Shuggie
Well-known member
I may be a ninny, and I am certainly no Wittgenstein but I have to pick you up on one point...
In writing: "I have no doubt however that he'd be getting similar rave reviews if his and Clarke's loan deals had been reversed and he had gone to Derby instead" the poster I quoted was making a counter factual assertion not asking a hypothetical question.
Here, you can talk to yourself ...
I have given you an argument, I don't have to provide you with an understanding.