Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[News] Middle East conflict



portslade seagull

Well-known member
Jul 19, 2003
17,944
portslade
If the Israeli army was 'random bombing' in such a densely populated area, then the figures would be astronomically higher than they're being quoted as. Not that any figure is a good figure :down:
There are sadly probably many 100s or 1000s still under the rubble on the many destroyed buildings so it will be higher if that pleases you
 






Insel affe

HellBilly
Feb 23, 2009
24,330
Brighton factually.....
At least 9,000 children but many missing

From the 7/10 massacre
695 Israeli civilians, including 36 children as well as 373 security forces and 71 foreigners, giving a total of 1,139 and 8,000 injured

From the war in Gaza

figures harder to quantify but around 9,000 children (with 8,663 injured, 7,000 missing) from a total of 22,489 and 57,000 injured

View attachment 172176


If people try and win the higher moral ground based on numbers there’s no comparison and they should not be compared like this anyway - it’s not a competition. It’s heinous that people including foreigners died in on 7/10 and heinous that civilian casualties are continuing to mount up daily in Gaza.


Two wrongs do not make a right, everyone can see Israel's response is disproportionate.
For every child killed by Hamas in that dreadful attack, Israel has taken nearly 253 children's lives for one of theirs and that does not include the missing 7000, which would be even more horrific 447 lives for one of theirs.
heart breaking, sickening and disgusting.
 


raymondo

Well-known member
Apr 26, 2017
7,338
Wiltshire
Unfortunately, the UK arms industry is waaaaaaaaay too profitable and powerful for that to ever happen.

The UK has about 15% of the entire global arms trade, worth billions. It's one of our biggest industries. Most of our sales go to the Middle East and most of that to Saudi.
Shame we can't redirect more of it to Ukraine for a while.
 


armchairclubber

Well-known member
Aug 8, 2010
1,658
Bexhill
Unfortunately, the UK arms industry is waaaaaaaaay too profitable and powerful for that to ever happen.

The UK has about 15% of the entire global arms trade, worth billions. It's one of our biggest industries. Most of our sales go to the Middle East and most of that to Saudi.
It makes you wonder how a serious threat or a deadline regarding this might have carried some weight in trying to negotiate a ceasefire or peace agreement, though neither of our front benches are or were of that mind.

My use of the term sanctions was left open though I'm unaware of any imposed.
 




beorhthelm

A. Virgo, Football Genius
Jul 21, 2003
36,013
If the Israeli army was 'random bombing' in such a densely populated area, then the figures would be astronomically higher than they're being quoted as. Not that any figure is a good figure :down:
its certainly no precision strikes either. cant find it now, the amount of ordinance dropped in months to December was about same as in the number of years the US dropped in Iraq II.

Israel dont care about the civilian collateral damage, because they dont want the Palestinians there anymore.
 
Last edited:


BadFish

Huge Member
Oct 19, 2003
18,194
As we play the numbers game with a focus on innocent lives being lost it surely becomes a no brainer that a cease fire is the most humanitarian and logical short term goal.

Although earlier in the thread they couldn't bring themselves to condemn the Israeli killings, surely even the Israel fanboys would agree with this?
 


BadFish

Huge Member
Oct 19, 2003
18,194
its certainly no precision strikes either. cant find it now, the amount of ordinance dropped in months to December was about same as in the number of years the US dropped in Iraq II.

Israel dont care about the civilian collateral damage, because they dont want the Palestinians there anymore.
The longer this goes on the more it looks like Israel is taking this opportunity with both hands to reach the end game of finally destroying the two party solution for good. Well let's call it what it is, genocide.
 




Bozza

You can change this
Helpful Moderator
Jul 4, 2003
57,283
Back in Sussex
its certainly no precision strikes either. cant find it now, the amount of ordinance dropped in months to December was about same as in the number of years the US dropped in Iraq II.

Israel dont care about the civilian collateral damage, because they dont want the Palestinians there anymore.
Well, the man who will have the best intelligence in the world, and the leader of Israel's greatest ally, described it as "indiscriminate bombing".

Joe Biden: "But they're starting to lose that support by indiscriminate bombing that takes place,"

 
Last edited:


Zeberdi

“Vorsprung durch Technik”
NSC Patron
Oct 20, 2022
6,905
The longer this goes on the more it looks like Israel is taking this opportunity with both hands to reach the end game of finally destroying the two party solution for good. Well let's call it what it is, genocide.
It was always the ‘endgame’ of the Religious Zionists of the Netanyahu regime for nearly a decade who have a ‘Greater Israel’ political ideology. The massacre on 7/10 simply provided the Religious Zionists that prop up the Netanyahu regime with what they thought would be their moral high ground from which they could justify it to the International community - “Expulsion of Hamas ( read that as ‘Palestinians’) from the OPT as an existential imperative for Israel facing annihilation from her neighbours” - many uninformed pro-Israel supporters have bought into the rhetoric condemning anyone that questions this perspective as anti-Semitic. The West and most of the Arab world was normalising relations with Israel before this attack - a relationship that was pressing very hard for a two state solution that neither Netanyahu nor Hamas wanted. What is chilling and as I said early in the thread, is that Israel is leading Gaza into the Abyss and risks dragging the whole of the ME with it and making it a self-fulfilling prophecy - we are another step closer to that now after the assassination of the deputy political leader of Hamas in Beirut. It is a very serious situation.
 
