Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Politics] Brexit

If there was a second Brexit referendum how would you vote?


  • Total voters
    1,099


Two Professors

Two Mad Professors
Jul 13, 2009
7,617
Multicultural Brum
Unfortunately (or perhaps not) we can't simply moor the gunboats off the coast of Europe and loudly clear our throats. We have to compromise. The compromise is not perfect, but on balance it is better for you and for me.

Only cos we haven't got any gunboats left:tantrum:
 




Two Professors

Two Mad Professors
Jul 13, 2009
7,617
Multicultural Brum
I won't be in there to long so no need to worry; I'll be in the poncey salons most of the time.

You'll be telling me next all these poncey salons are in Anderlecht!
 


Practically all economists agree that leaving the EU will cause damage to our economy. Nobody, not even the leave campaign, is disputing this fact.
What about remaining in the EU.

Greece is defunct, Italy is on the verge of financial meltdown, France is a basket case, Spain, Portugal and Poland too.
Ireland is struggling and it's youth are off to other countries at an alarming rate.

I will guarantee that Britain and Germany are going to have to bail out the EU. Forget our veto, it means nothing.

I worry that the EU army, which will happen with or without us, is going to antagonise that lunatic Putin and undermine Nato.

I feel we are at more risk from remaining than we are at leaving.

We are told that we are not really in a European Union. The fact that we are holding this referendum to Remain or Leave and not Join or Not Join tells me we have to get away from this rotting corpse.

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk
 


Hamilton

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 7, 2003
12,953
Brighton
No... they say "may".... they don't say "will"... you really need to keep up.

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk

For you and [MENTION=14132]Two Professors[/MENTION]

Ipsos MORI conducted an online survey of members of the Royal Economic Society and the Society of Business Economists on behalf of the Observer. The survey asked economists for their professional opinions on the likely effect of Britain leaving the EU and the single market on a variety of economic indicators, including real GDP and unemployment.

Now, we can debate what the economists mean by the words 'likely', but I think it is safe to say that it's their understanding that the word reflects a belief that the probability of something happening is quite high.

Of the 639 economists who responded:

72% thought it the most likely outcome would be a negative impact on UK real GDP over the next 10 to 20 years, if the UK left the EU and the single market. This compares with 11% who thought that a positive impact on real GDP would be the most likely outcome.

88% thought it most likely that real GDP would be negatively impacted in the next 5 years, if the UK left the EU and the single market. 4% thought GDP would be positively impacted over the same time period and the 7% thought GDP would be broadly unaffected.

Of those stating that a negative impact on GDP in the next 5 years would be most likely, a majority cited loss of access to the single market (67%) and increased uncertainty leading to reduced investment (66%).

73% of respondents thought that real household incomes in the UK would be lower over the next 10 to 20 years, if the UK left the EU and the single market. This compares with 10% who thought that incomes would rise and 13% who thought that incomes would be broadly unaffected.

Opinions on the longer term effects on unemployment were more mixed. 45% thought that the UK unemployment rate would be higher over the next 10 to 20 years if the UK left the EU and the single market. However, 33% of respondents felt that the unemployment rate would be broadly unaffected and 17% thought the unemployment rate would be lower. (This last statistic is the most optimistic statistic from IPSOS MORI's findings).

68% of respondents thought that the UK leaving the EU and the single market would increase the risk of the economy experiencing a serious negative shock. 22% thought it would make no difference and 8% thought it would reduce the risk.
 


Hamilton

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 7, 2003
12,953
Brighton
What about remaining in the EU.

Greece is defunct, Italy is on the verge of financial meltdown, France is a basket case, Spain, Portugal and Poland too.
Ireland is struggling and it's youth are off to other countries at an alarming rate.

I will guarantee that Britain and Germany are going to have to bail out the EU. Forget our veto, it means nothing.

I worry that the EU army, which will happen with or without us, is going to antagonise that lunatic Putin and undermine Nato.

I feel we are at more risk from remaining than we are at leaving.

We are told that we are not really in a European Union. The fact that we are holding this referendum to Remain or Leave and not Join or Not Join tells me we have to get away from this rotting corpse.

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk

But we will not be bailing out the EU. We have not bailed out any Eurozone economy. These are yet against pure lies being spread by the leave campaign. They are doing you a disservice.

There will NOT be a European army. Even if every country wants one bar the UK, it would need a Treaty and the UK would not sign up to that.

We are in a European Union. It enables us to collaborate, trade, share information, negotiate together, move freely - all positives that make a vast part of our continent a better place.
 






