It's encouraging to read your story of defiance which clearly helped you to survive.
Implicitly it suggests that the experience threatened to be damaging and the thrust of the article is that many people who endured such dislocation from family are psychologically ill suited to leadership, but paradoxically are 'shaped' to seek it as their role in life. Beard's thesis is entirely plausible and in my opinion gives an insight into the psychology of our last two old Etonian PMs who have 'misled' this country into such a parlous state. I hope you can agree....
Hi Lever,
There are no doubt a number of people who were sufficiently damaged by the experience to render them Ill suited to leadership, but conversely, there are plenty who survived intact who have made their mark as successful leaders in many spheres of life, not necessarily politics.Additionally, there are others who have gone about their lives in a quiet unassuming way and have turned out to be worthy members of society.
I tend to think Beard overstates his case and thankfully, not everyone who went to boarding school turns out to be a Boris Johnson. You may note from a previous post that I am not a fan and think the man is a disgrace and totally unsuited to be PM of this country. How much of that is down to his boarding school experience, not much I would suggest. I think he would be a shitehouse wherever he was educated.
PS. I am no great defender of public schools and my ‘alma mater’ gets short shrift from me when it seeks a donation from me to help pay for its latest vanity project.
Last edited: