Surely the linesman has a part to play in it as well?
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Howard Webb had a GOOD game...
- Thread starter DJ Leon
- Start date
Surely the linesman has a part to play in it as well?
I remember thinking at the time that Webb wasn't watching as the free kick was being taken.
I thought he had a so so game, which was made much harder by the behaviour of the Dutch players. He really should have sent off Van Bommel, long before half time. The fact that he didn't really isn't good refereeing in my book. It's BOTTLING the big decisions.
I'm not sure whether or not it was a foul before Spain got their goal but it's hard to have any sympathy for the Dutch. By the end of the game, there can't have been many non-Dutchmen still hoping they'd do it.
But if he had, he then would've been absolutely slated for "ruining the spectacle" "making it all about him" etc, so he really can't win, can he?
For the record I do think De Jong and Van Bommel should've seen red.
Indeed not, which understandably is why he bottled it.
Slough Seagull
Bye Bye Slough
- Nov 23, 2006
- 743
This!
What annoyed me about the Dutch players was their selective memory. Yes, there was a refereeing mistake in the run up to the goal. However, the Dutch won back the ball and gave it away three times (from memory) between the refereeing error and the goal. Had they been concentrating on their own game rather the blaming the referee, the outcome of that game may weel have been different.
Good refereeing from Webb in difficult circumstances. I would like to echo the comments above re: some of the card-happy african referees we have seen in the tournament - had one of them taken charge the game would have been runied, or worse called off due to the number of reds.
Good refereeing from Webb in difficult circumstances. I would like to echo the comments above re: some of the card-happy african referees we have seen in the tournament - had one of them taken charge the game would have been runied, or worse called off due to the number of reds.
The Large One
Who's Next?
I don't think he bottled it. I think he made an active decision - probably pre-meditated - to try and not send players off, rather than a set of passive indecision (i.e. bottling it). Whichever way he'd have made his decisions about whether it should have been yellow here or red there, the Dutch would still have blamed him for their defeat.
Spain, meanwhile, sensing that Netherlands were being brutal took full advantage in some cases to make sure they benefitted from it.
Tony Towner's Fridge
Well-known member
Howard Webb had a very good game. The Dutch have ruined my long lasting image of them being a skillfull team of footballers. They had 4 days (between Wednesday night and Sunday) to sort out some tactics; yet all we got was kick the oposition off the park. Shame on them and it is no use them bleating about the refeeee. Van Bommel was a disgrace and should have been red carded in the semi.
Well done to Spain, I love the way they play, silky football and they do try and play it the right way. Pity Llorente never got more than a token few minutes . He is quality , watch Althletic Bilbao next season to see how good he is.
All in all 6 out of 10 for the tourney. Not the best but not the worst.
TNBA
TTF
Well done to Spain, I love the way they play, silky football and they do try and play it the right way. Pity Llorente never got more than a token few minutes . He is quality , watch Althletic Bilbao next season to see how good he is.
All in all 6 out of 10 for the tourney. Not the best but not the worst.
TNBA
TTF
rcf0712
Out Here In The Perimeter
For me I think the only card he shouldn't have given was Segio Ramos but then many of the mickey mouse refs we've seen previously would have sent numerous players off. I think he had a good game, in a very difficult role - Holland were a disgrace...
The only way the Dutch were ever going to get close to Spain was to set out as spoilers and cloggers because they`re not in Spain`s league when it comes to football.
Webb was ok but too lenient in my opinion. If Holland had won this tournement they would have lost the mantle of best country never to have won the world cup but taken on the new one of 'Worst team ever to have won it'
Webb was ok but too lenient in my opinion. If Holland had won this tournement they would have lost the mantle of best country never to have won the world cup but taken on the new one of 'Worst team ever to have won it'
Rookie
Greetings
- Feb 8, 2005
- 12,324
thought he did really well, don't get what the Dutch have to moan about. Never a free kick just before the goal, he basically fell over. Webb tried to keep everyone on the pitch under some extreme provocation, which should have made a better game. Unfortunately appeared the Dutch didn't come to play football but went to hurt people
You can't do that, you have to apply the RULES of the game! Studs into the chest of an opponent is not acceptable and should have meant a straight red.
Either he didn't see it, or he bottled it.
I could not agree more. Webb handled the game as well as anyone could have handled it.
The Dutch deserved nothing from the game so I'm glad they went home with nothing.
Spain were not blameless but given the provocation I can understand some of their reactions.
Arthur
Well-known member
Really don't know why the Dutch a moaning? He bottled two decisions and both of them were against the Dutch (De Jong and Robben (2nd booking - for kicking the ball away towards the end)).
That said I dunno why people are having a dig at the Dutch, they clearly couldn't cope with the Spanish so set their stall out to play in a certain way and it worked. If they'd held out for another 4 mins then it would have been a coin toss to win the world cup.
That said I dunno why people are having a dig at the Dutch, they clearly couldn't cope with the Spanish so set their stall out to play in a certain way and it worked. If they'd held out for another 4 mins then it would have been a coin toss to win the world cup.
If everything had been punished I do not think the game would have been completed. Holland would not have had enough players on the pitch.
Skint Gull
New member
When you see the decision that the dutch were moaning about from the sideline the 2 Spanish clearly obstructed the player. When you see it from Webb's position of looks like a petty little dive!
I thought he had an excellent game to be honest and echo what others have said, if it had been another ref it would have been carnage
I thought he had an excellent game to be honest and echo what others have said, if it had been another ref it would have been carnage
No, it *nearly* worked. And it probably shouldn't have come close to working. If one of the Dutch players had been sent off, I reckon they'd have been completely outplayed in the second half.
Switzerland proved Spain weren't invincible without kicking seven bells out of them.