Player of the Season... So Far...

[Munkfish]

for me it is a really tough choice between.

-Noone
-Dunk
-CMS
-Greer

But out of those four I would give it to Noone, followed closely by Dunk.

 

[clippedgull]

For me it's between Dunk, Greer, and Bridcutt

 

[Mendoza]

For me
1 - Bridcutt - steady, keeps the team ticking with passing, buts in great crunching tackles
2 - Greer - getting better and better
3 - MacKail-Smith - always working despite getting the ball about 3 times a game

 

[algie]

1st Greer - Bridcutt - Dunk

 

[LABHA]

Bridcutt

 

[The Large One]

Only Gordon Greer, Lewis Dunk and CMS have shown any consistency.

Noone flatters to deceive, and KLL hasn't played enough.

Greer gets the nod at the moment.

 

[Albion Robster]

Bridcutt - consistent performer everyweek.
Dunk would be top, if he was able to cut out needless Yellow Cards.

 

[Munkfish]

Only Gordon Greer, Lewis Dunk and CMS have shown any consistency.

Noone flatters to deceive, and KLL hasn't played enough.

Greer gets the nod at the moment.

Nobody has mentioned KLL.

I think thats very harsh on Noone, although I havent made it to many away games, his performances at home have been brilliant IMO.

 

[Rugrat]

Very difficult but if put on spot I'd say Bridcutt

Pushing him ..... all those names above

I think Buckley has the potential to be Number 1 but suspect he's not going to get the pitch time

 

[The Large One]

Nobody has mentioned KLL.

I think thats very harsh on Noone, although I havent made it to many away games, his performances at home have been brilliant IMO.

Brilliant to a point. Can skin his man beautifully, go haring down the wing before planting an inch-perfect cross to the bloke in Seat J78.

 

[MattBackHome]

I vote GREER.
Then CMS, then Noone.

 

[BRIGHT ON Q]

Noone for me,absolutely outstanding for the first couple of months and still played well since.

 

[We're the Stripes]

Greer has come to the fore over the last month or two - probably shades it for me atm. Bridcutt, Noone & Dunk all started the season emphatically - all of August and most of September they were consistently brilliant, but haven't quite shown the same level of performance of late. Understandable considering they're all young and relatively new to this level. CMS has endeared himself to the fans as you'd expect, unbelievable effort and commitment, but hasn't been as productive as we (or he) would have liked.

Don't think anyone else gets a look in currently.

 

[The Large One]

I'm going to be controversial here and say I don't think Bridcutt has had a decent season at all - not one to be considered PotS anyway.

He's played OK in some games, and he can and does break up play. However, I feel he is too dithery on the ball, gives it away too much in dangerous areas, and the quality of his passing has slipped. I think he needs to up his game, although having a better quality midfield around him would help.

Flame away...

 

[Munkfish]

I'm going to be controversial here and say I don't think Bridcutt has had a decent season at all - not one to be considered PotS anyway.

He's played OK in some games, and he can and does break up play. However, I feel he is too dithery on the ball, gives it away too much in dangerous areas, and the quality of his passing has slipped. I think he needs to up his game, although having a better quality midfield around him would help.



Flame away...

Maybe a first, but I totally agree.

not saying he has had a poor season, but nowhere near PoS so far.

 

[aolstudios]

I'm going to be controversial here and say I don't think Bridcutt has had a decent season at all - not one to be considered PotS anyway.

He's played OK in some games, and he can and does break up play. However, I feel he is too dithery on the ball, gives it away too much in dangerous areas, and the quality of his passing has slipped. I think he needs to up his game, although having a better quality midfield around him would help.

Flame away...

Greer, Cms. And if Reyes or Vicente had some gametime...

 

[We're the Stripes]

Could argue Bridcutt has lost his way since he hasn't had Dicker beside him. They do work well in tangent (did all of last season) - probably more than most would like to appreciate.

Can't deny that he looked a Premier League player in the making over the first couple of months, though.

 

[Blues Rock DJ]

Greer for me, none of the strikers in my view.....including CMS I'm afraid.

 

[Simon Morgan]

Admittedly I haven't seen as many games as the rest of you, but in the ones I have seen Bridcutt seems to be absolutely crucial to us. He would be sorely missed if he left.

 

[Notters]

Michael Poke hasn't put a foot wrong.