[Albion] Recall Duffy ?

[Cowfold Seagull]

Well ? Would you recall Duffy ?

IMO he's a better defender than Webster and at set pieces more likely to score.

No.

As much as l love the big Irish Republican, he doesn't fit into Potter's style of play, so no point.

 

[Pavilionaire]

No. Shane Duffy isn’t a premier league defender. Hence he is playing in a league 1 standard league.

That is unfair. For three seasons he was good in the Prem and brought the best out of Dunk. Our biggest aerial threat at corners, a warrior.

Yes, he was never the best passer and this year his form has dipped but he is an Albion legend.

 

[neilbard]

Just waiting for “recall Hughton”

Hughton wouldn't even consider coming back to us, treated poorly in my opinion sacked by Bloom.

Bloom didn't even sack Hyypiä and he was shite.

 

[Cowfold Seagull]

Just waiting for “recall Hughton”

Well if you recall Duffy, you might as well recall Hughton too.

 

[WATFORD zero]

All day long better threat than Webster


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

With the ball at his feet I couldn't agree more. Unfortunately to us, not for us

 

[drew]

Hughton wouldn't even consider coming back to us, treated poorly in my opinion sacked by Bloom.

Bloom didn't even sack Hyypiä and he was shite.

Hyypia knew when to go, Hughton didn't. It would have looked better all round if it had been a mutual separation but the end result was the same.

 

[neilbard]

No thanks, hardly fits in with our style of play

Yeah I get what your saying, Duffy 8 goals absolute under achiever as a centre back, useless prick.

Whereas Bissouma has netted a whopping 2 goals, attacking midfield.

 

[drew]

Less than Shane did the previous season.

Duffy 8 in 123 games and Webster 3 in 44. In reality, there's not much difference in the scoring ratio

 

[neilbard]

Hyypia knew when to go, Hughton didn't. It would have looked better all round if it had been a mutual separation but the end result was the same.

He still wouldn't even think about coming back if we were in the mire...

 

[drew]

Yeah I get what your saying, Duffy 8 goals absolute under achiever as a centre back, useless prick.

Whereas Bissouma has netted a whopping 2 goals, attacking midfield.

Yet Bissouma is being touted with top clubs but Duffy ended up on loan in a minor league!

Duffy did a job as an old fashioned centre half stopper. We all know he isn't a ball playing defender and that's the style we are playing now.

 

[drew]

He still wouldn't even think about coming back if we were in the mire...

Never said he would and I doubt very much we would ever ask him, at least not whilst we are in the Premier League and even then I can't see Bloom ever going back to Hughton.

 

[Da Man Clay]

Duffy 8 in 123 games and Webster 3 in 44. In reality, there's not much difference in the scoring ratio

6 in 91 PL games compared to 3 in 44. Webster has a better goals to game ratio in the PL than Duffy did.

 

[drew]

6 in 91 PL games compared to 3 in 44. Webster has a better goals to game ratio in the PL than Duffy did.

Good point. I included all games.

 

[neilbard]

Yet Bissouma is being touted with top clubs but Duffy ended up on loan in a minor league!

Duffy did a job as an old fashioned centre half stopper. We all know he isn't a ball playing defender and that's the style we are playing now.

Agreed Duffy did a job, old school, Bissouma may well be touted with top clubs so was Dunk.

 

[Cowfold Seagull]

No. Shane Duffy isn’t a premier league defender. Hence he is playing in a league 1 standard league.

Harsh in the absolute extreme, l can think of a few Premier League teams that he would fit into, and in our first season in this league l remember that the Dunk n Duffy combo was being talked about by some, as one of the best central defensive pairings in the country. They complimented each other so well.

Facts are facts though,l and potter ball just doesn't suit Shane's talents.

 

[Beach Hut]

Yeah I get what your saying, Duffy 8 goals absolute under achiever as a centre back, useless prick.

Whereas Bissouma has netted a whopping 2 goals, attacking midfield.

Duffy is clueless passing the ball out of defence

 

[Da Man Clay]

That is unfair. For three seasons he was good in the Prem and brought the best out of Dunk. Our biggest aerial threat at corners, a warrior.

Yes, he was never the best passer and this year his form has dipped but he is an Albion legend.

Yes possibly a touch harsh. He was excellent for us under Hughton but It had become apparent we had moved beyond what he had to offer which is pretty limited for a PL defender. He would have suited someone like West Brom though and could have gone to a better level than Celtic.

 

[Surf's Up]

I think Duffy's absence has had a negative impact on Dunk's game but he's not a Potter player so he won't be back and Potter will have to find another way to help Dunk get his form back.

 

[bluenitsuj]

Of course not. How stupid would that be

 

[neilbard]

I think Duffy's absence has had a negative impact on Dunk's game but he's not a Potter player so he won't be back and Potter will have to find another way to help Dunk get his form back.

This.....