End of thread.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] At what point do we STOP being a selling club
- Thread starter JonnyComeEarly
- Start date
That was my point (above)
Oh I agree but that works along side buy gems as a low price and selling them high. We won't stop being a selling club.
this isn’t actually true. The only way is that you get taken over by a multi £bn consortium or oil rich nation. I don’t think any Brighton fan really wants that so we will have to keep doing things Tonys way.
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
As someone else pointed out all clubs are selling clubs Man City make significant sums selling young players it’s getting to the point when it’s not disruptive to the first team.
The Grockle
Formally Croydon Seagull
Probably never, almost all clubs have to sell their best players unless they have deep pockets or are happy to saddle themselves with huge debts.
It's also worth remembering that Bloom has invested huge sums of his personal wealth into the Club and to date, hasn't used money from transfers to service that debt, fees have been reinvested or covered operational losses.
It might be frustrating to lose our best players but we tend to stand firm, get good service from our top players and sell st a time that suits us.
It's also worth remembering that Bloom has invested huge sums of his personal wealth into the Club and to date, hasn't used money from transfers to service that debt, fees have been reinvested or covered operational losses.
It might be frustrating to lose our best players but we tend to stand firm, get good service from our top players and sell st a time that suits us.
Never, basically Real Madrid are the only club that's not a selling club and that's debatable.
This is just the frustrating side of being extremely successful. Do get a bit fed up of the media constantly talking about where our players are going to move to though, massive historically big team bias everywhere.
Why should I previously successful team have the divine right to be successful in the future?
This is just the frustrating side of being extremely successful. Do get a bit fed up of the media constantly talking about where our players are going to move to though, massive historically big team bias everywhere.
Why should I previously successful team have the divine right to be successful in the future?
Neville's Breakfast
Well-known member
You are imagining a world where we don’t trade football players. We just accumulate them until they are past their sell by date and then give them away when worthless. Who would ever finance that kind of football club ? Only the Saudis, Russians or some other shady criminal gangs. No thanks. I’m very happy selling players and re-investing to create different teams. What we will witness this season will be different to last year. Not worse without Caicedo and MacAllister. Just different and I like that.
Never.
The only way to stop that is to be owned by a state. I hope that never happens, so I'm content with the fact that we will always be a selling club.
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
It really doesn’t help the player we sold for a record British transfer fee has turned into a nervous wreck gifting goals to Forest and West Ham 
Algernon
Well-known member
Are we a selling club? Yes.
Will we ever stop? No. Nor should we. It's how we improve under the guidance of some clever individuals.
"Buying success" is a phrase used in a derogatory way in relation to football clubs and isn't something I'd ever expect anyone to levelled at our team or TB.
Can you buy success and still remain grounded and immensely proud of your club? Can you remain guilt free?
There's one way: The BHA way.
Have we "bought success?" Absolutely.
We've just bought it with someone else's money.
Thanks Todd.
Will we ever stop? No. Nor should we. It's how we improve under the guidance of some clever individuals.
"Buying success" is a phrase used in a derogatory way in relation to football clubs and isn't something I'd ever expect anyone to levelled at our team or TB.
Can you buy success and still remain grounded and immensely proud of your club? Can you remain guilt free?
There's one way: The BHA way.
Have we "bought success?" Absolutely.
We've just bought it with someone else's money.
Thanks Todd.
- Oct 12, 2022
- 2,798
When our capital and/or revenue streams are the highest of any club in world football. It’s a bit of an ask. Liverpool don’t want to sell Salah, but it’s still 50/50 that he’ll be here in three days time.
Every club is a selling club for someone.
nickbrighton
Well-known member
- Feb 19, 2016
- 2,187
Are we a "selling club" in the usual sense of the phrase? Southampton were a selling club. Our model is very different. We havent gone down that route although superficially it may seem so. Yes, we sell players for (a huge) proffit, but not until we are ready to, with replacements already at the club or lined up. The Cucerella , Bissouma and Caciedo transfers are prime examples of how we are different to the traditional selling club. Each time we all thought thats it- and yet replacements were in place, or were within a matter of weeks, and we carried on with arguably a better team.
