aolstudios
Well-known member
Good player but he'd only replace Webster on the bench atm.
Agree with all of this.I'm not sure it would suit all parties.
He'll want to be in the 1st choice CB pairing (I assume - he's playing every game now, albeit at LB).
Who makes way - Dunk or JPvH?
With Igor as first reserve and also Webby back fit, would we want to rock the squad boat by bringing him in? (Webster could be sold I guess). Still young of course, so the player potential and resale values are both high.
There is also the age old WAGES issue after his new deal at Chelsea. This, and the transfer fee with them needing their academy sales to ease FFP problems as much as possible (other than Colwill I think it's only Maatsen, Gallagher and James left who would attract a reasonable fee).
I have no doubt that signing him would improve the depth of our squad, but the knock-on effects could reduce the benefit?
Big fee and big wages for a player we are not desperate for...?
Not for me, Clive.
Obvs, if RdZ knows the squad would welcome him (and the competition for places he'd bring) with open arms, then I'm all in!
No but he's enjoying looking at his bank balance moreA testament to the coaching there.
I wonder if Caicedo is enjoying his football as much as last season?
If he could get in the teamNot so sure wages are as big an issue for him. Remember they were waving that 8 year contract in his face for weeks but he was stalling to see if we could meet an asking price for him. I think he’d take a slight cut to join us
And we would be helping them out of a huge FFP hole, giving them plenty of wiggle room for future signingsWould love to get him back but the prospect of giving that lot any money sets my teeth on edge.
He played well alongside Levi last seasonhe would be welcomed back by all, but adds another problem to resolve....
Dunky is better/effective when playing Left side - i.e. when with JPvH or Webster
Dunky is quality, but he then has to play Right side CB with Igor and Colwill and is not so effective
For once, have agreement with you to an extent, I would have liked him to stay, but he was and is a player to develop, and £40M seemed about twice as much as should have been his value at the time, looks worse still now. JPVH stepping up has made it work out really well for Albion.The guy is so overrated. Barely played last season and when he did he was good but probably because he had dunk next to him. Fair play to de zerbi for bigging him up as he's made the lad a lot of money.
I'm glad we didn't break the bank for him. Would have been very risky.
This. RDZ still talks about him today, if we had a chance to sign him for a not unrealistic sum we would and he would be a first choice player for us. He's class, just at the wrong, on many levels, club.Rdz loves colwill. I think he'd quite happily swap Webster for colwill in our squad. That would give him 2 left footed centre backs and 2 right footed.
With the number of injuries/suspensions/games we play there's plenty of playing time available.
We've also used 3 at the back and Igor at lb so I don't see any issues with game time.
The obvious and dull caveat is wages as it always is but if it were doable id be all for it. An added bonus would be getting him for a knock down price from Chelsea and then them losing their shit(again) when he goes back to being a top quality player and England regular.
No way would he be first choice right now. Not without dropping DunkThis. RDZ still talks about him today, if we had a chance to sign him for a not unrealistic sum we would and he would be a first choice player for us. He's class, just at the wrong, on many levels, club.
Lots more midfield cover last seasonI'm afraid I was never that impressed with him, though I can't deny that we had more clean sheets with him in the side. May or may not be coincidental.