Who is the worst player you have seen play for the Albion?

[DT Withdean]

Junior McDougald springs to mind, but to be fair, i could name loads from that era including Ashley Neale

Down in Bournemouth in torrential rain in 1995 I saw McDougald & Minton destroy the home team.

What about Alan Biley, and Seb Carole, Gavin Hoyte and Graeme Smith (with Peter Grummitt a 9/10, Smith's a zero).

 

[DT Withdean]

Mark Farrington and Mark "we've got and England in-ter-nat-ional" Barham.

Christ, even at the time I realised Barry Lloyd and others had assembled cr*p in the squad, beyond the first 11.

Add Tiltman, Horscroft, Jasper.


A miracle that we made it to 1991 play-off final. In 1991/92, First Division clubs would have knocked-up cricket scores against us.

 

[Derbyshire Seagull]

Steve Jacobs gets my vote. Though he did score for us against Peterborough in a snowy cup match in 1986. Apart from that he was shit.

 

[pork pie]

You could name most of the players from the late Goldstone and Gillingham era. With the so called "strikers" (with the exception of Richie Barker) heading the list.

 

[Braders]

from recent years still my list

Poke
Petterson
G.Smith
Pethick
Richards
Hoyte


how the HELL they thought any of the above were footballers I shall never know..

 

[Braders]

Down in Bournemouth in torrential rain in 1995 I saw McDougald & Minton destroy the home team.

What about Alan Biley, and Seb Carole, Gavin Hoyte and Graeme Smith (with Peter Grummitt a 9/10, Smith's a zero).

Carole started off decently , but every time he came back we seemed to lose a little bit of his quality

 

[BHAFC4EVER]

from recent years still my list

Poke
Petterson
G.Smith
Pethick
Richards
Hoyte


how the HELL they thought any of the above were footballers I shall never know..

Matt Richards?

 

[jharris]

David Lee
Geoff Pitcher
Graham Barrett
Paul Kitson

 

[hans kraay fan club]

Tiltman no question

 

[Statto]

I'm inclined to go Slow Joe Gatting. OK, there's been far worse football players played for the Albion, but at least they looked like they wanted to be footballers, they just weren't very good at it. Whereas Slow Joe always looked like he didn't even want to be a footballer in the first place, just looked like a family member pushed him into it or something.

Totally agree. I cant believe he played as many games as he did!

 

[Mendoza]

David Adekola

 

[DT Withdean]

Carole started off decently , but every time he came back we seemed to lose a little bit of his quality

And unfortunately there wasn't much quality to start with.

 

[chucky1973]

Diego Arismendi...........what a plie of plop that guy was, worst than any of the others mentioned on here.

 

[chucky1973]

Since moving to England, Arismendi has been branded a 'noise pest' after forcing his neighbour to move due to hosting late night parties.[7]

Wick pedia of Arismendi

 

[blue'n'white]

But Richard Tiltman MUST have been OK.
Otherwise why would Lloyd have put him in the team over that useless bastard now what was his name oh yes Dean Saunders !!!

 

[DT Withdean]

But Richard Tiltman MUST have been OK.
Otherwise why would Lloyd have put him in the team over that useless bastard now what was his name oh yes Dean Saunders !!!

That's right. Let's sell Saunders as cheaply and quickly as possible, without a sell-on profit clause.
He'll never make it in the top flight, will never be an international, and won't command big transfer fees.

Well done Lloyd.

Done is the best traditions of BHAFC transfers out:
Horton is a has been. He won't keep a tiny club like Luton in the 1st div for seasons. (There's a far better replacement. Tony Grealish).
Case, he drinks too much. He's too old to play brilliantly in the 1st div for 6 more seasons with S'ton.
Danny Wilson, the same. Can't see that guy beating Arsenal in the League Cup Final.
Beeney. Sell to a cash rich club, with the main part of the fee being a completely unobtainable reach x number of games, with Nigel Martyn No.1 ahead of him.

Lesson for the new Brighton. Don't be mugged again.

 

[gjh1971]

That's right. Let's sell Saunders as cheaply and quickly as possible, without a sell-on profit clause.
He'll never make it in the top flight, will never be an international, and won't command big transfer fees.

Well done Lloyd.

Done is the best traditions of BHAFC transfers out:
Horton is a has been. He won't keep a tiny club like Luton in the 1st div for seasons. (There's a far better replacement. Tony Grealish).
Case, he drinks too much. He's too old to play brilliantly in the 1st div for 6 more seasons with S'ton.
Danny Wilson, the same. Can't see that guy beating Arsenal in the League Cup Final.
Beeney. Sell to a cash rich club, with the main part of the fee being a completely unobtainable reach x number of games, with Nigel Martyn No.1 ahead of him.

Lesson for the new Brighton. Don't be mugged again.

For the umpteenth time, Saunders sale was forced by the bank after they heard we recieved a bid from Oxford, either we sold Saunders or the bank called in their loan. Beeney was sold for a decent sum which you may remember saved the club - we were in court on a winding up order the same day we sold him

 

[Seagull on the wing]

For those of us at Gillingham we had a loan player from QPR Mahoney Johnson or Johnston,the biggest pile of Doo Do ever.

 

[DT Withdean]

For the umpteenth time, Saunders sale was forced by the bank after they heard we recieved a bid from Oxford, either we sold Saunders or the bank called in their loan. Beeney was sold for a decent sum which you may remember saved the club - we were in court on a winding up order the same day we sold him

And Case, Horton, Wilson?

 

[Billy Mays]

Anyone "of age" that doesn't answer Ashley Neal is a complete willy nose. Dishonourable mention for Willie Young for the second half capitulation at Fratton Park in 1984 but at least he had been a legend and was on the way down. How Ashley ever got a pro contract is beyond me.