Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Player Ratings: Brighton v Luton







Gwylan

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
31,827
Uffern
Roberts 7
Hinshelwood 7
Mayo 6
Butters 7
Pethick 6
Hart 7
Carpenter 7
Oatway 8
Jones 7
Henderson 7
Knight 6

subs
Mcphee 6
Piercy 7
 


isabellas father

New member
Jul 25, 2003
163
Shepherds bush
I actually thought that henderson had his best game so far, and seems to be gaining match fitness. He wants another month and I think that is what we should give him. Hinshlewood was a revelation at right back and Mr Oatway was definitely MOM
 


Bald Gull

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
1,523
London
Roberts 8
Pethick 6
Butters 8
Hinshelwood 8
Mayo 7
Hart 6
Carpenter 7
Jones 7
Oatway 8
Henderson 8
Knight 6

subs
Mcphee 6
Piercy 7
 


Seagullible

Super Keeper
Jul 7, 2003
5,749
Tea room, The Office, Slough
Roberts 8 - Assured performance, Held every cross and swept well if the ball cam over the top

Hinshelwood 6 - Looked a little out of place and tended to be sucked into the centre but did nothing wrong

Pethic 7 - Can't remember missing a header all day. Solid display

Butters 7 - Missed a few headers but was solid and read the game well cutting out through balls. Passed the ball well.

Mayo 6 - Nothing special, did his job as needed.

Oatway 8 (MOM) - worked tirelessly battling away in midfield and kept the spirit up. Needs to get over his short corner fettish but capped a great display with a slightly lucky goal.

Carpenter 6 - Below par performance giving the ball away too much.

Hart 7 - Worked hard and gave options on the right but didn't have the luck.

Jones 7 - Showed some great tricks and worked hard

Henderson 6 - Seemed to get involved when he wanted to. Shows he is capable but played too many hospital balls.

Knight 7 - busy performance and got little help from the ref. Looked to shoot whenever a half chance showed itself.

subs McPhee 6 - Never really got into the game though was unlucky to be tackled by Newell.

Piercy 6 - never really had time to get into the game though showed a couple of nice touches
 




dunno

Old Skool
Jul 6, 2003
1,588
At work - probably
Roberts 7 - assured although scared the hell out of me when he went on his Barthez run. No shots to save really
Hinsh 8 - looked v.good a rightback IMHO
Mayo 6 - not one of his best games - went missing in the second half
Butters 8 - looked good and strong - good distribution
Pethick 8- makes a great sweeper
Harty 7 - Great first half ran his socks off
Carpenter 7 - first half great - went missing in the second
Oatway 8 - purely for his all-action first half - tired in the second half though
Jones 8 - great tricks a good running - obviously trying to impress before his ban!!
Henderson 7 - good tracking back when needed holds the ball up well - but it was a good job the defender but the ball in the net 'cos his feeble shot was going miles from goal!
Knight 7 - not his best game for the Albion and he still gets a 7 - unlucky with the header - showed great skill for Charlie's goal - never stopped trying
Subs: Piercy 7 - good passing - not on long enough to see what he can do
McPhee 7 - couple of miss-controls but then got into the game
 


Uncle Spielberg

Well-known member
Jul 6, 2003
43,095
Lancing
Roberts 8 - classy and too good for div 2
Hinshelwood 7 - solid
Mayo 7 - reliable
Butters 8 - fair play had a great game and is not fat
Pethick 6 - few errors and misplaced passes
Hart 7 - good in 1st but dissapeared in 2nd
Carpenter 8 - too good for div 2
Oatway 8 - battling performance
Jones 7 - inconsistant but piece of skill in 2nd half gets extra point
Henderson 7 - best game yet for us
Knight 5 - have to agree with Mrs G - he was rubbish today, our worst player
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here