Bennett bid accepted?

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊









Shooting Star

Well-known member
Apr 29, 2011
2,883
Suffolk
If it's true, I'll be gutted. Love Bennett and he's a bloody good player. If he is gone though, I wish him all the best and will be rooting for him in the Premiership.
If this is true, don't you think these Premier League clubs are taking huge risks this summer on League 1 players? First Mackail-Smith is going to the Premiership and possibly now Bennett?
 


peterward

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 11, 2009
12,281
Because we had one player out of contract, offered him what we thought he was worth but he got a better deal elsewhere. The club aren't going to break the bank for a player and nor should they. Bennett will be a disappointing loss and especially if he only goes for £1m, but if we get a replacement for equal or less money then it's hardly the end of the world.

It will be a big loss, what I don't understand is, if these figures being bandied about were to be accurate (and thats a bif "if"), how can a winger moving to another championship club (Buckley) be worth the same/or more as a winger moving to the prem (Bennett), if benno is deemed prem quality and buckley currently championship quality, then benno should be worth a fair bit more??
 


The_Viper

Well-known member
Oct 10, 2010
4,345
Charlotte, NC
If any of this is true and he only goes for a million, it seems our ambitions aren't as high as NSC think. Looks like selling our best players on the back of PROMOTION points towards us being in a pretty poor position to do anything in this league for a few years. Like I said in another topic, staying up would be incredible for me. Top goalscorer and the player with most assists gone. Played Brighton.
 




Seagull kimchi

New member
Oct 8, 2010
4,007
Korea and India
Because we had one player out of contract, offered him what we thought he was worth but he got a better deal elsewhere. The club aren't going to break the bank for a player and nor should they. Bennett will be a disappointing loss and especially if he only goes for £1m, but if we get a replacement for equal or less money then it's hardly the end of the world. I certainly wouldn't want to stand in his way of playing in the premiership.

We're getting the disappointments over and done with early in the summer and so it will now only be positive news all the way through to August

Yep. I love your level-headidness. You should be a part-time seagullfan therapist! You are right, with all the ups and downs we need to stay calm and enjoy the ride! It's just a bit emotional when you lose your latest Brighton hero. EB will always be a Withdean hero, just hoped he'd be an Amex hero too.
 


beardy gull

Well-known member
Jul 18, 2003
4,125
Portslade
If any of this is true and he only goes for a million, it seems our ambitions aren't as high as NSC think. Looks like selling our best players on the back of PROMOTION points towards us being in a pretty poor position to do anything in this league for a few years. Like I said in another topic, staying up would be incredible for me. Top goalscorer and the player with most assists gone. Played Brighton.

It's June 3. Sake.
 


Springal

Well-known member
Feb 12, 2005
24,785
GOSBTS
If any of this is true and he only goes for a million, it seems our ambitions aren't as high as NSC think. Looks like selling our best players on the back of PROMOTION points towards us being in a pretty poor position to do anything in this league for a few years. Like I said in another topic, staying up would be incredible for me. Top goalscorer and the player with most assists gone. Played Brighton.

Are you suggesting we should have offered Murray a contract that put him over DOUBLE our top earner ?

And are you suggesting we shouldn't sell a player who was unsettled in January and never looked the same afterwards, to a PREMIERSHIP club ?

I don't see how the club really has a choice with either Elliott or Glenn....
 




beardy gull

Well-known member
Jul 18, 2003
4,125
Portslade
Are you suggesting we should have offered Murray a contract that put him over DOUBLE our top earner ?

And are you suggesting we shouldn't sell a player who was unsettled in January and never looked the same afterwards, to a PREMIERSHIP club ?

I don't see how the club really has a choice with either Elliott or Glenn....

Steady.

Agree with the rest of your post.
 




Shooting Star

Well-known member
Apr 29, 2011
2,883
Suffolk




peterward

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 11, 2009
12,281
If any of this is true and he only goes for a million, it seems our ambitions aren't as high as NSC think. Looks like selling our best players on the back of PROMOTION points towards us being in a pretty poor position to do anything in this league for a few years. Like I said in another topic, staying up would be incredible for me. Top goalscorer and the player with most assists gone. Played Brighton.

without jumping the gun here on benno as these are all rumours......... we as a club also have to prove to Gus that our stated ambitions are matched by our resources to retain and build, and keeping our best players where possible is important in that.

It looks like Gus was not overly arsed about Murray, but I doubt he will want to lose benno, even though I assume the pragmatic Mr Poyet will understand benno's ambitions and do his best to add more quality.

2 steps forward, 1 step back..... will always be the best all selling clubs (those outside the big 4), can hope to achieve.

every championship club player has a price
 
Last edited:


Insel affe

HellBilly
Feb 23, 2009
24,350
Brighton factually.....
without jumping the gun here on benno as these are all rumours......... we as a club also have to prove to Gus that our stated ambitions are matched by our resources to retain and build, and keeping our best players where possible is important in that.

It looks like Gus was not overly arsed about Murray, but I doubt he will want to lose benno, even though I assume the pragmatic Mr Poyet will understand benno's ambitions and do his best to add more quality.

