All-time Withdean XI [merged threads]

[BensGrandad]

Roberts

Watson
Morgan
Butters
Painter

Bennett
Carpenter
Rogers
Brooker

Zamora
Murray

 

[Silent Bob]

The two absolute unanimous choices seem to be Calderon and Zamora unsurprisingly. Our 2 best players in the last 15 years? Would they both make an all time Albion 11?

Calde gets in but his competition is Watson and Whing, Watto had his qualities and part of a succesfull team but Calderon is clearly a better all round player, and Whing, well he had his decent times with us but no contest with Calderon. I don't know about all time, he's definitely the best RB I've seen at the club (since the 90s).

Kuipers
Calderon Morgan Ingimarson Painter
Bennett Carpenter Sidwell LuaLua
Zamora Forster​

 

[BensGrandad]

I went for Watson over Calderon based on his defensive ability and the fact that a normal manager not Gus would have the right back defending more. Gus is more attack minded so an all time XI would be subject to who was the manager obviously the best XI under Gus would be different to that under MA 1st time.

To compare Watson , Whing and Calderon suffice to say I hope Whing is playing Tuesday night against us as he is eligible not being on loan.

 

[perseus]

Michel Kuipers

Inigo Calderon
Simon Morgan
Adam Hinshelwood
Marcos Painter

Elliott Bennett
Alan Navarro
Andrew Crofts
Richard Carpenter

Bobby Zamora
Lee Steele

Subs:

Gary Hart
Glenn Murray

 

[trancing]

Kuipers

Calderon
Cullip
Morgan
Painter

Bennet
Carpenter
Sidwell
Brooker

Zamora
Murruy