Which Palace players would you take?

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊



Tooting Gull

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
11,033
Given the chance...for me, definitely Speroni, Clyne and Zaha. And that's it. Jedinak looks good, but Bridcutt's better.
 








Braders

Abi Fletchers Gimpboy
Jul 15, 2003
29,224
Brighton, United Kingdom
Clyne , Possibly Zaha , Murray as backup , give Garvan another looking over and Marrow so he can get the shit kicked out of in training.
 














Glenn-Murray

Banned
Jun 24, 2011
1,808
Given the chance...for me, definitely Speroni, Clyne and Zaha. And that's it. Jedinak looks good, but Bridcutt's better.

Ambrose? Williams? Parr? Gardner?

By the way, Jedinak is far better than Bridcutt. A truly superb find from our Aussie coach Tony Popovic. Was rotting in turkey, has become our most consistent player.

Obviously this is all pointless, as you likely wouldn't be able to get any of them. You couldn't afford half of Zaha and Speroni/Clyne are too good for you as well.
 


Glenn-Murray

Banned
Jun 24, 2011
1,808
i'd take a couple, roles reversed....they would have the whole team

This is entirely false. Are you suggesting you've got anyone half as good as Zaha or Clyne?

I'm struggling to think of anyone other than a fit Vicente or Buckley that I'd take.
 






Silent Bob

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Dec 6, 2004
22,172
This is entirely false. Are you suggesting you've got anyone half as good as Zaha or Clyne?

I'm struggling to think of anyone other than a fit Vicente or Buckley that I'd take.
That's because you are stupid.
 


Tooting Gull

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
11,033
Ambrose? Williams? Parr? Gardner?

By the way, Jedinak is far better than Bridcutt. A truly superb find from our Aussie coach Tony Popovic. Was rotting in turkey, has become our most consistent player.

Obviously this is all pointless, as you likely wouldn't be able to get any of them. You couldn't afford half of Zaha and Speroni/Clyne are too good for you as well.

I'd give you Williams, he was excellent at our place. None of the others. Just middling Championship fare at best, and Ambrose is already well past his best and injury-prone.
 










Glenn-Murray

Banned
Jun 24, 2011
1,808
I'd give you Williams, he was excellent at our place. None of the others. Just middling Championship fare at best, and Ambrose is already well past his best and injury-prone.

Injury prone? You must be having a laugh. He's been injured once in his three years here ffs! As for well past his best you're wrong again, he's only just turned 28 and he's in his prime.

You are wrong about the others. Gardner is probably our POTY so far apart from Jedinak. Parr is still a brilliant left back after playing two consecutive seasons of football in Norway and in the nPC.

Obviously you've probably seen them each only a few times, but I'd imagine Gardner, Parr and Jedinak have been rock solid defensively every time, Williams has been a MoM contender and Ambrose has had superb set piece delivery.
 


Glenn-Murray

Banned
Jun 24, 2011
1,808
Agreed Williams and perhap Speroni and Zaha. Thats all.

Perhaps? Zaha and Williams alone have a market value probably equal to your entire first team. Any Championship pundit will tell you that Speroni is the best keeper in the league.

I'm off folks, you lot are absolutely mental. Cloud coockoo land.
 




seagullondon

New member
Mar 15, 2011
4,442
Ambrose? Williams? Parr? Gardner?

By the way, Jedinak is far better than Bridcutt. A truly superb find from our Aussie coach Tony Popovic. Was rotting in turkey, has become our most consistent player.

Obviously this is all pointless, as you likely wouldn't be able to get any of them. You couldn't afford half of Zaha and Speroni/Clyne are too good for you as well.

out of interest, who would you take from us nigel?
 


Glenn-Murray

Banned
Jun 24, 2011
1,808
out of interest, who would you take from us nigel?

Buckley, a fit Vicente, struggling to think of many others. Maybe Lua Lua is he was on form, or early-season Noone? None of your players have actually impressed whenever I've seen you play (both games against us, Liverpool in the cup twice, Leeds, one or two more)

Can't see any of your defence displacing any of ours though, our record shows why. The only thing we lack is a midfielder that creates chances instead of only finishing them. With Williams injured, someone like (a fit) Vicente would be useful until Jonny comes back.

NOW I'm off :)
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top