Jan 30, 2008
31,981
for you and [mention=14132]two professors[/mention]

ipsos mori conducted an online survey of members of the royal economic society and the society of business economists on behalf of the observer. The survey asked economists for their professional opinions on the likely effect of britain leaving the eu and the single market on a variety of economic indicators, including real gdp and unemployment.

Now, we can debate what the economists mean by the words 'likely', but i think it is safe to say that it's their understanding that the word reflects a belief that the probability of something happening is quite high.

of the 639 economists who responded:

72% thought it the most likely outcome would be a negative impact on uk real gdp over the next 10 to 20 years, if the uk left the eu and the single market. This compares with 11% who thought that a positive impact on real gdp would be the most likely outcome.

88% thought it most likely that real gdp would be negatively impacted in the next 5 years, if the uk left the eu and the single market. 4% thought gdp would be positively impacted over the same time period and the 7% thought gdp would be broadly unaffected.

Of those stating that a negative impact on gdp in the next 5 years would be most likely, a majority cited loss of access to the single market (67%) and increased uncertainty leading to reduced investment (66%).

73% of respondents thought that real household incomes in the uk would be lower over the next 10 to 20 years, if the uk left the eu and the single market. This compares with 10% who thought that incomes would rise and 13% who thought that incomes would be broadly unaffected.

Opinions on the longer term effects on unemployment were more mixed. 45% thought that the uk unemployment rate would be higher over the next 10 to 20 years if the uk left the eu and the single market. However, 33% of respondents felt that the unemployment rate would be broadly unaffected and 17% thought the unemployment rate would be lower. (this last statistic is the most optimistic statistic from ipsos mori's findings).

68% of respondents thought that the uk leaving the eu and the single market would increase the risk of the economy experiencing a serious negative shock. 22% thought it would make no difference and 8% thought it would reduce the risk.

hark at the grim reaper :angry:
regards
DR
 


But we will not be bailing out the EU. We have not bailed out any Eurozone economy. These are yet against pure lies being spread by the leave campaign. They are doing you a disservice.

There will NOT be a European army. Even if every country wants one bar the UK, it would need a Treaty and the UK would not sign up to that.

We are in a European Union. It enables us to collaborate, trade, share information, negotiate together, move freely - all positives that make a vast part of our continent a better place.
I am sorry but I just don't believe this.
We have already gone way beyond the original common market.

I do not trust the European commission one bit and I suppose that is what it will come down too for us all. Good luck to all of us in our decisions and let's hope we can all get back to just hating palace afterwards( unless you are a palace supporter, and they can hate themselves)





Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk
 




Hamilton

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 7, 2003
12,953
Brighton
I am sorry but I just don't believe this.
We have already gone way beyond the original common market.

I do not trust the European commission one bit and I suppose that is what it will come down too for us all. Good luck to all of us in our decisions and let's hope we can all get back to just hating palace afterwards( unless you are a palace supporter, and they can hate themselves)

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk

The European Commission can't make us bail out an economy. You don't have to not believe it - it's a fact. It just can't happen.
 


lawros left foot

Glory hunting since 1969
NSC Patron
Jun 11, 2011
14,075
Worthing
I don't know .... I am not part of the "Brexiteers heirachy"....

How can there be any pre agreement... are you really just being dull and obtuse?.. (that was a question not a statement).....

The government will decide on next steps depending on outcome.....

We are voting on campaign aspirations, you know, like we do at a general election... manifesto promises??... remember those.... ?..


Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk

Please don't try and patronise or insult me.
How can you vote in favour of leaving if you have not a clue about any specifics of what a Brexiteers would entail?
The leave campaign should at least, be able to give us a certain time scale, they say two years, but that is how long it took Greenland to leave, and things are a bit more complicated for us.
We aren't voting on a manifesto, because neither side has presented one, in the case of the inners, this is understandable, as things will remain much the same, and Cameron's concessions won earlier in the year form a small change to our membership.
The Outers have not given any specifics on just about anything, just a very vague promise that things will be better out of the EU, how that will happen, they don't know, because nobody knows. When a Government is elected in a General election, there are certain constants, we will not have to negotiate new trade deals, we will not have to change our whole long term economic plan, ( yes, I know parties will say they are different, but generally our core financial systems don't change).
With us leaving the EU, everything may change , and I say may, because I have no more of an idea what would happen, than you, or Boris or Gideon.
I would like more certainties before I burn my bridges
 


Two Professors

Two Mad Professors
Jul 13, 2009
7,617
Multicultural Brum
The European Commission can't make us bail out an economy. You don't have to not believe it - it's a fact. It just can't happen.

