By whom? I certainly never heard that.
There is a big difference between listening to the opinions of supporters who have just lost a decent player and the opinions of supporters whilst he is playing for that club. I went on HoF after our game with Millwall and they were all drooling at Trotter's performance but LOADS questioned why he couldn't play like that more often...
Pretty much EVERY Watford fan said it. It was true for them too...my point is I believe our coaches/Gus are able to get consistency out of players. Buckley WAS much more hot and cold for Watford than for us.