Albion Player Ratings, from the SOUTHAMPTON ECHO...

[gruntage]

please give us the saints player ratings....

 

[cobbyseagull]

and the southampton ratings?

im looking for daily echo webiste as we speak...that reporter has no clue...

 

[Simon Morgan]

That is BEYOND biased

 

[gruntage]

100% straight up.

Referee;
Keith Friend 7
"Looked to have made the right calls on all the big decisions"

including murrays pen claim?! the clearest penalty decision ever..?

that paper knows its stuff.

 

[hans kraay fan club]

Saints player ratings;

Davies 7
James 6
Trotman 4
Jaidi 5
Harding 5
Antonio 6
Hammond 6
Scneiderlin 7
Lallana 6
Connolly 6
Lambert 6

 

[The Large One]

Daily Echo ratings;

Michel Kuipers 6
Andrew Whing 6
Tommy Elphick 5
James Tunnicliffe 5
Adam El Abd 5
Elliott Bennett 6
Gary Dicker 6
Andrew Crofts 6
Dean Cox 7
Nicky Forster 6
Glenn Murray 5

Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha etc.

Jesus wept, where the f*** did they dig up the numpty that gave those scores?

 

[sam86]

Haha. So let me get this straight.

Whing - gives a way a dumb penalty - 6
Elph & Tunni - solid all game, didn't give Lambert a sniff - 5

Cox - alright, played well, setup a goal, but lasted 70 odd mins - 7
Murray - two goals, great all round play for 90 mins - 5

Brilliant. Just brilliant.

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

amazing

 

[The Large One]

Come on Si, NAME and SHAME.

What is the name of this Stevie Wonder-wanabee who arbitrarily invents these scores?

 

[cobbyseagull]

Simon Walter

Sport Reporter

Email: simon.walter@dailyecho.co.uk


and thats you daily echo reporter!!!!!

 

[sam86]

Saints player ratings;

Davies 7
James 6
Trotman 4
Jaidi 5
Harding 5
Antonio 6
Hammond 6
Scneiderlin 7
Lallana 6
Connolly 6
Lambert 6

Murray 5

What the...

 

[1066familyman]

 

[cobbyseagull]

Gordon Simpson

Sport Reporter



Email: gordon.simpson@dailyecho.co.uk

or maybe him, there posh they have 2 reported!!!

 

[Mendoza]

Echo
Michel Kuipers 6
Andrew Whing 6
Tommy Elphick 5
James Tunnicliffe 5
Adam El Abd 5
Elliott Bennett 6
Gary Dicker 6
Andrew Crofts 6
Dean Cox 7
Nicky Forster 6
Glenn Murray 5

Argus
Michel Kuipers 8
Andrew Whing 7
Tommy Elphick 8
James Tunnicliffe 8
Adam El Abd 8
Elliott Bennett 6
Gary Dicker 8
Andrew Crofts 8
Dean Cox 7
Nicky Forster 7
Glenn Murray 9

They only agree on Bennett and Cox

 

[Peter Grummit]

So Connolly played better than Murray?

And their keeper better than ours?

Yeah, right.

I don't know why local papers bother scoring the other team, nobody in scumland would be interested (excepting your good self HKFC).

This in a paper reporting that the Scum's own manager confessed we were the better team.

And I thought Insider was one-eyed in his SCR summarising.

PG

 

[El Presidente]

So that makes in total Southampton 64 Brighton 63!

 

[hans kraay fan club]

In fairness to Simon Walter, who wrote the match report, I can't believe that the ratings are actually his, given that amongst other bits, he writes;

Andrew Crofts orchestrated the exquisite opening goal....excellent cross turned in by the clinical Glenn Murray, ...Saints were carved open time and again by the duo, who must rival Lambert and Connolly as the best strike partnership in League 1. etc.

 

[vegster]

How one eyed ! the Saints ratings would seem to indicate that THEY had won the game rather than be on the wrong end of a 3-1 home mauling

 

[hans kraay fan club]

As I say, ratings aside, the report is very fair.


Saints fans comments are mostly generous too;

"Hats off to Brighton. Came with a game plan and executed it perfectly"

"Wish we had Elphick. He's bossed their back line, and cleaned us up today"

"Didn't see that coming. Hats off to Brighton - they played very well"

"Brighton deserved the win, over a side that just didn't show up"

etc..

 

[Austrian Gull]

I had forgotten Schneiderlin was even playing until the last quarter of an hour - and he got a 7

Their keeper did play quite well (good save from Crofts) but Kuipers deserved a better mark.