Can we have our £600 million pound back then?Naughty EU,giving the Greeks our cash.:angry:
 




Jan 30, 2008
31,981
Practically all economists agree that leaving the EU will cause damage to our economy. Nobody, not even the leave campaign, is disputing this fact.
simple simon says , do really think it would be the end of the UK economy LONG TERM ,IF SO YOU'RE MORE OF A FOOL THAN I THOUGHT AND NOTHING BUT A DEFEATIST
regards
DR
 




Baldseagull

Well-known member
Jan 26, 2012
11,839
Crawley
What about remaining in the EU.

Greece is defunct, Italy is on the verge of financial meltdown, France is a basket case, Spain, Portugal and Poland too.
Ireland is struggling and it's youth are off to other countries at an alarming rate.

I will guarantee that Britain and Germany are going to have to bail out the EU. Forget our veto, it means nothing.

I worry that the EU army, which will happen with or without us, is going to antagonise that lunatic Putin and undermine Nato.

I feel we are at more risk from remaining than we are at leaving.

We are told that we are not really in a European Union. The fact that we are holding this referendum to Remain or Leave and not Join or Not Join tells me we have to get away from this rotting corpse.

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk

So are you saying, leave the E.U. because they need our help too much? Not very British of you.
 




Two Professors

Two Mad Professors
Jul 13, 2009
7,617
Multicultural Brum
For you and [MENTION=14132]Two Professors[/MENTION]

Ipsos MORI conducted an online survey of members of the Royal Economic Society and the Society of Business Economists on behalf of the Observer. The survey asked economists for their professional opinions on the likely effect of Britain leaving the EU and the single market on a variety of economic indicators, including real GDP and unemployment.

Now, we can debate what the economists mean by the words 'likely', but I think it is safe to say that it's their understanding that the word reflects a belief that the probability of something happening is quite high.

Of the 639 economists who responded:

72% thought it the most likely outcome would be a negative impact on UK real GDP over the next 10 to 20 years, if the UK left the EU and the single market. This compares with 11% who thought that a positive impact on real GDP would be the most likely outcome.

88% thought it most likely that real GDP would be negatively impacted in the next 5 years, if the UK left the EU and the single market. 4% thought GDP would be positively impacted over the same time period and the 7% thought GDP would be broadly unaffected.

Of those stating that a negative impact on GDP in the next 5 years would be most likely, a majority cited loss of access to the single market (67%) and increased uncertainty leading to reduced investment (66%).

73% of respondents thought that real household incomes in the UK would be lower over the next 10 to 20 years, if the UK left the EU and the single market. This compares with 10% who thought that incomes would rise and 13% who thought that incomes would be broadly unaffected.

Opinions on the longer term effects on unemployment were more mixed. 45% thought that the UK unemployment rate would be higher over the next 10 to 20 years if the UK left the EU and the single market. However, 33% of respondents felt that the unemployment rate would be broadly unaffected and 17% thought the unemployment rate would be lower. (This last statistic is the most optimistic statistic from IPSOS MORI's findings).

68% of respondents thought that the UK leaving the EU and the single market would increase the risk of the economy experiencing a serious negative shock. 22% thought it would make no difference and 8% thought it would reduce the risk.

100% of German scientists in 1939 said Einstein was a loony and his theories were the mad ramblings of a sub-human.Were they right?
 


Two Professors

Two Mad Professors
Jul 13, 2009
7,617
Multicultural Brum
So are you saying, leave the E.U. because they need our help too much? Not very British of you.

Maybe you could start a charity for them?
 








Billy the Fish

Technocrat
Oct 18, 2005
17,594
Haywards Heath
So, no plans from the Brexiteers heirarchy then, apart from we're leaving.
No pre-agreements, no promises, non- binding preliminary discussions, not even a wink and a nudge"You'll be alright" from any other nation on Earth. What we need are specifics, as in "We have a pre- agreement with this country,"" we are committed to a deal with Britain"from that country,but as all through this cluster**** of a referendum, not a word

You're misunderstanding the process. The Brexit campaign aren't in a position to do any of that. The vote is just a mandate from the people.

Once they have that mandate the government and civil service will have to work out and negotiate an exit strategy. It will take years to see what it looks like and it's too complicated for anyone from either side to predict.
 




Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here