Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Stone Roses to reform
- Thread starter Stinky Pete
- Start date
Arthur
Well-known member
Two points....
Firstly this rumor does the round about every six months. Every time it gets pooh poohed by one of the band members. Basically I'll be very surprised if it happens. That said money makes the world go round so who knows?
Secondly the whole "Ian Brown can't sing argument" is f***ing tedious! No one is going to disagree with that fact! But show me someone who has a better stage presence and I'm sure whoever that person is will be worth seeing! For that reason he's worth seeing. If you don't like Brown or the Roses then why bang on about it? One can only assume it's the case of "look at me I was at Spike Island" oneupmanship?
Firstly this rumor does the round about every six months. Every time it gets pooh poohed by one of the band members. Basically I'll be very surprised if it happens. That said money makes the world go round so who knows?
Secondly the whole "Ian Brown can't sing argument" is f***ing tedious! No one is going to disagree with that fact! But show me someone who has a better stage presence and I'm sure whoever that person is will be worth seeing! For that reason he's worth seeing. If you don't like Brown or the Roses then why bang on about it? One can only assume it's the case of "look at me I was at Spike Island" oneupmanship?
Indeed.
Although, it's nothing special is it - having been at Spike Island? After all, it seems like about 50,000 people were there...
Last edited:
MattBackHome
Well-known member
- Jul 7, 2003
- 11,867
Good f***ing chip shop that.
Pevenseagull
meh
- Jul 20, 2003
- 20,654
I love the FACT that this thread is more interested in where Nick Cave buys his chips than the prospect of seeing The Stone Roses go creme brulee, horribly overrated band.
Don't get me wrong, not proper shite, just not THAT good (by which I don't mean Take That)
Don't get me wrong, not proper shite, just not THAT good (by which I don't mean Take That)
What about where he buys his bagels?
Pevenseagull
meh
- Jul 20, 2003
- 20,654
Bagels from the man, chips from the basket
you know it makes sense
you know it makes sense
Albumen
Don't wait for me!
Whats the point? Genius album that will never be played well live as the lead can't sing live for toffee.
Albumen
Don't wait for me!
John Squire's artwork:
So I doubt it's going to happen.
ha. I bet he was drunk.
swiss tony
Member
For me it is SO important that this DOESN´T happen. I was 16 when the album came out, saw them in Leeds on the Second Coming and loved everything about them.
Post Roses, the Shirehorses were shit, Browny has released some decent stuff but its been dimishing returns. A reunion would undoubtedly represent an anal raping of their reputation. Please, please, DON´T do it.
There's only one other group which would represent more of a disaster if the did a reunion tour.......................THE SMITHS.
Post Roses, the Shirehorses were shit, Browny has released some decent stuff but its been dimishing returns. A reunion would undoubtedly represent an anal raping of their reputation. Please, please, DON´T do it.
There's only one other group which would represent more of a disaster if the did a reunion tour.......................THE SMITHS.
Vegas Seagull
New member
- Jul 10, 2009
- 7,782
Morrissey already does this, didn't you know?
kalinski
Well-known member
I passed up the opportunity to go to Stone Roses' concert at Spike Island #popularculturefail!
Sent from my HTC Desire S using Tapatalk
Sent from my HTC Desire S using Tapatalk
alan partridge
Active member
Agree with this. Although I never went to see them I remember the time very well. Also remember the first time I listened to their first album, whilst snogging my new girlfriend. Happy teenage days.
Dr. Notthenineo'clocknews
Remainer
Mark n Lard.....wasn't it? as for The Seahorses I was lucky enough to see them in Portsmouth, great show and it snowed hard that night, really enjoyed them. I'm at a certain age now where I can't be bothered with the merits of where and why, i hope it happens and I hope I get a ticket, Manchester will be perfect, i'll have a few beers with the lads, a bit of a laugh, a sing up and try not to over think the situation
Arthur
Well-known member
Glad someone else noticed that. Shirehorses now were talking!! Sadly though there is about as much chance as them getting back together as the Roses.
Weeeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssttt Country Boy!
n1 gull
Well-known member
I hate it when bands reform, I don't understand it (apart from them making money).
I'm a huge Smiths fan, but the thought of them getting back together makes me feel ill.
Leave it well alone. Its been done. Why anyone would want to be surrounded by fat 40+ balding blokes,
dancing badly, talking about back in the day... is beyond me
I'm a huge Smiths fan, but the thought of them getting back together makes me feel ill.
Leave it well alone. Its been done. Why anyone would want to be surrounded by fat 40+ balding blokes,
dancing badly, talking about back in the day... is beyond me
Arthur
Well-known member
Me and the wife did as well. What a gig that was eh? We stood a foot from the band the entire evening. Frau Tubthumper has never been the same since Cave placed his hand on her head and sang to her. I've done the similar, but it does not seem to have the same effect on the missus.
TheBlueAndWhiteStrips
Active member
I figured I wouldn't be alone in my feelings of disinterest. After everything Ian Brown has said about never reforming, to go back on that feels like a cynical ploy to make themselves some cash. And it aint the Roses without Reni on Drums.