[Music] The Greatest Band ever!

aftershavedave

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

7,186

as 10cc say, not in hove

• Oct 11, 2024

• #1

Now, my musical penchant happens to be Jazz and black music, but......the greatest band ever are surely The Small Faces, into the Faces circa 1972?

My particuar fave is Debris


But so many others, Rod Stewart was a voice indeed

 

Is it PotG?

Thrifty non-licker

Feb 20, 2017

25,749

Sussex by the Sea

• Oct 11, 2024

• #2

As John Weller would have said ‘Put your hands together for the best band in the f###ing world, The Jam!’

 

aftershavedave

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

7,186

as 10cc say, not in hove

• Oct 11, 2024

• Thread starter
• #3

Is it PotG? said:

View attachment 190162

Click to expand...

I saw The Jam 9 times, and loved them. But there was no Jam without Faces

 

Flounce

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Nov 15, 2006

4,683

• Oct 11, 2024

• #4

Rod Stewart is a long way short of Steve Marriott in the singing stakes! IMO obviously



I loved the Small Faces but it’s hard to think beyond the Stones as the greatest band ever

The Doors shone for a while, Led Zeppelin, Genesis, Fleetwood Mac in both guises, Queen, Pink Floyd, The Who, REM, Bob Marley, The Eagles, Creedence CR, The Kinks etc. Younger people may include the Clash, The Jam, Oasis, Nirvana

Can I include Coldplay in the contenders?

Harry will be along soon nominating at least 20 bands I have never heard of, except maybe Caravan

 

Last edited: Oct 11, 2024

aftershavedave

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

7,186

as 10cc say, not in hove

• Oct 11, 2024

• Thread starter
• #5

And here you go, Ronnie Lane genius:

 

Is it PotG?

Thrifty non-licker

Feb 20, 2017

25,749

Sussex by the Sea

• Oct 11, 2024

• #6

aftershavedave said:

I saw The Jam 9 times, and loved them. But there was no Jam without Faces

Click to expand...

All down to opinions I guess. The Beatles had their influences too. I grew up listening to the 'best band in the world'

 

aftershavedave

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

7,186

as 10cc say, not in hove

• Oct 11, 2024

• Thread starter
• #7

Flounce said:

Rod Stewart is a long way short of Steve Marriott in the singing stakes! IMO obviously

I loved the Small Faces but it’s hard to think beyond the Stones as the greatest band ever

The Doors shone for a while, Led Zeppelin, Genesis, Fleetwood Mac in both guises, Queen, Pink Floyd, The Who, REM, Bob Marley, The Eagles, Creedence CR, The Kinks etc. Younger people may include the Clash, The Jam, Oasis, Nirvana

Can I include Coldplay in the contenders?

Click to expand...

Steve Marriott I agree, but.......Coldplay nein danke. The late 60s early 70s Faces are without doubt the finest of all time

 

Swegulls

Well-known member

Aug 29, 2023

1,353

Stockholm

• Oct 11, 2024

• #8

The Clash for me.

 

aftershavedave

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

7,186

as 10cc say, not in hove

• Oct 11, 2024

• Thread starter
• #9

Swegulls said:

The Clash for me.

Click to expand...

I saw the Clash in 78. They wouldn't have been there without the Kinks and Faces

 

Stato

Well-known member

Dec 21, 2011

7,420

• Oct 11, 2024

• #10

The Beatles .

 

Is it PotG?

Thrifty non-licker

Feb 20, 2017

25,749

Sussex by the Sea

• Oct 11, 2024

• #11

 

Swegulls

Well-known member

Aug 29, 2023

1,353

Stockholm

• Oct 11, 2024

• #12

aftershavedave said:

I saw the Clash in 78. They wouldn't have been there without the Kinks and Faces

Click to expand...

Maybe not, but they were better

 

southstandandy

WEST STAND ANDY

Jul 9, 2003

6,111

• Oct 11, 2024

• #13

The Boxer Rebellion.

 

Flounce

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Nov 15, 2006

4,683

• Oct 11, 2024

• #14

Swegulls said:

Maybe not, but they were better

Click to expand...

Were they f***

 

aftershavedave

Well-known member

Jul 9, 2003

7,186

as 10cc say, not in hove

• Oct 11, 2024

• Thread starter
• #15

 

L

Lenny Rider

Well-known member

Sep 15, 2010

6,095

• Oct 11, 2024

• #16

Macca said this is the greatest song ever written.

So therefore by default surely it has to be The Beach Boys…..

 

Weststander

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Aug 25, 2011

69,966

Withdean area

• Oct 11, 2024

• #17

For me, in no particular order:

The Beatles
Joy Division
New Order
The Jam

Steve Marriott, the same for Steve Winwood, incredible vocalists even as teens. Stunning.

 

Flounce

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Nov 15, 2006

4,683

• Oct 11, 2024

• #18

Lenny Rider said:

Macca said this is the greatest song ever written.

So therefore by default surely it has to be The Beach Boys…..

Click to expand...

Not sure I’ll run with the opinion of the guy who wrote the Frog Song, Let it Be, Hey Jude and Mull of Kintyre’s opinion over most other musicians

All songs to send you to sleep from boredom.

 

TugWilson

I gotta admit that I`m a little bit confused

Dec 8, 2020

1,864

Dorset

• Oct 11, 2024

• #19

PINK FLOYD - Dave Gilmore`s voice and guitar are a thing of true beauty , if Mozart were alive he would be a fan .

 

lawros left foot

Glory hunting since 1969

NSC Patron

Jun 11, 2011

14,135

Worthing

• Oct 11, 2024

• #20

Lenny Rider said:

Macca said this is the greatest song ever written.

So therefore by default surely it has to be The Beach Boys…..

Click to expand...

You mean Paul McCartney?

The Paul McCartney whose repertoire includes the Frog Song, Yellow Submarine, Mary had a little lamb, Wonderful Christmas time, Silly love songs, Pipes of peace?


That Paul McCartney?

When he was good he was great, but, when he was bad, he was worse than awful.