[Albion] Player ratings vs them lot

[jcdenton08]

Sanchez - 3 - such is the life of a keeper. One dreadful mistake cost us the win unfortunately.

Veltman - 6
Dunk - 6
Webster - 7
Estupinan - 8
Caicedo - 5
Groß - 5
March - 8
MacAllister - 6
Mitoma - 4
Undav - 4
Ferguson - 5
Lamptey - 6

 

[lasvegan]

Sanchez - 3 - such is the life of a keeper. One dreadful mistake cost us the win unfortunately.

Veltman - 6
Dunk - 6
Webster - 7
Estupinan - 8
Caicedo - 5
Groß - 5
March - 8
MacAllister - 6
Mitoma - 4
Undav - 4
Ferguson - 5
Lamptey - 6

4’s and 5’s, really?

 

[jcdenton08]

4’s and 5’s, really?

Yeah, I thought the players I rated low didn’t have good games, hence the marks.

 

[lasvegan]

Didn’t think they had shockers, though

 

[Nobby]

Sanchez - 3 - such is the life of a keeper. One dreadful mistake cost us the win unfortunately.

Veltman - 6
Dunk - 6
Webster - 7
Estupinan - 8
Caicedo - 5
Groß - 5
March - 8
MacAllister - 6
Mitoma - 4
Undav - 4
Ferguson - 5
Lamptey - 6

Well that and the twat who can’t work out where to draw a line

 

[maltaseagull]

4’s and 5’s, really?

If we were so poor, how did we totally dominate them?

 

[jcdenton08]

If we were so poor, how did we totally dominate them?

They were worse

 

[Johnny RoastBeef]

Sanchez - 3 - such is the life of a keeper. One dreadful mistake cost us the win unfortunately.

Veltman - 6
Dunk - 6
Webster - 7
Estupinan - 8
Caicedo - 5
Groß - 5
March - 8
MacAllister - 6
Mitoma - 4
Undav - 4
Ferguson - 5
Lamptey - 6

A bit harsh. Would you have given those marks if VAR hadn't made that error?

 

[jcdenton08]

A bit harsh. Would you have given those marks if VAR hadn't made that error?

I would - if we had sneaked it 0-1 I felt the same. I thought our best performers were superb (March and Pervis) but as good as they were, Mitoma and Undav were bad on the day. Caicedo looked off the pace quite literally from the first minute, MacAllister was rattled by the occasion unfortunately. Arguably lucky to stay on the field.

So yeah, overall the good performances were the centre of everything and the bad performances prevented us (along with VAR and one dreadful mistake) from winning the game.

 

[Machiavelli]

There are a heap of ungenerous ratings on this thread. We battered them. Three things prevented us from winning the game (which would have prompted higher ratings):
-- the Sanchez howler
-- finishing, especially from Mac Allister
-- a howler so bad that its perpetrator(s) shouldn't be able to feature in the PL again

Sanchez 4 -- decent with his feet, -3 for the howler
Veltman 6
Webster 7 -- looked pretty much back to his best, a couple of great blocks, carried the ball forward well, passing mostly good but gave it away a few times. Don't think it was a foul on Mateta that led to their goal-scoring free kick
Dunk 6.5 -- solid enough, nothing more
Estupinan 9 -- stunning performance, that cross for the goal was something else. In a delightful run of form
Caicedo 6.5 -- lots of people slating him, no idea why
Gross 7 -- intelligent and industrious as ever
March 9.5 MotM -- what a player, what a performance
Mac Allister 5 -- could have seen red early (I think it was a yellow/orange, there was no force), but his finishing was way, way short of what he can do. Still he got into those positions.
Mitoma 5 -- somewhat shackled
Undav 5.5 -- decent enough linking

Subs:
Ferguson 5.5
Lamptey 6

 

[dazzer6666]

