Yeah he was really odd at corners and was also doing some odd movement like he was milking a cow with his hand and squeezing/clenching it. He took a lot of abuse from the family stand* over Alonso's elbow to Knocky.
*me
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Today’s ref Stuart Attwell
- Thread starter LamieRobertson
- Start date
Yeah he was really odd at corners and was also doing some odd movement like he was milking a cow with his hand and squeezing/clenching it. He took a lot of abuse from the family stand* over Alonso's elbow to Knocky.
*me
In 47 years of watching football, I have never seen the free kick given for an offside taken in our own half. It is an UTTER nonsense.
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
Top 4 Licker
Come on Piltdown......
No one, including [MENTION=2743]Mellor 3 Ward 4[/MENTION] is disputing that. We all know that you can only be offside in your opponent's half of the pitch.
The point of contention is where the resulting free-kick is taken from.
Like many on here, I was also screaming that Chelsea taking the free-kick in our half was wrong and, frankly, ridiculous because "you can't be offside in your own half". Then the qualified ref who sits behind me explained that the rule had changed, in that the free-kick is taken at the point the player became active and played the ball. So, Murray was in an offside position in the Chelsea half, but only became active when he headed the ball, by which point he'd returned to our half. As such, that is where the free-kick was correctly taken from.
It's something that doesn't happen very often, which is why so many of us didn't know about it.
And I bet Dermot Gallagher will rip them to shreds on Ref Watch this morning!
Yes, you're right, I'm dreaming!
Sussex Nomad
Well-known member
Oh good God, where have I said he was in our half?
Sussex Nomad
Well-known member
Elbow in the face needs a replay 5 yards from the lino?
Stato
Well-known member
- Dec 21, 2011
- 7,367
Corrected for you to explain the valid complaints people have made about yesterday and about PL referees' general star-struck approach to any game involving top six opposition.
Summed up for me a few years back in our Carling Cup game against Liverpool, when it was said that Michael Oliver spent the whole game addressing our players by the numbers on their back whilst using the Liverpool players' first names and nicknames.
AFC Bournemouth v Brighton
Referee: Mike Dean
Assistants: Darren Cann, Dan Robathan
Fourth official: Graham Scott
Referee: Mike Dean
Assistants: Darren Cann, Dan Robathan
Fourth official: Graham Scott
Attention seeker. Once upon a time they had tape instead of a crossbar. Once upon a time you didn't have substitutes. Things move on.
Sussex Nomad
Well-known member
I tend to agree, despite the above trolling... never seen it before, and to be fair neither had 28,000 Brighton fans at the time of the free kick.
BensGrandad
New member
It is not it is the new offside rule brought in this year. If as happened a player moves from an offside position the offence is committed when he plays the ball so as in this case GM played it in our half after being in an offside position so it was a correct decision. A player still cannot be offside in his own half only after moving from an offside position in the opponents half. or if every Chelsea player bar the keeper had been on the edge of our box and GM in the centre circle in our half he still wouldn't be offside
Last edited:
Sussex Nomad
Well-known member
That is fine BG, I think that has already been covered. But for those of us that don't read up the laws of football - all of us - then we see it differently. At the time yesterday, 28k wondered wtf was going on. Me, on my live stream was the same. So, Attwell got one decision correct, big deal. Alonso was offside for their first goal, why wasn't it flagged?
Yep, I was right - Dermot 'the-ref-is-always-perfect' Gallagher cleared Attwell of everything. March didn't have the ball when he was pulled down, 'might' not have got it and 'might' not have scored, so not a red.......Knocky wasn't sufficiently in an attacking position to warrant a yellow card for pulling him down........
Sigh..............
Nathan
Well-known member
- Jan 8, 2010
- 3,788
Did they mention the offside for the first goal?
I'll give you three guesses..............!
Are you paraphrasing, or did he really say 'might not have scored'? Obviously he might not have. It's a goal scoring opportunity, not actually a goal.
Was he just pulled a bit, and not hit at all then?
Paraphrasing, slightly wrongly, sorry - went back to check - 'would he (March) have gained possession of the ball, and that's the grey area....... He has to be positive........'
Mind you, unless he tripped over his own shoelaces or something, I can't see how March could not have got that ball!
The elbow in the face was not discussed, just the pull back in our penalty area.
Last edited:
Arthur
Well-known member
Was that when Knocky was pulled back in our box mid way through the second half??
If so is that the law? A cynical foul is only a booking when in an attacking position??