Jello Biafra
Active member
- Aug 8, 2011
- 300
Lopez is a disgrace. He should be dropped and fined. Play the game or don't bother.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Brighton v Newcastle - Player Ratings
- Thread starter Seagull27
- Start date
GingerBeerMan
3-0
- Dec 29, 2011
- 8,205
Spot on, please put me down for these scores too.
Players start of with a performance of 6 which is average, and he made a few saves, so 6.5
Shirley a 5 would be average
Pipe down. Win at all costs
Ankergren 6.5
Lopez 8.5
El-Abd 7.5
Greer 8
Bridge 9
Bridcutt 9
Hammond 8.5
Dicker 8
Orlandi 8
Barnes 7.5
CMS 6.5
Hoskins 8
Lualua 7
Crofts n/a
Solid performance against a dreadful Newcastle side. Very encouraging
Lopez 8.5
El-Abd 7.5
Greer 8
Bridge 9
Bridcutt 9
Hammond 8.5
Dicker 8
Orlandi 8
Barnes 7.5
CMS 6.5
Hoskins 8
Lualua 7
Crofts n/a
Solid performance against a dreadful Newcastle side. Very encouraging
Not sure how you can describe Greer's pass as superb, Bridge only just got to the ball.
Steve Foster
Well-known member
If 5 or 6 (depending on the pollster) is average, how can no-one so far rate CMS below average?
He didn't do anything all game. No shots on goal that I can recall or beat his marker.
Was definitely worse than average.
3 for me
He didn't do anything all game. No shots on goal that I can recall or beat his marker.
Was definitely worse than average.
3 for me
ees complicated no?
New member
Ankergen 5 - I have no confidence in him.
Lopez 8 - fantastic today Bruno is going to have to work hard to reclaim RB!
El-Abd 7- done well.
Greer 7 - done well.
Bridge 8 - had a great game, did excellently for the assist for the first
Bridcutt 9 - MOM - please sign a 5 year contract I will let you shag my mrs.
Hammond 8 - Best game this season I'd say for him.
Dicker 7.0 - starting to like him again can see him starting more.
Orlandi - 8 - fantastic game.
Barnes - 7 - did ok
CMS - 4 - waste of time starting him.
SUBS
Hoskins - 7 - I've always had confidence in him and wonder why he doesn't play more.
Lua Lua - 7 - done what was needed.
Crofts -N/A
chez
Johnny Byrne-The Greatest
Easy son. Maybe he made a bit too much of it but it was a foul and probably a yellow card as well so he deserved to go.
You would hope that a ref would look at the foul and not the reaction of the player when evaluating what action to take so you can't blame Lopez.
CliveWalkerWingWizard
Well-known member
Ank 6
Bridge 8
Greer 7
El Abd 7
Spanish 8
Bridders 9
Orlandi 8
Barnes 7
Dicker 7
Hammond 5
CMS 6
Bridge 8
Greer 7
El Abd 7
Spanish 8
Bridders 9
Orlandi 8
Barnes 7
Dicker 7
Hammond 5
CMS 6
- Thread starter
- #32
Alright, what did he do wrong that meant he was below par then?
Ankergren - 7 surprise selection but did his job well
Spanish Dave - 8
Bridge - 8
Greer - 7
El-Abd - 7
Bridcutt - 10 awesome, just awesome
Hammond 8
Orlandi - 8.5
Dicker - 9 had a very good game
Barnes - 7.5
CMS - 6
LuaLua - 7
Hoskins - 8 Please start against Derby
Crofts - 7
Outstanding performance, such a contrast to the Watford game. Newcastle, mind you, weren't up to much.
Spanish Dave - 8
Bridge - 8
Greer - 7
El-Abd - 7
Bridcutt - 10 awesome, just awesome
Hammond 8
Orlandi - 8.5
Dicker - 9 had a very good game
Barnes - 7.5
CMS - 6
LuaLua - 7
Hoskins - 8 Please start against Derby
Crofts - 7
Outstanding performance, such a contrast to the Watford game. Newcastle, mind you, weren't up to much.
Steve Foster
Well-known member
What did he do to suggest he was average?
Not saying it was his fault as the ball didn't seem to fall to him all game, however, how can anyone suggest a player with no shots on goal, no assists & not beating his marker can be given anything above a 3 or 4 is totally blinkered
Are you joking?