There are a heap of ungenerous ratings on this thread. We battered them. Three things prevented us from winning the game (which would have prompted higher ratings):
-- the Sanchez howler
-- finishing, especially from Mac Allister
-- a howler so bad that its perpetrator(s) shouldn't be able to feature in the PL again

Sanchez 4 -- decent with his feet, -3 for the howler
Veltman 6
Webster 7 -- looked pretty much back to his best, a couple of great blocks, carried the ball forward well, passing mostly good but gave it away a few times. Don't think it was a foul on Mateta that led to their goal-scoring free kick
Dunk 6.5 -- solid enough, nothing more
Estupinan 9 -- stunning performance, that cross for the goal was something else. In a delightful run of form
Caicedo 6.5 -- lots of people slating him, no idea why
Gross 7 -- intelligent and industrious as ever
March 9.5 MotM -- what a player, what a performance
Mac Allister 5 -- could have seen red early (I think it was a yellow/orange, there was no force), but his finishing was way, way short of what he can do. Still he got into those positions.
Mitoma 5 -- somewhat shackled
Undav 5.5 -- decent enough linking

Subs:
Ferguson 5.5
Lamptey 6

Nailed it

 

[US Seagull]

It's on the extended highlights on the club site.

Studs up, but no real force, pulls away immediately after contact

Some Palace fan on twitter described it as a leg breaker.
It isn't.

Palace fans have very weak legs. Not enough calcium in their diets don't you know?

 

[SanchoMitoma]

Apart from last 5 mins against Bournmouth that is 2 games running Mitoma has been marked out of game

He was mostly marked out by Estupinan… thankful for Pervis’s assist but he was trying so hard the other day, always dribbling, or taking the extra touch and it killed all the potential passes and best sets-up for Mitoma. I think they work very well individually but they don’t really benefit each other, I prefer the way March and his RB coexist, it allows March to really dedicate himself to the attack.

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

There are a heap of ungenerous ratings on this thread. We battered them. Three things prevented us from winning the game (which would have prompted higher ratings):
-- the Sanchez howler
-- finishing, especially from Mac Allister
-- a howler so bad that its perpetrator(s) shouldn't be able to feature in the PL again

Sanchez 4 -- decent with his feet, -3 for the howler
Veltman 6
Webster 7 -- looked pretty much back to his best, a couple of great blocks, carried the ball forward well, passing mostly good but gave it away a few times. Don't think it was a foul on Mateta that led to their goal-scoring free kick
Dunk 6.5 -- solid enough, nothing more
Estupinan 9 -- stunning performance, that cross for the goal was something else. In a delightful run of form
Caicedo 6.5 -- lots of people slating him, no idea why
Gross 7 -- intelligent and industrious as ever
March 9.5 MotM -- what a player, what a performance
Mac Allister 5 -- could have seen red early (I think it was a yellow/orange, there was no force), but his finishing was way, way short of what he can do. Still he got into those positions.
Mitoma 5 -- somewhat shackled
Undav 5.5 -- decent enough linking

Subs:
Ferguson 5.5
Lamptey 6

Would give Estupinan and Webster 8’s, otherwise nailed it for me

 

[raymondo]

Apart from last 5 mins against Bournmouth that is 2 games running Mitoma has been marked out of game

It's going to happen...but if it takes two to mark him out of the game, his colleagues need to take advantage of the space afforded them

 

[Uh_huh_him]

It's going to happen...but if it takes two to mark him out of the game, his colleagues need to take advantage of the space afforded them

I think in general they do.
Estupinan and March both had blinders. MacAllister had 4 or 5 shots on goal.

I think in hindsight, It would have been better to play Ferguson, but Undav was my pick before the game.

 

[el punal]

Can’t be arsed to do the whole team, still massively pissed off we’ve gifted that pile of shit a point again.

Sanchez: 1
March: 10

A bit like the Palace fans reaction to last season’s Maupay’s equaliser in stoppage time. Swings and roundabouts and all that shit. We move on, as in onwards and upwards.

 

[schmunk]