Agree about Rooney.
If you look at his achievements on paper, that sounds ridiculous, given the titles he won and records he holds.
But you’re right, his peak was around 18.
The 2004 Euro Championships in Portugal he was outstanding, and looked like he could go on to be a true world star at a level England never really produces. Pele. Maradona. Messi. But everything after that just felt less and less. Diminishing returns.
And sure, he continued to score the occasional worldie every season or two, and hoover up titles due to being part of a dominant Utd side, and notch up the England goals in meaningless qualifiers, but but but... he looked in the beginning like he might have been genuinely magical. And that magic never truly shone as dazzlingly as hoped.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Agree about Rooney.
If you look at his achievements on paper, that sounds ridiculous, given the titles he won and records he holds.
But you’re right, his peak was around 18.
The 2004 Euro Championships in Portugal he was outstanding, and looked like he could go on to be a true world star at a level England never really produces. Pele. Maradona. Messi. But everything after that just felt less and less. Diminishing returns.
And sure, he continued to score the occasional worldie every season or two, and hoover up titles due to being part of a dominant Utd side, and notch up the England goals in meaningless qualifiers, but but but... he looked in the beginning like he might have been genuinely magical. And that magic never truly shone as dazzlingly as hoped.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Abdul Razak. Anyone who saw that performance against Ipswich will know what could have been.
Le Tissier.
Should have had 100 caps for England, played in the Champions League, won trophies.
An astonishing talent, that whilst admirable he stayed at his first club, should have done so much more.
I agree about Robson and even more controversially, I don't think Rooney made the most of his talent either and I think that was mainly down to lifestyle and drinking. I know, I know, this is ridiculous as he's United's and England's record scorer but he could have done even more. I have never seen a kid as frighteningly talented as he was between 16 and 18, I think he should have been the best ever, better than Messi, Ronaldo and Maradonna but he peaked at 18.
OK I'll bite:
Gareth Barry
Craig Johnston
Owen Hargreaves
Jamie Carragher
Adama Traore
Craig Mackail-Smith
James Milner
Jordan Henderson
Quite a lot of Liverpool in there
As for big fish in a small pond, I'm not sure that Zaha is really a big fish, and allegedly, unlike Le Tiss, he wants to leave his club but can't
I'm not sure he did waste his talent, in fact by staying at Southampton I think he made the most of it. I had to watch his career closely living here and he was a remarkable player but I don't think he could have done what he did for Southampton at a bigger club, he wouldn't have been afforded the freedom he had there and he just wouldn't have been able to fit into a structured side alongside other talented individuals. He needed freedom - he was at his best when Alan Ball just said to the other players to just give him the ball and let him do what he wanted.
If he had gone to Spurs or Chelsea who he always seemed to be linked to, I think it would have been a matter of time before he was a bit part player, he wasn't disciplined enough to be a small cog in a bigger machine.
And the daddy of them all, Kevin Keegan.
Strange choice: I'd have said Keegan was the exact opposite of a wasted talent: a player who didn't have the greatest natural talent in the world but made the absolute most of what he had
Strange choice: I'd have said Keegan was the exact opposite of a wasted talent: a player who didn't have the greatest natural talent in the world but made the absolute most of what he had
SEGW - Big fish, small pond
A little disingenuous to some of those that got 110% out of limited talent, through hard work and application Harry ? I give you
David Beckham
Ashley Barnes
For anyone too young to remember Matt Le Tissier, do yourself a favour and watch this. Ask yourself how this guy didn’t play more than 8 times for England.