Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Politics] Russia invades Ukraine (24/02/2022)







Eric the meek

Fiveways Wilf
NSC Patron
Aug 24, 2020
8,013
If he goes perhaps they'll keep him.
It's as good a prediction as any. Hold him hostage. To be honest, our record of predictions on here (including mine), is a bit crap.

None of us saw the betrayal and stitch-up of Ukraine coming. At least not the unimaginable scale of the attempted extortion. And then, the strength of character of Zelensky to tell them to **** off.

It's all highly unpredictable.
 




SouthSaxon

Stand or fall
NSC Patron
Jan 25, 2025
136
It's as good a prediction as any. Hold him hostage. To be honest, our record of predictions on here (including mine), is a bit crap.

None of us saw the betrayal and stitch-up of Ukraine coming. At least not the unimaginable scale of the attempted extortion. And then, the strength of character of Zelensky to tell them to **** off.

It's all highly unpredictable.
Obviously it doesn’t matter much what the abilities of the fine denizens of this board are in predicting Trump.

Europe’s politicians and diplomats are another matter. Trump was telling the world last year what he thought. This is a report from September.

I rather feel they fell into the trap/lie, that Farage has regularly used, that “Trump doesn’t speak literally”. When it comes to what he plans to do, yes he does.

Because the US has been our staunch ally for decades, people reflexively assume Trump has similar motives. He really, really doesn’t.
 


Eric the meek

Fiveways Wilf
NSC Patron
Aug 24, 2020
8,013
Obviously it doesn’t matter much what the abilities of the fine denizens of this board are in predicting Trump.

Europe’s politicians and diplomats are another matter. Trump was telling the world last year what he thought. This is a report from September.

I rather feel they fell into the trap/lie, that Farage has regularly used, that “Trump doesn’t speak literally”. When it comes to what he plans to do, yes he does.

Because the US has been our staunch ally for decades, people reflexively assume Trump has similar motives. He really, really doesn’t.
Oh, I'm with you. I agree with all of that.

The message for Europe is clear. Fortunately it looks like Europe has got the message. We can no longer rely on Trump or the US. Both are unreliable, and motivated by money.

Long ago, I came to the conclusion that Trump is supremely unpredictable. There is no discernible positive (or negative) correlation between what he says and what he does. Both happen. Some things he says happen, and some don't. So all we can go on is what he actually does, and look back at history to see if he said it some point.

This doesn't mean we should remain closed to new ideas or events. Things can and will change. We have already seen this.

Several things of interest have happened recently:

1. A deployment of B-52s, a U-2, and others with supporting cargo and personnel. Why?
2. The fly past in Tallinn. Is it a message to Estonians? Why else would it have happened?
3. In the light of point 2, in his recent visit to Poland, Trump promised that U.S. troops would stay in Poland and the country “shouldn't worry.” Was that a false promise? Or was he telling the truth?

All these don't amount to much. But they are food for thought. Let's keep our eyes open.
 




SouthSaxon

Stand or fall
NSC Patron
Jan 25, 2025
136
Oh, I'm with you. I agree with all of that.

The message for Europe is clear. Fortunately it looks like Europe has got the message. We can no longer rely on Trump or the US. Both are unreliable, and motivated by money.

Long ago, I came to the conclusion that Trump is supremely unpredictable. There is no discernible positive (or negative) correlation between what he says and what he does. Both happen. Some things he says happen, and some don't. So all we can go on is what he actually does, and look back at history to see if he said it some point.

This doesn't mean we should remain closed to new ideas or events. Things can and will change. We have already seen this.

Several things of interest have happened recently:

1. A deployment of B-52s, a U-2, and others with supporting cargo and personnel. Why?
2. The fly past in Tallinn. Is it a message to Estonians? Why else would it have happened?
3. In the light of point 2, in his recent visit to Poland, Trump promised that U.S. troops would stay in Poland and the country “shouldn't worry.” Was that a false promise? Or was he telling the truth?

All these don't amount to much. But they are food for thought. Let's keep our eyes open.
My assumption on the flypast thing is that it would have been arranged months ago with Biden’s people and just went ahead as planned.

But that’s the thing, assumptions suddenly carry a much higher risk…
 




Eric the meek

Fiveways Wilf
NSC Patron
Aug 24, 2020
8,013
My assumption on the flypast thing is that it would have been arranged months ago with Biden’s people and just went ahead as planned.

But that’s the thing, assumptions suddenly carry a much higher risk…
You think a B-52 bomber was arranged by Biden's people, to do a fly-past on Estonia's Independence Day, (=a kick in the 'nads to Russia), and left untouched by Trump, to go ahead as planned?

That's the sort of thing a Russian would do, isn't it?

Oh, I see what you mean....

You never can tell...
 






Triggaaar

Well-known member
Oct 24, 2005
54,546
Goldstone
So, re Russian ability to fight and prosecute the war, a report from Congress feels reasonable, definitely not rosy for Russia, but they are not on the brink of collapse.


I didn't have time to look at the link earlier. It's dated 18/8/2023. That's just under 18 months into the war, which is now 3 years old, so I'm not sure what relevance it is?

But regardless, I don't think Russia's war effort itself will collapse either now, or in the near future. What I do think would collapse, is the Russian economy, but that view would change if the US remove the sanctions on Russia.

I don't think Trumps decisions will make Ukraine lose, but they have the potential to save Russia from losing.
 






Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here