Last edited:








wellquickwoody

Many More Voting Years
NSC Patron
Aug 10, 2007
13,911
Melbourne
That second sentence is just not necessary.
I disagree. The Holocaust is used ad infinitum to justify Israel’s policy to defence, they are now committing ethnic cleansing and genocide themselves (albeit on a far smaller scale). If one country should be acutely aware of not going down the same extreme right wing route it is Israel.
 






Bakero

Languidly clinical
Oct 9, 2010
14,883
Almería
I disagree. The Holocaust is used ad infinitum to justify Israel’s policy to defence, they are now committing ethnic cleansing and genocide themselves (albeit on a far smaller scale). If one country should be acutely aware of not going down the same extreme right wing route it is Israel.

The thing is it seems deliberately inflammatory and unproductive. Not the kind of comment that's going to win hearts and minds.
 


BadFish

Huge Member
Oct 19, 2003
18,194
It was always the ‘endgame’ of the Religious Zionists of the Netanyahu regime for nearly a decade who have a ‘Greater Israel’ political ideology. The massacre on 7/10 simply provided the Religious Zionists that prop up the Netanyahu regime with what they thought would be their moral high ground from which they could justify it to the International community - “Expulsion of Hamas ( read that as ‘Palestinians’) from the OPT as an existential imperative for Israel facing annihilation from her neighbours” - many uninformed pro-Israel supporters have bought into the rhetoric condemning anyone that questions this perspective as anti-Semitic. The West and most of the Arab world was normalising relations with Israel before this attack - a relationship that was pressing very hard for a two state solution that neither Netanyahu nor Hamas wanted. What is chilling and as I said early in the thread, is that Israel is leading Gaza into the Abyss and risks dragging the whole of the ME with it and making it a self-fulfilling prophecy - we are another step closer to that now after the assassination of the deputy political leader of Hamas in Beirut. It is a very serious situation.

It is also easy to argue that Netanyahu's policies and actions over the last how ever many years have made the actions of 7th October inevitable. His support of Hama's at their outset provides part of the evidence for this. Obviously adding in walls, checkpoints, limiting supplies and increased settlements to this list of course.
 


Giraffe

VERY part time moderator
Helpful Moderator
NSC Patron
Aug 8, 2005
27,217
its certainly no precision strikes either. cant find it now, the amount of ordinance dropped in months to December was about same as in the number of years the US dropped in Iraq II.

Israel dont care about the civilian collateral damage, because they dont want the Palestinians there anymore.
I don’t think it’s completely fair to say they don’t care. I’m sure they do if only to placate their allies in the West.

What I find interesting is the size of Gaza. It’s not that different to the Isle of Wight so I’m struggling to understand why it’s taking so long to get this done. But then the population is 600k v 140k which probably explains it I suppose. However if they were really carpet bombing it that would be over very very quickly.

IMG_3152.jpeg
 


BadFish

Huge Member
Oct 19, 2003
18,194
I don’t think it’s completely fair to say they don’t care. I’m sure they do if only to placate their allies in the West.

What I find interesting is the size of Gaza. It’s not that different to the Isle of Wight so I’m struggling to understand why it’s taking so long to get this done. But then the population is 600k v 140k which probably explains it I suppose. However if they were really carpet bombing it that would be over very very quickly.

View attachment 172209
I was wondering this when they talked about the fighting continuing for most of 2024. Even if the goal was to kill everyone, it couldn't take this long.
 






Bakero

Languidly clinical
Oct 9, 2010
14,883
Almería
I don’t think it’s completely fair to say they don’t care. I’m sure they do if only to placate their allies in the West.

What I find interesting is the size of Gaza. It’s not that different to the Isle of Wight so I’m struggling to understand why it’s taking so long to get this done. But then the population is 600k v 140k which probably explains it I suppose. However if they were really carpet bombing it that would be over very very quickly.

View attachment 172209

The situation 1 month ago:

70% of homes now damaged/destroyed https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveb...ed-or-destroyed-wall-street-journal-analysis/

Have a read of this if you have time https://www.ft.com/content/fa93e55e-da75-477f-8bf7-e0f598d280d5 Or take a look at the video at the top of this story https://www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/gaza-destruction-bombing-israel-aa528542
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here