southstandandy
WEST STAND ANDY
- Jul 9, 2003
- 6,044
Prefer him to stay.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Facundo Buonanotte **On Loan To Leicester 10/08/24**
- Thread starter macbeth
- Start date
SI 4 BHA
Active member
Unless we find better. OK player, but bloody weak. Maybe he can get a bit stronger. Pretty sure that as a prem. top 10 side we can do better.
The Wizard
Well-known member
- Jul 2, 2009
- 18,399
He’s 19
I feel like people forget this because he seems to have been around while, once he matures into his body and all the usual stuff as players mature he could be a real player, he’s already very technically gifted just raw and needs to find his exact position.
Hard to tell from just highlights but wasn't he playing as one of the CMs against kajima?
Apart from experience the only thing I slightly doubt for the role is stamina, and given the amount of running the chosen two (assuming FH stays with his previous system) are going to get through there's going to be plenty of minutes for substitutes there.
Definite stay for me
Apart from experience the only thing I slightly doubt for the role is stamina, and given the amount of running the chosen two (assuming FH stays with his previous system) are going to get through there's going to be plenty of minutes for substitutes there.
Definite stay for me
bluenitsuj
Listen to me!!!
I'm would be happy with that. A 1 year loan and then back here to rip the league up
Would have got just as much if not more game time with us, in the Premier League
I’m more interested in the 25/26 Facundo than the 24/25 one who surely won’t be a go-to starter for us.
The 25/26 Facundo could be better with a loan and plenty of minutes. A similar loan made Minteh Mint, it can make Buonanotte into a Buen jugador!
Wardy's twin
Well-known member
- Oct 21, 2014
- 8,866
The guy needs to stay and be given game time....
I did see a comment that we won't need as many players these season as not in Europe, well a couple of decent cup runs would put pressure on the squad if we don't have the numbers and there were times last year we just scraped things together. I would prefer to see how season starts then maybe loan if he is not playing/developing.
Bags of talent but does need a bit of support AND needs to play as a 10 and not on the wing.
I did see a comment that we won't need as many players these season as not in Europe, well a couple of decent cup runs would put pressure on the squad if we don't have the numbers and there were times last year we just scraped things together. I would prefer to see how season starts then maybe loan if he is not playing/developing.
Bags of talent but does need a bit of support AND needs to play as a 10 and not on the wing.
kelvinnewman
Well-known member
- Aug 17, 2023
- 203
For me very much depends on what happens with Groß and WBG, if one or both of them move on I can see FB getting a chunk of game time, if they stay around then a development loan might make sense.
Tho a buy clause could end up being a frustrating situation like Undav
Tho a buy clause could end up being a frustrating situation like Undav
- Nov 15, 2006
- 4,245
Of course you don’t he’s not a defender
- Oct 12, 2022
- 2,688
From outside it doesn’t, but we have no idea how happy the player is, how happy the coaching team are with the player’s development and progress, and whether there might be personal reasons for the player wanting to move.
I feel it would be a shame to lose him as he was developing, and would have really benefited from playing in the Ali Mac role rather than out on the wing, but we seem to be buying players for that role, so perhaps we were already aware that Buonanotte wanted away. In all these things we have to trust in the player and the club to find the right solution.
- Oct 17, 2008
- 14,486
A shame if he does go, but our new look side does need a trim so some players will inevitably have to go. In and around the squad alone we’ve got March, Buonanotte, Mitoma, Osman, Minteh, Adingra, Baker-Boaitey, Cozier-Duberry, Sarmiento and Enciso who are able to play on the wing.
Even allowing for Sarmiento, Osman, Buonanotte and Enciso who can play 10, that leaves us with six players vying for two spots. With even more transfers linked and to come.
Realistically, definite want-to-keeps for our first team squad this season are Mitoma, Minteh, March and Osman. I can’t see Cozier-Duberry going anywhere either.
This leaves the sale/loan of any the rest. So while I don’t want to see Buonanotte go, some of them have to and will probably want to given their prospective lack of playing time.
Even allowing for Sarmiento, Osman, Buonanotte and Enciso who can play 10, that leaves us with six players vying for two spots. With even more transfers linked and to come.
Realistically, definite want-to-keeps for our first team squad this season are Mitoma, Minteh, March and Osman. I can’t see Cozier-Duberry going anywhere either.
This leaves the sale/loan of any the rest. So while I don’t want to see Buonanotte go, some of them have to and will probably want to given their prospective lack of playing time.
nwgull
Well-known member
Looks like it’s a loan and possibly a sale.
Loan is definitely realistic, and a good idea for a clearly talented 19 year old. No chance we’re including a buy option though. It’s just not our MO for such a young player, especially who’s only been with us 18 months.
I'm not against a loan but selling him on the cheap seems remiss. And yes, it would be on the cheap as Feyernoord aren't big spenders and his value is only going to rise.
Super Steve Earle
Well-known member
Beautiful cross for assist for the third goal today.
- Oct 12, 2022
- 2,688
I suppose it’s ok to sell for a low-ish fee if there’s the chunkiest of sell-on fees.
I’d rather see him stay, or loan without a buy option, but I trust the club.
Stato
Well-known member
- Dec 21, 2011
- 7,365
Looks like it’s a loan and possibly a sale.
That Twitter account just trawls Twitter and posts anything it finds to do with the Albion. Trace it back to the original report: https://1908.nl/artikelen/feyenoord-en-brighton-in-gesprek-over-buonanotte and it sounds fairly speculative, filling out the article with tangents and says a loan and that negotiations will show whether they'll be a sale will be an option. There won't. Getting FB a development season like Minteh's just had would be our way. Selling him when he's not yet reached his potential would not. Bloom's always been clear, everyone is for sale at the right time and at the right price. For Buonanotte this isn't the right time and the right price won't be coming from Feyenoord.