Mackenzie
Old Brightonian
...Not quite the same discussion though is it, I would liken it more to whether Simon Sherwood was a brillient jockey because he rode Dessert Orchid to six wins in a row, or whether the horse would have won had he had any reasonably capable NH jockey riding him.There are some seriously disingenuous posters on this board, honestly.
If you see an amazing piece of architecture do you think the designer had a brilliant drafting desk? Or a great house so the builder had an amazing trowel? An artist only got success because of his brushes, Hendrix was only top because of his guitar?
Button has a great car, but HE won - and he won by good driving
I would say that Jenson Button has done a fine job, and is a worthy champion BUT his championship was due to his car equally, if not more than, his driving skills.
If I wanted a driver to drive a race for my life, JB wouldn't be that high on my list despite him being this years champ.