Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Fund my life: I want to live like a moron...



Pogue Mahone

Well-known member
Apr 30, 2011
10,949
Swansman, you're not getting much support on here, so let me offer it. I totally agree with you that too often people point their ire at those near them, whose narratives are easy to digest (immigrants, "scroungers", etc) whereas the much bigger, more important picture is the concentration of resources that mean a lot of people can't get the support they need. I also agree that our education system is misguided and think we need to do a lot more on critical thinking (especially now as facts are apparently becoming more 'subjective'). But no matter how comparatively trivial this off grid family's story is, I think it's unjustifiable to permit their conscious choice to unnecessarily rely on the work of others and deny their children a more rounded education.



Interesting. What's happening in Burnley?

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

Yes, that's pretty much what I have been thinking as I have been reading through this thread. Nicely put.
 




happypig

Staring at the rude boys
May 23, 2009
8,171
Eastbourne
Being a bit of a leftie liberal hand-wringer I tend to think that as a very wealthy country we can afford to support those unable to work. As a pragmatist I recognise that some of those who claim to be unable to work are, in fact, unwilling to work.
This pair of herberts, though, seem to be proud to espouse their unwillingness and as such are fully deserving of all the scorn and ire that they are getting.

I would also say the same about Her Majesty if she were ever to appear on TV and say she was milking the gig.
 


Easy 10

Brain dead MUG SHEEP
Jul 5, 2003
62,413
Location Location
Having watched the programme, they're clearly not stupid people. The guy in particular seemed pleasant enough, articulate and engaging, and they clearly adore their kids - as Stacey said, there's a lot of love in that house. But it doesn't take away from the fact that the chaotic, unstructured "we just do what they want" upbringing of those kids can only curtail and damage their life chances in the long term.

I cannot accept the illiteracy, or the lack of a proper diet, or the lack of vaccinations / medicine / dentistry, of not sitting down together for a meal, going to bed whenever they want, and the complete apathy towards actually parenting your kids. This vague notion of letting them "find their own way in their own time" is bobbins. Every child needs an element of that whilst growing up, but it cannot JUST be that alone. Thats bonkers. Kids aren't wise enough to make all the rules, or decide when they might start reading. They need help, structure and guidance, and from what I saw, they were getting precious little of that.

I would be deeply worried how that little lad is going to be coping with life in 5 years time, when he should be starting to gain some independence, but has been left so ill equipped to cope with life.

And whatever way you cut it, the parents are a couple of professional spongers.
 


marcos3263

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2009
954
Fishersgate and Proud
They are front page of the argus today and its a sensitive write up and makes them look less hideous - It almost looks acceptable the way its been written. I could be converted........
 


Hastings gull

Well-known member
Nov 23, 2013
4,652
Being a bit of a leftie liberal hand-wringer I tend to think that as a very wealthy country we can afford to support those unable to work. As a pragmatist I recognise that some of those who claim to be unable to work are, in fact, unwilling to work.
This pair of herberts, though, seem to be proud to espouse their unwillingness and as such are fully deserving of all the scorn and ire that they are getting. I would also say the same about Her Majesty if she were ever to appear on TV and say she was milking the gig.

A reasonable post but I would add that you might find that her Majesty is very willing to work.
 








Mr Putdown

Well-known member
Jan 26, 2004
2,901
Christchurch
1) their children: as others on this thread have pointed out, the kids are clearly being harmed by being deprived of basic education and lifeskills,

This got me thinking and I’m not sure my schooling gave me any genuine life skills, all of those came from my parents and wider family.
 




Easy 10

Brain dead MUG SHEEP
Jul 5, 2003
62,413
Location Location
“It’s a cost-effective way to live. If people are really angry, they can employ us to teach them to live on a shoestring."

*shakes head*
 




Chicken Run

Member Since Jul 2003
NSC Patron
Jul 17, 2003
19,811
Valley of Hangleton
Having watched the programme, they're clearly not stupid people. The guy in particular seemed pleasant enough, articulate and engaging, and they clearly adore their kids - as Stacey said, there's a lot of love in that house. But it doesn't take away from the fact that the chaotic, unstructured "we just do what they want" upbringing of those kids can only curtail and damage their life chances in the long term.

I cannot accept the illiteracy, or the lack of a proper diet, or the lack of vaccinations / medicine / dentistry, of not sitting down together for a meal, going to bed whenever they want, and the complete apathy towards actually parenting your kids. This vague notion of letting them "find their own way in their own time" is bobbins. Every child needs an element of that whilst growing up, but it cannot JUST be that alone. Thats bonkers. Kids aren't wise enough to make all the rules, or decide when they might start reading. They need help, structure and guidance, and from what I saw, they were getting precious little of that.

I would be deeply worried how that little lad is going to be coping with life in 5 years time, when he should be starting to gain some independence, but has been left so ill equipped to cope with life.

And whatever way you cut it, the parents are a couple of professional spongers.

If you get a puppy and let it roam aimlessly over the house pissing and shitting, have ko structured bed time, don’t teach it door manors, perhaps never walk it but if you did no lead, don’t discipline it when it wants to jump up at strangers, run into the road and finally let it eat what it wants when it wants and refuse to give it worming and flea tabs...

What sort dog is that puppy going to turn into??? Assuming the RSPCA haven’t stepped in!!
 






BLOCK F

Well-known member
Feb 26, 2009
6,723
This got me thinking and I’m not sure my schooling gave me any genuine life skills, all of those came from my parents and wider family.

It is surely good for children to be regularly mixing and socialising with other children, and in the process, learning the life skill of being able to work, communicate and collaborate with others, some of whom you may get on with and others less so.
It can help when one reaches adulthood and have to do these things!
 


Easy 10

Brain dead MUG SHEEP
Jul 5, 2003
62,413
Location Location
If you get a puppy and let it roam aimlessly over the house pissing and shitting, have ko structured bed time, don’t teach it door manors, perhaps never walk it but if you did no lead, don’t discipline it when it wants to jump up at strangers, run into the road and finally let it eat what it wants when it wants and refuse to give it worming and flea tabs...

What sort dog is that puppy going to turn into??? Assuming the RSPCA haven’t stepped in!!

I'm honestly at a loss as to how the social services haven't stepped in. While other kids are at school, these two are on a trampoline in the back garden, and going foraging in the woods. All very "New Age" I'm sure, but you'd think that when a child is home schooled, there are certain educational standards which that child still has to attain by key stages in their development ? The poor kid being completely illiterate at 8 years old is an absolute disgrace on their part.
 






Mr Putdown

Well-known member
Jan 26, 2004
2,901
Christchurch
It is surely good for children to be regularly mixing and socialising with other children, and in the process, learning the life skill of being able to work, communicate and collaborate with others, some of whom you may get on with and others less so.
It can help when one reaches adulthood and have to do these things!

Socialising, yep I’ll give you that one.
 


soistes

Well-known member
Sep 12, 2012
2,651
Brighton
This got me thinking and I’m not sure my schooling gave me any genuine life skills, all of those came from my parents and wider family.

Fair enough, but to judge from the coverage of this family, it is at least questionable whether what these particular “home educated” kids are getting from their parents, is likely to resemble what most of us would regard as “genuine life skills”. Foraging, trampolining and rolling in the dirt only gets you so far in today’s world...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 










Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here