AstroSloth
Well-known member
- Dec 29, 2020
- 1,496
Palace fans to leave again at 3-0 only for them to come back to 3-3.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] No Veltman, no party
- Thread starter Guinness Boy
- Start date
pigmanovich
Good Old Sausage by the Sea
To be fair he shouldn’t have been playing at LB!
- Oct 17, 2008
- 15,066
OP is spot on. I’ve been JV’s number one cheerleader on here since he signed and have said many, many times he’s practically my first name on the team sheet. Absolutely crucial player to how we play.
Lifelong Supporter
Well-known member
Veltman is a really good player when he is not playing. When he does play he has good and bad games. He is combative but not classy. I doubt very much if he would be starting for any team above us in the PL. He's not in the Dutch international squad is he?
aolstudios
Well-known member
He was until a bust up with Koeman. He was in previous squads & tbf they have *serious* competition
Last edited:
- Oct 20, 2022
- 7,306
Actually we have 5 that can play RB (Veltman, Webster, Lamptey, Hinshelwood and Kadioğlu) but you’re missing the point again.
To repeat, imo Veltman is by far our best RB followed closely by Jack and we are much poorer in defence when neither of our 2 decent FBs are available - the others are OK options for me (I’ve not seen Ferdi enough as a right sided player to judge though tbf)
I don’t think though, we’d be having this conversation if FH hadn’t resorted into playing 3 at the back with VH as RB because 4 of our RBs were injured, or us relying on a RB who is clearly better in attacking mode than running back to defend.
- Oct 12, 2022
- 2,804
So (purely out of curiosity) why did you say we had one and a half?
I know the OP and you see it differently, but the second goal was a direct result of our reaction to their first goal. We lost our heads.
Veltman is a great RB and a passable RWB, great at shithousery and keeping calm and composed himself, but I’m not convinced he’s the type of leader on the pitch seeking to calm or reassure others. That has to come from captain and coaching staff, Veltman takes care of his own business.
Is the team better with Veltman in it? Playing a back four yes, playing a back three I’d rather see Hinshelwood or Kadioglu there for the role’s overall mobility.
Veltman wouldn’t have made a blind bit of difference yesterday. All we had to do was keep playing the football that had allowed us to control the game for the first 85 minutes. I’m not buying this “our whole team falls apart without Veltman” narrative. At all. Our team fell apart yesterday through FH signalling his panic to the rest of the team, changing formation, abandoning the methods that had allowed us to control the game.
Veltman’s a quality right-back, I’m glad we’ve got him, but to lay recent results solely at the door of his absence is just wrong.
If the OP had said that the right side has been a problem for us without Jack, Ferdi and Joel, I’d agree with him to an extent, but I still maintain that our frailty is psychological and squad-wide, rather than player/position specific.
We don’t believe we can close out games. Fear of making mistakes is paradoxically leading us to make mistakes. We have to be less afraid, and that has to come from the coaching side. I’m hoping this new chap starting in January will be looking/working on this. Time will tell.
- Oct 12, 2022
- 2,804
I hear what you’re saying, but this is how the team are trained to play. If Igor couldn’t see an out ball, he’s supposed to hold onto it until he can.
I agree it sometimes feels suicidal, but I feel blame has to be shared between Igor and the players who were supposed to be giving him an out. We’d lost our heads.
Marshy
Well-known member
- Oct 20, 2022
- 7,306
I didn’t for the final time. Please stop posting edited sentences - it completely changes the meaning.
I said IMO we only have one and a half really decent RB s and that our defensive line is much weaker when Veltman isn’t playing - on the latter point I DO agree with the OP.
- I have consistently said (and listed!!) 5 in the squad who play in that position.
I didn’t read the rest of your post because it was too long and I don’t have time but it wasn’t related to the erroneous point you keep trying to make - that I think we only have 1.5 RBs on the team!
Last edited:
- Oct 20, 2022
- 7,306
See GB and my comments above.
If you rate Lamptey on the same level as Veltman or even Hinsh as RFBs on his defensive work then you must have been watching a different team for the last 2 seasons - As for Ferdi - How often have we played him in RB?
aolstudios
Well-known member
Sorry, Tariq is not a very good full *back*. His defensive positioning, discipline, awareness & anticipation are woeful. He's excellent going forward, of course. No one will dispute that
London Irish
Well-known member
Thought he was much improved yesterday in those areas, he was the real big plus on a day when the stars like Pedro had off days
Brian Munich
teH lulZ
- Jul 7, 2008
- 341
The Dutch national squad love a bust up, don’t they?
aolstudios
Well-known member
Pretty much compulsory aren't they?
Ajax fans told me Joel had called Koeman a "fat ****" & were splitting their sides at his dubbing of ten Hag (who'd made him captain) "the most boring person we'd ever had to listen to"
#harshbutfair
aolstudios
Well-known member
Oh dear
Hopefully Eze has an off day.
Jackthelad
Well-known member
- Mar 31, 2010
- 1,113
Ok to good level when playing well but Hinsh is the only one that excites me for his potential. The others so so and could be replaced long term.
Tony Le Mesmer
Well-known member
Imagine if we had to play in Europe this season.
8 injuries for today's game.
It's crippling us
8 injuries for today's game.
It's crippling us