Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Is Ashley Barnes good enough for the championship
- Thread starter vulture
- Start date
terryberry1
Well-known member
Most games no, although he was much better today
Kneon Light
Well-known member
If played up front and not on the left wing then yes - as a back up to Hoskins and CMS.
Brimmermusic
New member
Shocking player. He is truly terrible.
shaolinpunk
[Insert witty title here]
I still don't really understand how he scored so many last season
deletebeepbeepbeep
Well-known member
- May 12, 2009
- 21,810
Played well today and he's only 22 FFS
Conkers
Well-known member
Despite the moaners on here, actually had a decent game. 2 absolute fantastic passes, one which would have ended in a nail on goal if it wasn't for a fantastic interception from the Brizzle defender.
Brimmermusic
New member
Are you joking?
turienzo's lovechild
New member
- Oct 25, 2003
- 23,964
he's average at championship level, good at league 1 level
my main problem with him is that he doesn't contribute ANYTHING if he's not scoring, unlike CMS and from today's evidence, hoskins
that said he's often played out of position BUT against wrexham he was up front against conference opposition and he still did absolutely jack sit
my main problem with him is that he doesn't contribute ANYTHING if he's not scoring, unlike CMS and from today's evidence, hoskins
that said he's often played out of position BUT against wrexham he was up front against conference opposition and he still did absolutely jack sit
Seagulls4life
New member
He has been played out of position alot. When you look at the performances where he's been up front with CMS... Pompey, Cardiff, Blackpool etc. He's been brilliant. He set up both CMS goals in the Leeds game and has converted a few penalties, he's a good player but he needs some confidence.
darters74
New member
Are you one of these fans that is gonna hate him no matter what he does? He is a striker not a winger. He is only 22 and has scored almost 30 goals for us in 18 months! Give him a break will ya!
I am a massive CMS fan but he has missed more sitters than Barnes this season, but he don't get the stick that Barnes gets.
JonathanLivingstonSeagull
New member
I don't understand how people can have such short memories. I presume if anyone criticise Barnes with vitriol and no balancing argument that they weren't a fan of the club last season. Opinions null and void.
That said, I think that Ash has struggled in this division unfortunately. It doesn't help he has been played as an ersatz winger so often, but it is in those pressure moments in front of goal where he has failed to hit the target that we have to do our judging. I don't feel like the club has time to bring his game to the level it needs. Maybe even a matter of confidence, but it looks to me like he should drop back down to L1 and be a top striker there, work on his game and maybe come back (even Craig Davies has done it!) after a season or two. Not necessarily to us of course, that's not how it works, but I wouldn't begrudge it! He was a sterling player for us last season and one of the reasons we were promoted.
That said, I think that Ash has struggled in this division unfortunately. It doesn't help he has been played as an ersatz winger so often, but it is in those pressure moments in front of goal where he has failed to hit the target that we have to do our judging. I don't feel like the club has time to bring his game to the level it needs. Maybe even a matter of confidence, but it looks to me like he should drop back down to L1 and be a top striker there, work on his game and maybe come back (even Craig Davies has done it!) after a season or two. Not necessarily to us of course, that's not how it works, but I wouldn't begrudge it! He was a sterling player for us last season and one of the reasons we were promoted.
Brimmermusic
New member
If he played well I wouldn't have this opinion.
He is lazy, terrible touch, can't shoot, no awareness and always loses the ball. He has only scored 3 goals from open play this season.
northstandnorth
THE GOLDSTONE
Like most of the team he needs a season to find his feet at this level if besides,Gus feels he has the ability to warrant a place in the first team so who are we to argue.
Why.T.F do so many sub Sunday league class footie players on here feel they know more about the game than Gus?
Why.T.F do so many sub Sunday league class footie players on here feel they know more about the game than Gus?
He only plays because of injuries to others.
Brimmermusic
New member
We might as well all shut up then, pfffft.
northstandnorth
THE GOLDSTONE
That statement is so f***ing wrong it makes me wonder if you have ever actually gone to a game.Injury to who exactly?