2 steps forward, 1 step back..... will always be the best all selling clubs (those outside the big 4), can hope to achieve.

every championship club player has a price

Well said
 


ferring seagull

Well-known member
Dec 30, 2010
4,607
Copied from Vital Football Brighton today

Brighton Accept Norwich's Bennett Bid
Brighton are believed to have accepted an offer for star winger Elliott Bennett from newly promoted Norwich City, although personal terms are still to be finalised.

The Canaries have been after Bennett since the January 2011 transfer window, where Brighton rebuffed two bids to keep him at the club until the end of the season.

Norwich have now come in with a bid which Brighton have accepted, which is rumoured to add up to over £1million including add ons.

Bennett was influential in the Seagulls own title winning season scoring 8 times, and assisting over 20 of Brighton's 95 goals.

It will come as a bitter blow for Brighton fans as they are still coming to terms of losing their leading scorer, Glenn Murray to rivals Crystal Palace.

Russell Slade signed Bennett from Wolverhampton Wanderers on a 3 year deal in 2009 following a 7-1 defeat at Huddersfield Town.

This deal was extended during this season, but the lure of The Premier League and a bumper contract was too much, despite signing a new deal with Brighton.

Wolves will be keeping an eye on proceedings, as they are set to benefit from a sell on clause which was part of the deal when Bennett signed for Brighton.

Bennett played 99 times for The Seagulls, scoring 17 times and picking up the first medal of his professional career.

It was his pace and energy, as well as his sweet right foot that stood out making him a firm favourite amongst the Withdean faithful.

Norwich have been the busy early on in the transfer window, signing James Vaughan from Everton, bidding for Steve Morrison from Millwall, Craig McKail-Smith of Peterborough, Robert Snodgrass of Leeds United as well as Elliott Bennett from Brighton.

Gus Poyet returns to England today and is set to deal with the blow of losing his star man straight away, by announcing the signing of Will Buckley from Watford, in a deal that would smash The Seagulls record transfer fee by a considerable amount.

Buckley started his career at Rochdale, before moving to Watford in the January 2010 transfer window. Buckley has made 95 career appearances, scoring 18 goals.

Brighton have already signed Will Hoskins from Bristol Rovers, and Chelsea youth team products Ben Sampayo and Anton Rogers.

Gary Dicker and Liam Bridcutt have also signed two year deals with The League One Winners after their contracts were due to expire this summer.

Read more: Brighton Hove Albion - Brighton Accept Norwich's Bennett Bid
 




Seagull kimchi

New member
Oct 8, 2010
4,007
Korea and India
Copied from Vital Football Brighton today

Brighton Accept Norwich's Bennett Bid
Brighton are believed to have accepted an offer for star winger Elliott Bennett from newly promoted Norwich City, although personal terms are still to be finalised.

The Canaries have been after Bennett since the January 2011 transfer window, where Brighton rebuffed two bids to keep him at the club until the end of the season.

Norwich have now come in with a bid which Brighton have accepted, which is rumoured to add up to over £1million including add ons.

Bennett was influential in the Seagulls own title winning season scoring 8 times, and assisting over 20 of Brighton's 95 goals.

It will come as a bitter blow for Brighton fans as they are still coming to terms of losing their leading scorer, Glenn Murray to rivals Crystal Palace.

Russell Slade signed Bennett from Wolverhampton Wanderers on a 3 year deal in 2009 following a 7-1 defeat at Huddersfield Town.

This deal was extended during this season, but the lure of The Premier League and a bumper contract was too much, despite signing a new deal with Brighton.

Wolves will be keeping an eye on proceedings, as they are set to benefit from a sell on clause which was part of the deal when Bennett signed for Brighton.

Bennett played 99 times for The Seagulls, scoring 17 times and picking up the first medal of his professional career.

It was his pace and energy, as well as his sweet right foot that stood out making him a firm favourite amongst the Withdean faithful.

Norwich have been the busy early on in the transfer window, signing James Vaughan from Everton, bidding for Steve Morrison from Millwall, Craig McKail-Smith of Peterborough, Robert Snodgrass of Leeds United as well as Elliott Bennett from Brighton.

Gus Poyet returns to England today and is set to deal with the blow of losing his star man straight away, by announcing the signing of Will Buckley from Watford, in a deal that would smash The Seagulls record transfer fee by a considerable amount.

Buckley started his career at Rochdale, before moving to Watford in the January 2010 transfer window. Buckley has made 95 career appearances, scoring 18 goals.

Brighton have already signed Will Hoskins from Bristol Rovers, and Chelsea youth team products Ben Sampayo and Anton Rogers.

Gary Dicker and Liam Bridcutt have also signed two year deals with The League One Winners after their contracts were due to expire this summer.

Read more: Brighton Hove Albion - Brighton Accept Norwich's Bennett Bid

Keep up at the back!
 










bhaexpress

New member
Jul 7, 2003
27,627
Kent
It should be mentioned that this bit of 'news' has only been mentioned on Vital Football sites, nowhere else.
 




Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top