Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Brighton are too good and will go down one day
- Thread starter The Oldman
- Start date
Saudi shill. He's been crying on Twitter about how unfair it is that Newcastle can't spend their gazillion dollars. He basically thinks it's a game of Monopoly rather than a sport.
beorhthelm
A. Virgo, Football Genius
- Jul 21, 2003
- 36,013
for a veteran and award winning journalist, that's a very peculiar way to say we're doing really well and it may not last.
Brightonfan1983
Well-known member
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
….and yet here we are
Needs to fill those column inches (does he get that much?) somehow
Needs to fill those column inches (does he get that much?) somehow
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,109
It's an argument I've heard a lot, but I think it misses the key point.
he recruitment strategy goes much deeper than "buy a wonderkid, sell on for a profit after a season".
The fact that has happened for 3 or 4 seasons, coinciding with our improvement, doesn't mean it is all we are doing.
We have gradually increased the quality of the whole squad. over the past 5 or 6 seasons.
Our core players are good enough to keep us mid-table at least.
I fully expect the strategy to continue to do this, for a good while yet.
he recruitment strategy goes much deeper than "buy a wonderkid, sell on for a profit after a season".
The fact that has happened for 3 or 4 seasons, coinciding with our improvement, doesn't mean it is all we are doing.
We have gradually increased the quality of the whole squad. over the past 5 or 6 seasons.
Our core players are good enough to keep us mid-table at least.
I fully expect the strategy to continue to do this, for a good while yet.
BBassic
I changed this.
- Jul 28, 2011
- 13,043
There's a narrative I've seen out there that we're a Southampton waiting to happen; that this model has proven to be unsustainable over a long period of time.
Which I don't necessarily disagree with - in theory a couple of bad transfer windows where we sign more duds than wonderkids could cause us problems.
I'm not naive enough to think we won't go down. The odds are against us, in the long term.
But it's a lazy narrative based solely around the fact that we, like Southampton before us, prefer to buy emerging talent to sell for huge profit. It fails entirely to take into account that Tony Bloom isn't a f**king idiot with his money.
Which I don't necessarily disagree with - in theory a couple of bad transfer windows where we sign more duds than wonderkids could cause us problems.
I'm not naive enough to think we won't go down. The odds are against us, in the long term.
But it's a lazy narrative based solely around the fact that we, like Southampton before us, prefer to buy emerging talent to sell for huge profit. It fails entirely to take into account that Tony Bloom isn't a f**king idiot with his money.
brighton_tom
Well-known member
- Jul 23, 2008
- 5,511
It goes hand in hand with the people that compare us to Southampton, in that there was a point where they had a top 6 quality squad which they broke apart by selling for big money & they couldnt replicate it so eventually tumbled down the table. They see how well we're doing, they see us selling players for big money, and think the same will happen. & it may, one day. But the huge difference between Southampton & us, is that yes it was good scouting for them to find those players but the timing which had them in one squad was rather fortuitous. With us it is much more of a long term strategy. We've scouted, bought, developed, and sold players for big money in the past (White, Cucurella, Caicedo, MacAllister, Sanchez, Trossard, Bissouma). We've got players currently in the squad where similar could happen in terms of big fees (Ferguson, Pedro, Enciso, Adingra, Buananotte, Mitoma, Baleba, Barco, Van Hecke, Hinshelwood). & beyond that we have the next batch of players in their early development stages who havent even got to our mens squad yet (Sarmiento, Ayari, Kozlowski, Leonard, Mazilu, Osman, Beadle, O'Mahony etc). Basically the people who write these articles and say it cant last have no idea of the succession planning that goes on in terms of our playing squad. This golden era may not last beyond another 5 years, but there's also a very good chance that it does.
Guy Fawkes
The voice of treason
- Sep 29, 2007
- 8,295
That we need to buy badly, have average at best players which are therefore undesirable to other teams, and will mean that we can keep the side together as the best way for us avoid relegation.
We wont lose our better players, because no-one will want them, and mean that although we'll finish closer to the relegation spots each season (i guess he thinks) we'll survive longer in the division?
I like the idea that if we have a bad season for injuries we are doomed. Fortunately this season we have been lucky and hardly had any, I guess. We decided to take the field vs spurs without a winger or full back on the pitch through tactics and nothing else.
I mean, eventually he's right in that Brighton (and Brentford, and indeed everyone else outside the big 7) will end up being relegated, it's hardly the greatest insight any journalist has produced.
Within the next 5 years? Maybe, maybe not.
Within the next 5 years? Maybe, maybe not.
rebel51
Well-known member
He's right in a way, it won't last all this, it's all been too amazing all this atm, but a club like ours cannot stay rooted in the Premier league,it's not sustainable.
As has been already said, he's only right insofar as it's a truism. It's not remotely insightful.
The bottom line is that unless the league becomes populated by "other 14" clubs (the big 6 will always have enough money to compete/beat us) where their infrastructure is populated by management structures similar to ours, and masterminded by similar statistical geniuses, we're not going down. Even when Bloom steps down, there's a good chance we will continue to compete owing to the structure now in place.
Fred Oliver - Legend
Well-known member
The dark days are back.
NorthstandRacoon
Well-known member
Wtf is he on?! Complete tosser. Makes no sense! Too good so they will go down. If we are to adjust our model to spend more then we will be fine and as long as we are still well run by TB / PB. What a cock,
Greg Bobkin
Silver Seagull
- May 22, 2012
- 16,026
Billy the Fish
Technocrat
Agree with all this.
I'd like to add to the list of potential pitfalls:
Manager that doesn't work out.
Bigger clubs copy and dilute our transfer policy (this might already be happening)
Dressing room turmoil (e.g Leicester under Micky Adams)
Tony Bloom gets distracted
It'll probably be a combo of everything, to varying degrees. . We absolutely will have a bad season sooner of later, we just have to hope we can recover and build again afterwards.
Southampton went down because of a chain of events which began with the death of Markus Liebherr. He was the driving force of their success, his daughter wasn't as interested and sold it to a Chinese bloke who didn't have a clue. It wasn't just some inevitable thing waiting to happen.
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
It is lazy journalism comparing us to Southampton and Leicester. Their demise wasn't so much as they couldn't keep up with the demands of the PL, but that they both had the misfortune to have their owners die.
As long as Tony Bloom is alive and kicking, we'll be ok.
As long as Tony Bloom is alive and kicking, we'll be ok.