Ankergren 8 - parried out into danger area, otherwise not tested first half, couple of important late saves - from greer deflection and stayed big in a one on one
bridge 8.5 - chased lost cause* to cross for first goal, generally good performance
el ab 7.5 - outmuscled a few times, a few silly moments
greer 8 - good commanding performance, cleaning up spills, good late block in the ding moments
Lopez 8.5 - really starting to show his quality
orlandi 8.5 - well taken goal
bridcutt 9 - bossed midfield
hammond 8 - constantly getting involved, poor shot early on, a little slow, but generally good
dicker 9 - good passes, really pressuring their players when they have the ball
Barnes 8 - needless comical dive when could have perhaps broken through, otherwise generally good, positive contribution
CMS 7.5 - worked hard, generally good, but not involved as much as everyone would probably like, lost ball first thing due to being weak in possession, poor first touch ended an early break away, plays the ball a little too far in front of him making it easy to nick possession
Lualua 8 - seemed up for it, not sure he managed to achieve much, but still good
Hoskin 8.5 - Well taken goal, timed his run perfectly, constant threat after he came on. More game time.
Crofts n/a - Good one two with lopez to draw a newcastle player and created room for Hoskins and lopez for the second goal, but no on long enough to rate.
*not lost cause exactly, but the sort of ball that many left backs would give up on, and Bridge got to it before it rolled out of play
bridge 8.5 - chased lost cause* to cross for first goal, generally good performance
el ab 7.5 - outmuscled a few times, a few silly moments
greer 8 - good commanding performance, cleaning up spills, good late block in the ding moments
Lopez 8.5 - really starting to show his quality
orlandi 8.5 - well taken goal
bridcutt 9 - bossed midfield
hammond 8 - constantly getting involved, poor shot early on, a little slow, but generally good
dicker 9 - good passes, really pressuring their players when they have the ball
Barnes 8 - needless comical dive when could have perhaps broken through, otherwise generally good, positive contribution
CMS 7.5 - worked hard, generally good, but not involved as much as everyone would probably like, lost ball first thing due to being weak in possession, poor first touch ended an early break away, plays the ball a little too far in front of him making it easy to nick possession
Lualua 8 - seemed up for it, not sure he managed to achieve much, but still good
Hoskin 8.5 - Well taken goal, timed his run perfectly, constant threat after he came on. More game time.
Crofts n/a - Good one two with lopez to draw a newcastle player and created room for Hoskins and lopez for the second goal, but no on long enough to rate.
*not lost cause exactly, but the sort of ball that many left backs would give up on, and Bridge got to it before it rolled out of play
Last edited:
- Thread starter
- #37
Well I think that he did everything he could given the service he had. He didn't have any chances to shoot. And he did make a couple of good runs, very nearly nicked the ball off their defender to score, and generally held the ball up fairly well when required. Nothing special, but certainly not a bad performance by any means.
Beach Hut
Brighton Bhuna Boy
Can't be bothered with this other than Spanish Dave was easily MOTM in my view
Casper 7
Lopez 8
Greer 7.5
AEA 7.5
Bridge 7.5
Dicker 8.5
Hammond 8
Bridcutt 9.5
Orlandi 8
Barnes 8.5
CMS 6.5
KLL 7
Hoskins 7
Lopez 8
Greer 7.5
AEA 7.5
Bridge 7.5
Dicker 8.5
Hammond 8
Bridcutt 9.5
Orlandi 8
Barnes 8.5
CMS 6.5
KLL 7
Hoskins 7
Ankergen 8 Very good with distribution choices
David 8.5 Wow
El-Abd 7
Greer 8 Best performance for a while
Bridge 8
Bridcutt 9 Brilliant
Hammond 7
Dicker 8 Best ever?
Orlandi - 8
Barnes - 7
CMS - 7
SUBS
Hoskins - 7
Lua Lua - 7
Crofts - N/A
Top performance from a lot of players. David Lopez was like Bruno at the beginning of the season, Orlandi is starting to look really good and Gary Dicker, take a bow son.
They let us play which our opponents do away. Now Gus has to solve the problem of teams that park the bus at the Amex.
David 8.5 Wow
El-Abd 7
Greer 8 Best performance for a while
Bridge 8
Bridcutt 9 Brilliant
Hammond 7
Dicker 8 Best ever?
Orlandi - 8
Barnes - 7
CMS - 7
SUBS
Hoskins - 7
Lua Lua - 7
Crofts - N/A
Top performance from a lot of players. David Lopez was like Bruno at the beginning of the season, Orlandi is starting to look really good and Gary Dicker, take a bow son.
They let us play which our opponents do away. Now Gus has to solve the problem of teams that park the bus at the Amex.