sussex_guy2k2
Well-known member
- Jun 6, 2014
- 4,080
I was just to write of Jackie. I'm very much with you in that Portman was for the most part excellent, yet didn't make the character likeable at all, and it made me wonder of Portman's intent. Bits of it were very good, and there were elements of the chaos in amongst the trauma of such graphic and personal loss - what could and would she be now, or what could a woman be in those days of male-led inequality, how can she build on the myth of her husband's greatness, in part as I am sure we would all do when someone so close has gone, but also to her own sense of public identity - but whichever messages it was trying to release weren't clearly painted. I liked her in interview mode, of how in control she was whilst the remorse seemed to have begun to drift away a tad. The music was a bit much toward the end too. Was alright, but could have been more interestingly told. And without Greta Gerwig, whose hipster-face is even less changeable than Actorfleck.
I totally agree with all of that. Her motivations even seemed scewed with regards to just how intimate and loving her relationship really was with her husband, but again, that impression came from a couple of throwaway comments she made about their relationship which were never really shown further or built upon.
That had nothing to do with Portman, however. She had me. But it led to a lack of identity for the character, with how they'd written her. It's a shame, as it had the potential to be a 10/10 with slightly slicker writing.