BensGrandad
New member
Past history tells us that rather than sign kids with potential MA will sign tried and trusted pros to get us out of this division and then reassess the situation.
so whats the difference if Wilkins signs some young kid we have never heard of from a Championship club, then if Adams did the same thing? Why is the Adams one automatically higher quality??
I would half agree with you. I think a more factually correct statement would be: Wilkins Loan signings have been the best for years.
Murray has yet to prove himself on a regular basis.
Have you actually seen him play? Going against the NSC grain I think the guy is absolute quality and I doubt we'll see him in the stripes for long
Have you actually seen him play? Going against the NSC grain I think the guy is absolute quality and I doubt we'll see him in the stripes for long
What
Im saying adams will attract a better class of player....players know him, they have heard of him, they know his reputation as whing commented on in the argus.
They will want to part of this, more in my opinion than a youth coach in his second season. Adams is well liked and respected in football...they know his acheivements in lower leagues and on top of it all...he will get every % out of a player and get them playing to their potential..something which wilkins didnt get imho.
We needed adams back...we need bigger gates, we couldnt have another season of 4-5k gates, and the quality wasnt good enough hense why people didnt go....that will change now imho
seconded, just because he doesnt appear to run around like Revell or Hart doesnt mean he is rubbish - quality signing, quality player
Im just saying it comes across like you think whoever Adams signs, it will be better than anything Wilkins could do.
Even if it was a young loan player no one had heard of
The one thing Wilkins has done is made generally decent signings. Even some of the more erratic ones (Savage) have made an impact.
Adams did make some fairly ropey signings last time (Newhouse, Pinamonte, Palmer, Campbell, Cartwright, Cameron etc) and also some superb ones.
One thing that is different now is that in Lloyd we do seem to have a decent scout.
Also where is Virgo going to play for us?
Is he signing then?
Murray is definitely a class act and the best striker since Zamora, IMO. Yes - as for raw talent, I really do think he's better than Nicky Forster and Leon Knight.Have you actually seen him play? Going against the NSC grain I think the guy is absolute quality and I doubt we'll see him in the stripes for long
Is he signing then?
If that is the case then Celtic will want him loaned out in the Championship for 3 to 6 mionths, where he's more likely to gain exposure to potential buyers.I have no idea, but it seemed to be the assumption people on here jumped to when Adams was re-appointed.
However he does have one year left on his Celtic contract and I would guess Celtic will be wanting to recoup some of the 1.5 million we mugged them for...
I have no idea, but it seemed to be the assumption people on here jumped to when Adams was re-appointed.
However he does have one year left on his Celtic contract and I would guess Celtic will be wanting to recoup some of the 1.5 million we mugged them for...
Not at all...im just stating that with the summer here and players geting released left,right and centre from a higher division, I feel Adams will attract a higher quality of player. Wilins seemed very tunnel vision about younger players, Adams knows what it takes to get us out of this division...a tasty blend of youth and expiereince and he knows what type of player. A mix of battle hungry defenders and goal hungry strikers....
Adams will also imho attract the right kind of player.....the player with the do or die attitude
Sprinkle a bit of Adams motivation and desire to succeed on top, gas mark 4 and we have a tasty team!!!
Do you think that if Adams was in charge the season just finished, his motivation would have got us the 10 extra points we needed to get in the play offs (irrelivant of Leeds points with/without deductions)
He hardly player under adams did he, so I cant see why he would come back.
He was a coppell,mchee,taylor player I thought.
But that is the sort of player adams will go looking for im sure....a put your head into anything kind of player....wilkins and his nancy boy youth players wouldnt last under adams...
I think Fraser will like adams style...not sure about coxy though.....adams wont stand for his crap like wilkins did.
If that is the case then Celtic will want him loaned out in the Championship for 3 to 6 mionths, where he's more likely to gain exposure to potential buyers.
Adams had him on loan for a season at Coventry and then Colchester had him on loan for last season and Adams was the number 2 there until Christmas, so he has played him a fair bit.
It's almost as if some people have forgotten the shite football Adam's teams play.