[Albion] Danny Rose

[Seasidesage]

Actually he would offer more offensively at least than Burn or March IMO and would be a decent addition bar his age and wage demands which are likely to rule him out. He also has a wish to move closer to his roots in Leeds apparently so all in all unlikely...

 

[OSRGull]

I'm baffled that people are so quick to say no. Watching him on the Spurs documentary it's evident all he wants to do is play football, he may have had a disagreement with Mourinho but I wouldn't say that automatically means he is a bad player to have around the squad.

Adds a great deal of experience, on loan it wouldn't be a bad signing at all.

 

[aolstudios]

I wouldn't say he has an attitude so much as a brain

 

[MJsGhost]

Emile Heskey got 62 caps.

I'd be very happy to have Emile Heskey (in his prime) in our squad right now.

Maupay and/or Connolly buzzing around & feeding off his hold-up play would be a tasty plan B in my opinion.

110 premier league goals of his own is not too shabby either.

 

[Giraffe]

Doesn't fit the bill. Would rather see March given an extended run as left wing back.

 

[OSRGull]

Doesn't fit the bill. Would rather see March given an extended run as left wing back.

May I ask what the bill is? Apart from being under 30...

 

[vagabond]

I think this is nonsense anyway. But would ask to those in favour:

Why Rose over Bernardo?

Why Rose over March?

Why Rose over Burn?

Why Rose over any of our u23s who could play there?

 

[OSRGull]

I think this is nonsense anyway. But would ask to those in favour:

Why Rose over Bernardo?

Why Rose over March?

Why Rose over Burn?

Why Rose over any of our u23s who could play there?

Because he is easily better than all 3 of those players in that position, it's that simple.

 

[vagabond]

Because he is easily better than all 3 of those players in that position, it's that simple.

It is? Then why don’t Spurs and Newcastle want to keep him?

I personally wouldn’t swap Burn for him. Massively underrated, man of the match in a lot of our games last season.

And even then I’d sooner give the opportunity to one of our youngsters, eg Cochrane or whoever.

 

[maltaseagull]

I think this is nonsense anyway. But would ask to those in favour:

Why Rose over Bernardo?

Why Rose over March?

Why Rose over Burn?

Why Rose over any of our u23s who could play there?

Why Rose over Bernardo? Better player in that position.

Why Rose over March? Better player in that position.

Why Rose over Burn? Better player in that position.

Why Rose over any of our u23s who could play there? Better player in that position. plus very experienced in PL.

However, would want him on loan with some wages paid by Spurs.

 

[OSRGull]

It is? Then why don’t Spurs and Newcastle want to keep him?

I personally wouldn’t swap Burn for him. Massively underrated, man of the match in a lot of our games last season.

And even then I’d sooner give the opportunity to one of our youngsters, eg Cochrane or whoever.

They've never said that they didn't want him. He just wasn't playing consistently and that's what he wants to do so that's why he went out on loan. Newcastle have signed Jamal Lewis who is a young upcoming Left Back who will not cost as much in wages. Dan Burn has done a good job at left back when needed, but he is not the answer to a Left Wing Back,

 

[SeagullinExile]

I fear some people are expecting way too much!

To dismiss an experienced international player out of hand so quickly is completely bonkers!

 

[dwayne]

NSC folk once again kind of showing they don't know much about football. Danny Rose is a top top player way better than anything we have down the left side.

He's always played with commitment when he's been selected.

Would be an exceptional addition.

Sent from my SM-G977N using Tapatalk

 

[m@goo]

Just remember though, he’s been there 13 years and prob not caused issues before. Think he felt he deserved some respect...

The way he felt might have been justified but there are still mature ways of handling it. He might have got a better response from JM if he'd been less confrontational. He went in there for a fight.

 

[Timbo]

Like all people who suffer from depression, indeed.

And this weeks empathy award goes to.......Timbo!

Take a bow.

Honestly, do you really think that's what I meant or are you one of those that goes round all day desperately looking for something to be offended by?

Do you think I sat and watched Danny Rose open up about depression and thought 'yeah you're a right **** for saying all this'?

 

[Ecosse Exile]

I fear some people are expecting way too much!

To dismiss an experienced international player out of hand so quickly is completely bonkers!

Similar reactions at the start of the Adam Lallana thread, i wonder what happened to him.

Fwiw, my opinion is that i would prefer someone younger but he is undoubtedly better than what we have, so wouldn't object. Would prefer a loan with option to buy if both the Albion and Rose are happy to make it permanent at the end of the loan.

 

[vagabond]

NSC folk once again kind of showing they don't know much about football. Danny Rose is a top top player way better than anything we have down the left side.

He's always played with commitment when he's been selected.

Would be an exceptional addition.

Sent from my SM-G977N using Tapatalk

And how much do you know?

“Top player top player”, so where are all the top sides after him? Newcastle fans not glowing reports, not keen on keeping him either. Ditto Spurs fans who say he has a bad attitude to boot.

Yes he was a good player some years ago. On the decline now. Doesn’t fit our business model.

Again our fans do a huge disservice to the brilliant Dan Burn. Yes we need a LwB to round out our squad. I don’t think Rose is the answer.. as always I trust GP, Dan and Tony.

 

[Palacefinder General]

Similar reactions at the start of the Adam Lallana thread, i wonder what happened to him.

Fwiw, my opinion is that i would prefer someone younger but he is undoubtedly better than what we have, so wouldn't object. Would prefer a loan with option to buy if both the Albion and Rose are happy to make it permanent at the end of the loan.

You do realise it's a nonsense rumour I take it?

 

[Ecosse Exile]

You do realise it's a nonsense rumour I take it?

Yep, most of these rumours are.

 

[dwayne]

And how much do you know?

“Top player top player”, so where are all the top sides after him? Newcastle fans not glowing reports, not keen on keeping him either. Ditto Spurs fans who say he has a bad attitude to boot.

Yes he was a good player some years ago. On the decline now. Doesn’t fit our business model.

Again our fans do a huge disservice to the brilliant Dan Burn. Yes we need a LwB to round out our squad. I don’t think Rose is the answer.. as always I trust GP, Dan and Tony.

You don't suddenly lose it. A manager like potter is ideal for rose. Absolutely no harm in getting him on loan

Sent from my SM-G977N using Tapatalk