Couldn't see another thread on this but MOTD2 all believed it was a handball.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Penalty?
- Thread starter PILTDOWN MAN
- Start date
Baldseagull
Well-known member
I think not, but I also think the one they gave against Dunk was not either, who the f*** knows what the handball rule really is anymore?
Insel affe
HellBilly
- Oct 17, 2008
- 14,579
Interestingly the short Sky Sports highlights on YouTube focused on it.
It would’ve been very harsh. Never a penalty in my view.
Unlike the delivery.
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,139
In the replay on MotD2 you can see that his arm is away from his body and moves towards the ball.
Under the current rules, it was clearly a penalty.
The fact it "would have been harsh" is ignoring the fact that the current interpretation of the laws is extremely harsh.
Under the current rules, it was clearly a penalty.
The fact it "would have been harsh" is ignoring the fact that the current interpretation of the laws is extremely harsh.
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,139
Indeed.
MotD2 didn't fall back on the "I've seen 'em given" cop out.
They all agreed we had been hard done by.
- Oct 17, 2008
- 14,579
When you watch the clip a few times at 0.25 speed (as I did to get the screenshot) he doesn’t move his arm towards the ball, he just jumps to block the cross. It was never a penalty.
The problem is Dunk’s one against us was very soft and never should’ve been given either, so fans, pundits and - crucially - referees have no idea what the actual law is any more anyway.
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,139
OK but he jumps with his arm out.
It wasn't given because he had "his arm tucked in" which is frankly, bolleaux.
macbeth
Dismembered
there was but those are only given if the player being grabbed has a reasonable chance of playing the ball.
which webster didn’t, as of course the delivery was abysmal
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
Ain’t that just so….eeez complicated
- Oct 17, 2008
- 14,579
Been a while since I’ve seen this gem. The beauty is you can answer practically any question with it.
Penalty every day. Not even a glancing blow, like some that have been given for merely brushing the arm as it went past. This was a hard elbow which cleared the ball away from a danger area direct to one of his fellow defenders - a really good pass, in fact!
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,139
Good point!
Similar to the one not given against Brentford last season, the handball actively interferes with the game, by preventing a targeted cross.
Sorry that it wasn't deliberate etc etc, but blocking a cross with your hand - is handball, and always should be.
This is the correct answer.
People might see it as unbelievably harsh, but it ticks all the very clear criteria for a handball under the current laws.
brighton_tom
Well-known member
- Jul 23, 2008
- 5,525
Maybe harsh but you’ve seen them given and fits a lot, if not all, of the criteria for a handball penalty. Arm up, away from body, blocks the ball.
5Ways Gull
È quello che è
Think 1 in 5 refs would have given it! According to RdZ.
METALMICKY
Well-known member
- Jan 30, 2004
- 6,844
This too!