brighton_tom
Well-known member
- Jul 23, 2008
- 5,525
He's part of a team that is currently 3rd in the Premier League. So he's fine by me. & apart from scoring goals I think his general play has been decent over these first 4 games.
[Albion] Solly March, local lad and Premier League star, is f***ing brilliant
- Thread starter Husty
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Are you saying he's not good enough for the PL, or simply that at our level (let's say 9th from last season) he's simply average, rather than good?
BN41Albion
Well-known member
- Oct 1, 2017
- 6,830
If GP trusts him that's good enough for me.
But I didn't come here for a lecture in communism.
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
It’s alright defending the missed opportunities that seem to regularly fall his way when we win, the problem is when we need a goal to win a game or get back in a game are constantly being squandered. Unfortunately the keeper is like a magnet for March.
The Wizard
Well-known member
- Jul 2, 2009
- 18,401
What an idiotic thread.
Part of a unit that’s got 10 points out of 12, he’s also been part of a team that hasn’t conceded from open play, he contributes a lot defensively as well. I look at our starting line up at the moment as a unit rather than individuals.
Trossard was equally as wasteful if not more than March yesterday yet no thread on him
Funny how there always has to be someone to moan about even when we are unbeaten and joint second in the league, very strange some of our fans.
Part of a unit that’s got 10 points out of 12, he’s also been part of a team that hasn’t conceded from open play, he contributes a lot defensively as well. I look at our starting line up at the moment as a unit rather than individuals.
Trossard was equally as wasteful if not more than March yesterday yet no thread on him
Funny how there always has to be someone to moan about even when we are unbeaten and joint second in the league, very strange some of our fans.
Ha! There’s a big chunk of that list that have been perma banned now.
As for this thread? Well, I can actually see the point being made but while we are wiping the smiles off the faces of some of the PL’s most self satisfied fans, the team can carry on and Potter can keep working his magic.
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
Is it idiotic though? He’s flapped at two great chances like a school boy. Trossard gets numbers so mentioning him is kind of irrelevant when discussing March. If we can’t discuss players on here then what’s the pointWhat an idiotic thread.
Part of a unit that’s got 10 points out of 12, he’s also been part of a team that hasn’t conceded from open play, he contributes a lot defensively as well. I look at our starting line up at the moment as a unit rather than individuals.
Trossard was equally as wasteful if not more than March yesterday yet no thread on him
Funny how there always has to be someone to moan about even when we are unbeaten and joint second in the league, very strange some of our fans.
Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
Is it idiotic though? He’s flapped at two great chances like a school boy. Trossard gets numbers so mentioning him is kind of irrelevant when discussing March. If we can’t discuss players on here then what’s the point
Why not start it as a discussion rather than giving a ridiculous statement. That is the idiotic part, not a reasonable discussion about Solly needing to improve his end product. Not sure the OP wanted a discussion at all.
I think it’s a fair call to ask the question regardless of league position. We all want the team to be the best and definitely improve all the time. Siolly is a solid player but probably our weakest link. He works hard and rarely has a mare of a game. His finishing and dead ball kicks are not the best. He does miss a lot of really good opportunities tbf.
His name never crops up in transfer rumours, but GP obviously believes in him.
I don’t think he ever puts fans on the edge of their seats does he?
I like his attitude. He has something, but rarely an end of product in his play.
His name never crops up in transfer rumours, but GP obviously believes in him.
I don’t think he ever puts fans on the edge of their seats does he?
I like his attitude. He has something, but rarely an end of product in his play.
SULLY COULDNT SHOOT
Loyal2Family+Albion!
Agree with the first two disagree with the last. He is a better right wing back than Lamptey because he hardly ever gets caught upfield. When Lamptey played lasts eason it seemed to be that Potter thought he needed Veltman behind. Seems more confident of Solly. I suspect Tariq will play when we can go all out and attack but when we need to be a bit clever with our wing backs it'll be March.
macbeth
Dismembered
okay here's the discussion then. agree the OP started the thread in an idiotic way, but there's definitely a discussion to be had, even if we've won. march does a lot of things brilliantly. defensively excellent, always gives 100% and never goes missing.
but if we had a right sided played who could finish semi-decently (and contrary to popular belief these do exist outside the top six) then we'd have had a field day. we killed them two or three times with that through ball yesterday, when march went one on one I didn't even bother standing up as I already knew the outcome. not saying he should be dropped or sold, but in terms of where the squad is right now, he's one of the worst finishers going, second maybe only to lallana, and if we're looking at areas to eventually improve the squad, he either needs to finish more convincingly, because he does have the technical ability to finish well, or eventually he'll be upgraded on.
imagine if we hadn't won yesterday. he'd have been crucified on here, and actually probably crucified by a lot of posters who've already rubbished the need for a discussion on this thread.
Last edited:
I agree. March is a great player for us and his contribution to our current success is clearly evident. However, his finishing is very poor - unfortunately it always has been. It's a bit of a mystery as he has a cracking shot but he lacks the coolness in front of goal to pick out a corner or even work the keeper. Maybe its something that cannot be coached and he will remain a frustration in this respect of his game. If he cant improve on it then the Club will need to look for an upgrade in his position.
macbeth
Dismembered
yep. I also don't buy this 'if he could finish he wouldn't be playing for us' line. okay, if he was getting 10+ goals a season then probably not, but it's at the point now where he's missing one or two sitters every game. that's not 'he misses sometimes, like all players do', that's abysmal. same reason why I don't understand people bringing trossard into this discussion. leo is probably our second best chance of a goal at the minute, and everything good we do generally goes through him. solly can play the defensive role well, but ultimately the way we play means that he finds himself in these goalscoring positions at least once a game, and it's almost guaranteed that he won't come close to finishing convincingly. as I said, great player and great character to have around, but if you're challenging towards the business end of the table that isn't enough on its own to be a starter.
Deleted member 37369
Well-known member
- Aug 21, 2018
- 1,994
tigertim68
Well-known member
- Sep 3, 2012
- 2,625
Webster is not a forward , March is meant to be able to score and create goals being an attacking midfield player, but he does neither , if Webster scores it’s a bonus ,
dejavuatbtn
Well-known member
Interesting that the best coach in the country is happy to put his name down first on the team sheet. Potter recognises what he’s contributing to the master plan, even if some of us don’t.
He’s not a striker, using your logic his goals are also a bonus.