[Albion] Player Ratings v BMuff

[mccraque]

Well someone had to...

Ryan - 3

Montoya - anonymous 2

Dunk and Duffy- ffs 0

Bernardo- offered more than some 4

Stephens-. Gash 1

Propper - whats happened? 2

Bissouma- for all his skill, such a wasteful player 2

Andone and locadia -1 between them. They’re not strikers

Knockers. Ran around for a while and tried a few things. They didn’t come off so the usual happened. 1

Muzza- not as bad.

Jose - anonymous.


No movement. No idea. Sorry chris... that was the worst performance I remember

 

[Eeyore]

Players don't suddenly become rubbish.

 

[BNthree]

Bit generous to Ryan if you ask me.

 

[flint]

Can’t argue with players marks
Dunk has to be dropped and likewise Stephens

 

[Mayonaise]

Ryan - 5

Montoya - 5

Dunk and Duffy- 5

Bernardo- offered more than some 7 MOM for me

Stephens-. Gash 3 slow tracking back and wasteful with the ball

Propper - 5

Bissouma- good moments but decision making and keeping the ball poor 5

Andone - 4 I am an Andone fan but he was poor today

Locadia -5

Knockers 3 lots of effort but let himself and us down again FFS

Muzza- 6

Jose - 5

Chris - 5 has so few options when we need to change it

Feels like all that good will built last week at wembley has disappeared down the toilet!

 

[Sarisbury Seagull]

Ryan - 2

Montoya - 3
Dunk - 1
Duffy - 3
Bernardo - 5

Stephens - 1
Propper - 2
Bissouma - 4

Knockaert - 1
Andone - 2
Locadia - 2

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

6 - average

Ryan - 5
Montoya - 3 - poor in so many ways
Bernardo - 5 - Bambi on ice at times
Dunk - 4 - poorest performance since he turned pro
Duffy - 4
Knockaert - 4 - moronic challenge
Bissouma - 5 - kept running but mainly in circles
Stephens - 3 - worst performance since he signed
Propper - 3 - see Stephens
Locadia - 4 - tried but failed, not a winger
Andone - 3 - no touch

Murray - 5 - felt he offered something, but don’t know what it was....
Izquierdo - 3 - WTF was that.

Hughton - has to be 3.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[SollysLeftFoot]

How you can rate anyone based on that?

 

[Weststander]

Ryan - 4
Montoya - 1 repeatedly left Duffy facing 2 on 1. A shocking lack of awareness of that.
Duffy - 3 Teetering giant outclassed by a mobile front line.
Dunk - 2 ditto, with some terrible mistakes.
Bernardo - 2 He caught Montoya’s disease
Stephens 4
Bissouma 4 Started brightly, then became a specialist in giving the ball away.
Propper 1 Outclassed, immobile, no pace, cringeworthy passing.
Locadia 1 Obsessed with showing that he lifts bigger weights that Bmuff’s RB and RW, outclassed.
Knockaert 3 Tried, drove forward, but selfish, didn’t support Montoya.
Andone 1 Simply didn’t turn up.

Muzza 3 He entered the pitch, then the team decided not to cross any more.
Izzy 1 The game passed him by, last season he was a good PL player.

 

[Blue3]

Bit generous to Ryan if you ask me.

To be fair he did collect the ball out of the net with some style five times

 

[aolstudios]

Ryan - 5

Montoya - 5

Dunk and Duffy- 5

Bernardo- offered more than some 7 MOM for me

Stephens-. Gash 3 slow tracking back and wasteful with the ball

Propper - 5

Bissouma- good moments but decision making and keeping the ball poor 5

Andone - 4 I am an Andone fan but he was poor today

Locadia -5

Knockers 3 lots of effort but let himself and us down again FFS

Muzza- 6

Jose - 5

Chris - 5 has so few options when we need to change it

Feels like all that good will built last week at wembley has disappeared down the toilet!

About right, sadly

 

[seagull_special]

Ryan - 5 OK first half but absolutely no command of the goal area

Montoya - 4 slow and ineffective

Duffy - 4 an awful day in an outstanding season

Dunk - 5 struggled today and threw himself around hopelessly, tried a couple of defense splitting passes which didn’t quite come off

Bernardo - 6 MOM constantly tried to make things happen and one of the only players with a modicum of composures

Stephens - 4 when he plays badly we lose unfortunately too many sub par performances this season. Slow and negative today

Propper - 4 a player I want to se succeed but he has not lived up to his promise

Bissouma - 5 has been the highlight of a dull dull season, he is going to be a stunning player, fear it won’t be with us

Locadia - 3 such a huge disappointment, never looked like he was going to make any contribution to the game

Andone - 4 anonymous and looked like a 5 million pound striker

AK - 3 pathetic sending off, just does not have mentality to be a top PL Player as much as we want it

Izquierdo - 3 no impact a shadow of himself

Murray - 4 never in the game but at least had a presence

CH - 3 you could see him fuming from the first 5 minutes. Nothing worked today

Ref - probably best ref around

Crowd - deserved so much more.

