Hypia out or in?

[hitony]

What managers have we had to paid off since the Amex?

I don't know, I would probably have to sit in on all the board meetings to know exactly the correct answer to that, my comment was, in fairness, "they tend to have contracts that protect them financially"

 

[Insel affe]

But wouldnt it be fair to give him some time, if he is under immediate pressure from the off, the chances are failure will be the way it goes, he needs some decent amount of time and good all round backing from fans and staff alike............we wont go down in my opinion, that said we won't be in the top 6 either, but re-building with limited finances is not easy, it will take time IMO.

The club and staff do need stability to achive success.

Your right in away along with my concerns that he may not have the experience to galvanise the squad to turn these draws and defeats into victories. It's a very tuff call and one to be made by better men than me or NSC. I fear it is the devil or the deep blue sea sceniro, however very very important that the powers that be get it right. I feel the bums on seat factor will deal the ultimate death card not the future prospects of a manager we live in very much the here and now society and all that entails.... No patience.

 

[Braders]

IN but changes need to be made in training - we're trying the same thing week after week and it simply doesn't work!!

 

[Tubby-McFat-Fuc]

Out.

Before today anyone who mentioned the R word would have been laughed at.

Watching Hypias body language at the end, I actually think he could take us down. I would not be in the least bit surprise to see him go by mutual consent in the next week or so.

Tony Bloom is a legend and great at what he does, but I think its time for someone else to pick a manager.

We need an experienced British manager.... a dinosaur to some people

 

[Mellor 3 Ward 4]

Fence ... ask again after Hudders and Rotherham

This.

Lose at Huddesfield, and next Saturday at home to Rptherham, and he would have to go.

 

[Bombardier]

I hardly post anymore but felt compelled to vote OUT. I was not happy with the appointment from the start but decided to give him until the end of October. He is simply not ticking any boxes and todays performance was woeful!

 

[Mellor 3 Ward 4]

And with no players 'til Jan, bring in whom exactly?

Isn't the loan market open?

 

[British Bulldog]

Who might you suggest then, and which game changing players shall this Messiah bring?

Personally I'd have Oscar back like a shot to bring some organisation to the squad, but in the meantime without checking which managers are available I'd appreciate a manager who plays to our strengths and doesn't expect players to spend all their time covering other positions they are not used too.

 

[Steve Foster]

OUT so long as some of the backroom go too

 

[hitony]

Your right in away along with my concerns that he may not have the experience to galvanise the squad to turn these draws and defeats into victories. It's a very tuff call and one to be made by better men than me or NSC. I fear it is the devil or the deep blue sea sceniro, however very very important that the powers that be get it right. I feel the bums on seat factor will deal the ultimate death card not the future prospects of a manager we live in very much the here and now society and all that entails.... No patience.

Good reply and reasoned content, I have given good rep as a result

 

[WhingForPresident]

I would be inclined to blame the board rather than the manager. Our team is not good enough.

I didn't go today so maybe our tactics were terrible and we looked hopeless, but I think we've been playing decent stuff recently despite the results, we are just obviously lacking a quality striker. The board are the ones sanctioning the signings, hence I believe they should bear the brunt of the blame for our current position. The loan window is still open..

Having said all of this, our team may not be as strong as it was last season but we certainly shouldn't be where we are in the table, and if you aren't getting results you're bound to come under pressure.

 

[Insel affe]

Good reply and reasoned content, I have given good rep as a result

Oh joy, my first and last no doubt.....

Have a good evening.

 

[fleet]

Sorry to say this but the tactics are inept, but the team could be good. We are playing 2 at the back and 8 wandering around like lost headless chickens. Time to go now sadly.

 

[Rugrat]

I didn't go today so maybe our tactics were terrible and we looked hopeless, but I think we've been playing decent stuff recently despite the results

Trust me, forget the last 4 when arguably we could have won them all ... today we were gash

 

[Springal]

Needs 6 points from the next 3 games to prove himself in my opinion

 

[Don Quixote]

Many people were saying the team was a top 6 team not that long ago, and now it seems everyone thinks they are useless. Perhaps it is the manager.

 

[wigman]

We are going nowhere under him, he has no experience in this league and we need to save this season so he has to go.
He can also take his Welsh sidekick with him.

 

[hitony]

Nah, Ive done it again......and enjoy your evening

 

[jimbob5]

Wheel give him 3 games. If he does does win at least one of them I think wheel have to tell him he's finnish!

 

[Weststander]

Back him, simply because as discussed on here many times, the squad quality (including loanees) is shockingly poor compared to 18 months ago. That is absolutely not Hyppia's fault, with TB and Burke calling the shots.

We've lost Barnes, Ulloa, Hammond, Kuzschak, Upson, Orlandi, Vicente, Lopez, Bridge, Buckley, El-Abd, Bridcutt. There may be some players in that list that some disliked at the time, but compared to now, we've gone from feast-to-famine and at the same time have lost some fighters and leaders.

I don't think the likes of Lennon and Symons, praised because they're immediately getting wins, could get goals and wins out of CMS, COG, Baldock, JFC, LuaLua. The Bolton and Fulham squads still include many players of PL experience and quality.

The fault for this mess lies firmly with the Board. FFP must be complied with, but how come Bournemouth and Derby playing fast, passing and scoring football, with quality in their squads?