Where does the signing of Ulloa leave...

[LamieRobertson]

If Dobbie is sold or loaned out, 4 months after being signed questions need to be asked. Presumably on big wages having come from Swansea.

U can b first in the queue to ask

 

[LamieRobertson]

Tit

Great

 

[Green Cross Code Man]

We will not be able to give McSmudger away, we are stuck with him and his wage bill unfortunately.keep playing him and we will not reach the play offs

Why can't you post anything constructive?

 

[Napper]

We might get a new player and already people are trying to get rid of some one else, how about keeping them all and getting some kind of competition for places. I for one would like Hoskins given some time in the side. He appears to get a few games as a sub and that's it. Barnes gets half a season and more.

Agree

Promotion competing sides have numerous options up front. We have made do with bare bones for a while so it now feels we need to trim but reality is we now have enough for them all to compete and impress if given the chance. Keep them all . Squad game , different combinations for different things.

 

[HenryC]

Agree

Promotion competing sides have numerous options up front. We have made do with bare bones for a while so it now feels we need to trim but reality is we now have enough for them all to compete and impress if given the chance. Keep them all . Squad game , different combinations for different things.

Yes keep if we can afford. We only need an injury or two and we're baack in the shit...

 

[hans kraay fan club]

I bet we paid a million for him, he's a proven championship goal scorer.

£300k according to my information, but significant wages.

 

[8ace]

I personally very much doubt it. £500,000 at best we will get for him

This.

 

[Gullys Cats]

Dobbie to Millwall?

Why Millwall? What do you know??

 

[HawkTheSeagull]

Keep them all, one of the reasons for signing a new striker is to cover the position better. You start selling players, all it takes is 1 or 2 injuries and then your down to DS squad players.

 

[Weststander]

Cms to posh, in part ex.

 

[somerset]

Ship Dobbie out on a free, anywhere, just get rid. Hoskins, whatever we can get for him, He's League One standard at best. Barnes is flexible a and valuable addition to the team, as is CMS, and he is our top scorer.

Here is a good example of an idiot, keep Barnes and sell Hoskins do you actually ever watch a full game?..... Mind you, we are stuck with Barnes, no fecker will ever pay good money for him. By flexible you mean he flexes between average and poor?

 

[portslade seagull]

Hoskins will score a fair few more by the seasons end

 

[Richy_Seagull]

Here is a good example of an idiot, keep Barnes and sell Hoskins do you actually ever watch a full game?..... Mind you, we are stuck with Barnes, no fecker will ever pay good money for him. By flexible you mean he flexes between average and poor?

"do you ever watch a full game?" ha the irony eh.

Moronic.

 

[beardy gull]

Here is a good example of an idiot, keep Barnes and sell Hoskins do you actually ever watch a full game?..... Mind you, we are stuck with Barnes, no fecker will ever pay good money for him. By flexible you mean he flexes between average and poor?

You're right, it's a very good example of an idiot. Now, what do you think?

 

[danish seagull]

Out of the lot of them, the one I'd want to keep most would be Hoskins.

Completely agree, he has the quality and only needs the game time to show that

 

[supaseagull]

All totally different types of player that offer something different. Dobbie shouldn't be included though as his position is that of an attacking midfielder - that's where he had played some of his best football.

 

[brightonmark1234]

i think we will still look for another forward or defender

 

[JamesAndTheGiantHead]

Out of the lot of them, the one I'd want to keep most would be Hoskins.

If I may indulge myself, I was on me iPhone earlier, so to explain my reasoning;

I think CMS has basically plateaued in terms of skill. Lordy knows he gives it his all every game and can only be commended for it,
but I don't think he'll get better while still with us, unless there is a drastic restructure in the way that we play/and the players we have. Which won't happen.

Barnes is very similar in some ways, in that he offers a fair bit all over the pitch and will occasionally score an absolutely ridiculous goal that he has no right to score,
but then will spend 4 - 5 games knocking every shot wide of the post.

I don't know about Dobbie, but as previously mentioned he's out of position really and for my money when I've seen him, uninterested.

Either way, those 3 will not win us promotion, even if they're with an absolute goal machine for company.

Hoskins is a wild card in that we haven't seen him play yet, but if it was any of the aforementioned players above running onto that ball from Lopez against Newcastle,
I don't know if they'd have scored. We know about CMS/Barnes/Dobbie, but Hoskins seems to have a lot of potential and think we should give him a PROPER go.

 

[DarrenFreemansPerm]

Cms to posh, in part ex.

Part ex for who?

 

[Medwayseagull]

Hoskins will score a fair few more by the seasons end

Only if he is on the pitch.