 

[Milano]

Ridiculously knee jerk.
6 average

Ryan - 5. Didn’t do much wrong and kicking was better today, when was the last time he made a ‘dig us out’ save though?
Montoya - 6. I thought he was decent in spells, most good came down our right.
Duffy - 4. Totally at fault for the first goal, awful game. Limitations are being exposed.
Dunk - 5. Will be gutted. Actually played OK until that last 20 minutes.
Bernardo - 4. Good player, terrible game. I’d be tempted to play Bong Tuesday.
Stephens - 3. Lost all confidence with the ball, suddenly can’t seem to tackle. Actually improved slightly when Propper went off and we went to a 4.
Propper - 1. SHIT. Stunk the place out. Rightly subbed.
Bissouma - 6. The ONLY one looking to drive forward, if people can’t see the potential here they’re watching the wrong sport.
AK - 0. Goodbye.
Locadia - 3. I fear we’ve done our money. Play him as a number 9 or not at all. Why didn’t he shoot when he passed to Murray?
Andone - 4. Starting to think he is actually more affective as an impact sub. I think he’s a number 10 in a 4-4-2. Was subbed to stop him getting sent off, the irony.

Murray - 5. Did OK, so slow to react to that half chance though.
Izzy - 4. Did nothing, looks rusty which is understandable.

Hughton - 2. The formation doesn’t work, we don’t have the players for it. Einstein’s theory of insanity is doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different outcome. A large section of our crowd turned today, I fear this won’t end well which is very sad.

The crowd - 10. At last we told the team (and manager) what we felt. A result like this has been brewing for months and we’ve been letting them off easy IMO.

 

[twickers]

If Andone and Locadia can operate the contactless paymemt device then that could be two less cash only queues at half time...with coaching they could do cash too.

 

[rusty redeyes]

How you can rate anyone based on that?

I wholeheartedly agree

 

[portslade seagull]

How any can get more than a 2 surprises me. CH minus 10

 

[Not Andy Naylor]

Ryan 5. Made one save.
Montoya 4. Looks okay on the ball but playing for Barcelona and Valencia doesn't prepare you for being under the sort of pressure we put ourselves under.
Duffy and Dunk both 6. Not their best day but still throwing themselves in the way of everything when others had thrown in the towel.
Bernardo 6. Being dragged down to the others' level.
Knockaert 3. All passion, no brain. Has forgotten how to cross and is a disciplinary liability.
Bissouma 4. Love him, but we won't stay up if he stays in the team.
Stephens 5. Often had nobody to pass to.
Propper.0. Skill but no heart. We need people to fight and run the extra yard.
Locadia 3. Got into good positions but when it became obvious nobody had seen his runs he needed to go looking for the ball.
Andone 3. Isolated but maybe needs to stew on the bench and get annoyed because he isn't starting then have some impact as a sub.

Subs: Murray 4. Showed as a target but what can he do on his own?
Izquierdo 3. Not the player he was. If he ever was.

.

 

[PILTDOWN MAN]

Ryan 0. Didn’t make a save and his kicking is sooo shit. What the **** is this sideways foot kicking, floating it to just about halfway

Defence 0 ****ing awful

Midfield 0 Stephens feigning injury was a disgrace. I want winners not shirkers. Propper has been awful for ages doesn’t tackle, doesn’t run, can’t head the ball. Then there’s headless running about in no particular direction.

Forwards 0 oh I can’t be arsed....just ****ing spend you’re wages in Brighton at least then you’re giving something back to Brighton.

Hughton dreadful soulless tactics.

 

[portslade seagull]

With the poor scores for Propper maybe his head has been turned at the supposed interest from Ajax

 

[Seagull1989]

Ryan -1- not only letting in 5 but his distribution is terrible
Montoya -1- Get Bruno back for the run in - we need a leader
Duffy -1- spent most the game on his arse having had the B’mouth players run rings around him
Dunk -1- see Duffy
Bernardo -1- how many times did he slip over
Stephens -5- scapegoated today the boos before half time when he played it backwards when he didn’t have any other options, were unwarranted. Just to add I’m not a Stephens fan
Propper -2- I don’t know what he brings to the team
Bissouma -6- showed some urgency
AK -2- gave the ball away for their 2nd. Didn’t see sending off, would like to say he showed some passion but it seems like it was a terrible tackle
Locadia -1- Always looks so wooden
Andone -1- did literally nothing

Murray -5- did more than Andone
Izqueirdo -4- only just game on when AK saw red. Then had to adapt his game