It did work though to the extent that it brought the louder, most vociferous fans together for singing. If you didn't want to stand and sing then there was always seats to be had down the front or on the extremities. If everybody sat down in their allocated seats then I'm sure there would be many bemoaning the lack of singing / support / atmosphere.
As we have seen with the North Stand, the atmosphere is not as good as it could be because you have small dispirate groups spread throughout the stand trying to get songs started (often different songs, at the same time). To me, it makes perfect sense for the more vocal support to be grouped together when we are away.
I used to go away a fair bit from mid 70s through to the 90s (but only infrequently in past 20 years) and I've never seen any blue on blue scrapping. The odd row between individuals now and then, but no real scrapping.
Very true, good point.
Unfortunately the 20 year olds who crushed us at Molyneux etc weren’t singers. Just chatting amongst themselves, on their phones, abusing home fans.