The money from all our transfers since White hasnt been wasted, its been spent carefully and (so far) has been remarkedly succesful in that there have been so few misses.
As has been said earlier every club loses players , even Liverpool are obviously struggling to keep hold of Salah for example. That wont ever change, the whole football world relies on player movement vbetween clubs from non-league to the very very top. Thye system collapses with out it
So I dont think we are a "selling club" as such. We have an academy which produces players for different leagues around Europe and further afield, as well as providing players for our first team. We have started to buy some of the best players, and have become a second tier destination club, just iunder the real heavyweights- Fati to us insrtead of Spurs for example. I can not see this system changing while TB is at the helm-Thank God
The money from all our transfers since White hasnt been wasted, its been spent carefully and (so far) has been remarkedly succesful in that there have been so few misses.
As has been said earlier every club loses players , even Liverpool are obviously struggling to keep hold of Salah for example. That wont ever change, the whole football world relies on player movement vbetween clubs from non-league to the very very top. Thye system collapses with out it
So I dont think we are a "selling club" as such. We have an academy which produces players for different leagues around Europe and further afield, as well as providing players for our first team. We have started to buy some of the best players, and have become a second tier destination club, just iunder the real heavyweights- Fati to us insrtead of Spurs for example. I can not see this system changing while TB is at the helm-Thank God
tigertim68
Well-known member
- Sep 3, 2012
- 2,695
Would help if we had a bigger stadium
even a 35000 capacity would be a great help into gaining more revenue, which in turn would help
keep players for longer periods,
Also need to improve other sources of income, walked into the shop before yesterdays game , 20 minutes before kick off and was empty, , surely they would of learnt from last season ,
went to get the new away shirt for Europe no where in site , they must get these supplies in whilst the demand is there
even a 35000 capacity would be a great help into gaining more revenue, which in turn would help
keep players for longer periods,
Also need to improve other sources of income, walked into the shop before yesterdays game , 20 minutes before kick off and was empty, , surely they would of learnt from last season ,
went to get the new away shirt for Europe no where in site , they must get these supplies in whilst the demand is there
Never. Selling players at a peak price and refreshing the squad successfully is the dream model for every club. Where we’re shaking things up with the likes of Cucurella and Caicedo is demanding the amount they’ll be worth as soon as they’ve played a few high profile games for a ‘big’ club, rather than selling cheap and watching their value instantly double.
When we get bought by the Chinese state and become just another state run propaganda outfit in a soulless bowl selling 90,000 tickets every week.
Personally I’d rather we stayed the way we are.
Personally I’d rather we stayed the way we are.
Don’t start me on the trouble getting food and drink pre-match even with an hour in hand, or the post-match shambles that is now the WSU with stewards trying to kick everyone out within half an hour of the final whistle. Small beer (like the ones they eventually serve which are usually a quarter froth if they’re not flat) but on current form they’re going to lose roughly £400-500 a season revenue from me and my wife alone. And we only aim for a pint before and after. Multiply by, say, 3000 and it’s well over a million quid turnover down the swanee, just for not giving a shit.
portlock seagull
Well-known member
- Jul 28, 2003
- 17,962
Stop calling them ELITE! They’re just the RICHEST. Sake, no offence, but it’s feck all to do with being the best. So label them for what they are. Absurdly RICH!
Mr Bridger
Sound of the suburbs
Although frustrating at times to see such top talent go out the exit door, especially to the shit show they call Chelsea, but on the other hand it’s exiting and pleasing to see new jems being posted through the Amex letter box and being polished (oh missus) into something special. All part of our journey.
“Brighton have only gone and done it again, how do they do it”
“Brighton have only gone and done it again, how do they do it”