of Currie....

I originally put Walker then changed my mind. Close one.

 

[hans kraay fan club]

The likes of Cullip compared to Foster, Lawrenson, Stevens, w Young, E Young, Rougvie, even Rollings. Different era very different class

Whilst I agree with Mr. Piltdown's general point, Willie Young!? You have got to be joking? He may have had a fairly succesful career before joining us but he was a crock of shit when he got here. He certainly din't win any international caps at that time. Were you not at Fratton Park, when we were 1-0 up at half time, before Willie single-handedly gave away FIVE goals in the second half?

 

[Icy Gull]

Whilst I agree with Mr. Piltdown's general point, Willie Young!? You have got to be joking? He may have had a fairly succesful career before joining us but he was a crock of shit when he got here. He certainly din't win any international caps at that time. Were you not at Fratton Park, when we were 1-0 up at half time, before Willie single-handedly gave away FIVE goals in the second half?

The Mark Hately game?

 

[British Bulldog]

Steele

Stevens Foster Lawrenson Catlin

Wilson Horton O'Sullivan

Ryan

Ward Zamora

 

[hans kraay fan club]

The Mark Hately game?

Probably. All I really remember is that it pissed down the whole time, and the Albion fans in the only uncovered stand got very wet.

All except us who were sitting in the main stand having gotten comps [from Keeley I think]. We were giving it large until half-time, and were then made to feel increasingly uncomfortable during the second half as WIllie Young got to work and the goals started piling up!

 

[Lawro's Lip]

GK Corrigan
RB Stevens
CB Foster
CB Lawrenson
LB Hutchings
MF Case
MF Danny Wilson
MF Mortimer
CF Saunders
CF Zamora
CF Ward

Subs (From): Beeney, Michael Robinson, John Gregory (yes I know..but a good player!), Garry Nelson, Martin Keown, Brian Horton, Terry Connor, Gotsmanov, Sammy Nelson, Steve Gatting

Manager: Chris Cattlin

Thats more like it.

How can anyone not have Peter Ward even in the squad. Even if you never saw him play his scoring record for Albion says it all.

(Rant over now.....)

 

[*Gullsworth*]

Whilst I agree with Mr. Piltdown's general point, Willie Young!? You have got to be joking? He may have had a fairly succesful career before joining us but he was a crock of shit when he got here. He certainly din't win any international caps at that time. Were you not at Fratton Park, when we were 1-0 up at half time, before Willie single-handedly gave away FIVE goals in the second half?

I Was there and thats not true..............Joe Corrigan was his partner in crime, on his debut i seem to remember. (I think)

 

[hans kraay fan club]

I Was there and thats not true..............Joe Corrigan was his partner in crime, on his debut i seem to remember. (I think)

Sorry Gullsworth [and Willie]. You are right, Corrigan was also shocking. Willie was still dreadful though!

 

[DTES]

CF - Darius Henderson

Are you joking? In our best ever 11? Next you'll be telling me he's a Premiership player.

What?

 

[*Gullsworth*]

Sorry Gullsworth [and Willie]. You are right, Corrigan was also shocking. Willie was still dreadful though!

Agreed

 

[goldstone]

ben roberts




virgo ingermarson butters mayo





carole carpinter oatway frutos




bobby zamora gifton noel williams

Now look little lad, I guess we don't mind 13 year olds posting on here if they have to, but please think before you post.

"Brighton's best ever line up" and then you list players who have played only in the last couple of years??

Only one of those, Bobby Z, is likely to be in a best ever squad.

 

[Silver flying chariot]

Roberts

Virgs Cullip McShane Harding


Brooker Carpenter Rodgers Jones


Zamora Knight

Harding What the f***??

 

[Gerbil]

Roberts

Virgs Cullip McShane Harding


Brooker Carpenter Rodgers Jones


Zamora Knight

So there's Ian Chapman and you've gone for Dodgy Dan

 

[Deleted member 2719]

Grummit

Williams Foster Lawrenson Stevens/Catlin/Shanks


Horton Case Worthington

Zamora

Mellor Ward

Subs O'Sullivan, Potts, Gregory, Gatting, Nelson

This looks a cracking side i would just swap grummit for Beeney and williams for Chapman and Sidwell on the bench instead of Nelson.

 

[BensGrandad]

With due respect to everybody who has cri tisised surrey13 if that is his age, then he can only state what he has seen and believes to be the best that he has seen with encouragement he may go on to support the club for many years like myself now nearing 60.

My best would be, and a lot will say who was he,

Eric Gill

Gary Stevens
Steve Foster
Mark Lawrenson
Mel Hopkins or Jimmy Langley

Tony Towner
Brian Horton
Denis Mortimer
Dave Turner or Peter O Sullivan


Ian Mellor
Peter Ward.

I do not believe that Ian Mellor was better than Bobby Zamora but playing with Peter Ward they were a very good foil for each other.

Manager: Alan Mullery the only man to take us into what is now the Premiership.