Let's have some respect for McGhee

[SJ's Love Monkey]

He's got my respect.

Walking out on Millwall and then leading BHA gallantly to relegation. Legend.

Ouch!

 

[Seagullible]

McGhee has his good points but also has bad points. It depends which you look at most and I'm afraid his tactics and substitutions in addition to his man management have been a consistent issue in my eyes whereas great days such as the Play-off final where a single day and we only just got there thanks to Virgo after a truely awful performance.
By the Voroshilov, just because i don't agree with you it doesn't mean my comments are born from stupidity

 

[Pavilionaire]

I agree that his use of substitutions have been questionable, his transfer dealings mixed and his relationships with some of the squad have been troubled, to say the least.

On balance I actually favour a change of manager because I think we'll have a better chance of promotion if we can get the right man.

However, I think it's pointless sacking him until the Falmer Appeal has been decided, because we'll get much better candidates with an unequivocal YES.

Whatever happens, in 10 years time we'll look back at these past 3 seasons and think "how the f*** did we ever manage to compete at that level with no resources."

All those who say they hate McGhee should feel ashamed.

 

[Lander]

Be fair, it does say rather a lot about the person that posted it. Not exactly a carefully contructed piece it it ?

edited

 

[The Large One]

McGhee has his good points but also has bad points. It depends which you look at most and I'm afraid his tactics and substitutions in addition to his man management have been a consistent issue in my eyes whereas great days such as the Play-off final where a single day and we only just got there thanks to Virgo after a truely awful performance.
By the Voroshilov, just because i don't agree with you it doesn't mean my comments are born from stupidity

Blimey, you have got a guilty conscience.

 

[Tony Meolas Loan Spell]

Where has this come from?

Recent kit sponsor dinner where he was there. MM didnt show and DK was rather quiet.

 

[B.W.]

Some of the recent anti-McGhee comments on this board are well out of order.

Whether or not you think he should remain as manager remember this:

1. He gave us the best day out since 1991 and got us promoted.
2. He kept us up against the odds last seasons.
3. He has not walked away from this club, like the 4 big names before him.
4. He's brought in money to the club from player trading.

The club is no worse off now than when he took over. We're closer to Falmer than we were then and we've got great kids coming through. Few managers could have kept things afloat during these 3 troubled seasons like he has.

Whatever happens to him in the future he'll have my respect.

Agree with all of that...

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Mark McGhee is ok

 

[The Large One]

I agree that his use of substitutions have been questionable, his transfer dealings mixed and his relationships with some of the squad have been troubled, to say the least.

On balance I actually favour a change of manager because I think we'll have a better chance of promotion if we can get the right man.

All those who say they hate McGhee should feel ashamed.

Why do you only focus on the negative? For every 'minus' transfer deal or player-relationship issue against his name, there are several more in the plus column. Also, his record in promoting the Albion from the division below is 100%, so I'm quite satisfied with that.

 

[looney]

Some of the recent anti-McGhee comments on this board are well out of order.

Whether or not you think he should remain as manager remember this:

1. He gave us the best day out since 1991 and got us promoted.
2. He kept us up against the odds last seasons.
3. He has not walked away from this club, like the 4 big names before him.
4. He's brought in money to the club from player trading.

The club is no worse off now than when he took over. We're closer to Falmer than we were then and we've got great kids coming through. Few managers could have kept things afloat during these 3 troubled seasons like he has.

Whatever happens to him in the future he'll have my respect.

My sentiments totally. Well done!

 

[Seagullible]

Blimey, you have got a guilty conscience.

not really, I wnat McGhee out but I'm willing to be reasonerable and listen to all arguements without forcing my opinion on people .

 

[The Large One]

Recent kit sponsor dinner where he was there. MM didnt show and DK was rather quiet.

Rubbish. I had a conversation with MM and DK that evening. MM addressed the audience, remember? And I sat next to Sebastien Carole talking to him all evening, the poor wee sod. And I got plenty of nuggets of information and gossip out of him, plenty of which jar with your post.

Sorry.

 

[The Large One]

not really, I wnat McGhee out but I'm willing to be reasonerable and listen to all arguements without forcing my opinion on people .

I don't think he was referring to you specifically though.

 

[The Antikythera Mechanism]

Cue the attention seeking pseudo city boy friend of celebrities and sweeps ginger wannabe gangsta for an intelligent response

 

[The Large One]

Cue the attention seeking pseudo city boy friend of celebrities and sweeps ginger wannabe gangsta for an intelligent response

Sorry, plain English please.

 

[Charles 'Charley' Charles]

Some of the recent anti-McGhee comments on this board are well out of order.

Whether or not you think he should remain as manager remember this:

1. He gave us the best day out since 1991 and got us promoted.
2. He kept us up against the odds last seasons.
3. He has not walked away from this club, like the 4 big names before him.
4. He's brought in money to the club from player trading.

The club is no worse off now than when he took over. We're closer to Falmer than we were then and we've got great kids coming through. Few managers could have kept things afloat during these 3 troubled seasons like he has.

Whatever happens to him in the future he'll have my respect.

What a great post

 

[bhaexpress]

Cue the attention seeking pseudo city boy friend of celebrities and sweeps ginger wannabe gangsta for an intelligent response

As they say, Good Point Well Made

 

[the right footed denilson]

Recent kit sponsor dinner where he was there. MM didnt show and DK was rather quiet.

bollocks mate

complete and utter bollocks.

i'd like to see MM go, but you REALLY think we have one training session a week?

good post btw.

 

[Race]

Recent kit sponsor dinner where he was there. MM didnt show and DK was rather quiet.

Sorry but you are wrong there, MM got up and did a speach in front of everyone!!! DK sat next to Tank and co most of the evening and certainly wasnt quiet!

As for training once a week, are you being serious??!!

 

[enigma]

Some serious clowns on this board. Training once a week?