Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Football] Man City WILL BE RELEGATED from Premier League, says Football Finance Expert



wehatepalace

Limbs
NSC Patron
Apr 27, 2004
7,371
Pease Pottage
Well City's lawyers will have an idea of whether the case went really well, really badly, or somewhere in between. If it's in between then those at the top won't even know what's going to happen.

But if Pep knew it was going to be bad (and he'd know more than the players), why the hell would he sign for an extra year? Is it his lifetime ambition to manage in the Championship?
Surely it’s every managers dream 🤣
Can you even call yourself a manager unless you’ve had a season in the championship!
 




Stumpy Tim

Well-known member
Well City's lawyers will have an idea of whether the case went really well, really badly, or somewhere in between. If it's in between then those at the top won't even know what's going to happen.

But if Pep knew it was going to be bad (and he'd know more than the players), why the hell would he sign for an extra year? Is it his lifetime ambition to manage in the Championship

Maybe his one year extension includes an exit clause in the case of relegation? Maybe that's the main reason he signed an extension?
 


Shuggie

Well-known member
Sep 19, 2003
696
East Sussex coast
City’s Board may well be hearing one thing from their eye-wateringly expensive legal team whilst simultaneously protesting their innocence in public. But behind closed doors they ought to be planning contingencies. They’d have to sack themselves if they didn’t.

It’s almost impossible to be caught up in a doublethink exercise like this without unsettling the next layer down … which undermines the next … etc etc. And before you know it, you start losing games without being able to put your finger on why.
 


peterward

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 11, 2009
12,780
Nah. The club have spent the entire time claiming they're innocent and confident they will get no punishment, and while that's false bravado, they're not going to have quietly gone to the players 'we think we'll get a 60 points deduction, so don't bother trying'. Perhaps you're only suggesting that some players have a nagging doubt, and that can effect them, which is fair enough. But they don't know their fate any more than we do.

The fact is that a couple of key injuries (like Rodri) combined with the entire squad getting a bit old and crap (like Walker) all combined to make them drop.
A few of them will be onto their agents trying to work out who may take them on a season long loan next season!

Doku and Minteh would be a bit rapid :)
 


Herr Tubthumper

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 11, 2003
64,156
The Fatherland
Nah. The club have spent the entire time claiming they're innocent and confident they will get no punishment,
The vast majority of guilty poeple do. And then when they're banged to rights say "they made an error of judgement" to be followed in turn by some mitigating factors. stress, mental health etc.
 




jcdenton08

Joel Veltman Fan Club
NSC Patron
Oct 17, 2008
16,396
The vast majority of guilty poeple do. And then when they're banged to rights say "they made an error of judgement" to be followed in turn by some mitigating factors. stress, mental health etc.
In this case their offending has (reportedly) been so egregious and sustained, a guilty plea would’ve provided little mitigation or reduction in penalty, I suspect. Probably in their interest to fight it and drag it out with the most expensive best lawyers money can buy and take their chances with the panel.
 




Me and my Monkey

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 3, 2015
3,526
But if Pep knew it was going to be bad (and he'd know more than the players), why the hell would he sign for an extra year? Is it his lifetime ambition to manage in the Championship?
Maybe I'm just being a bit soppy, but isn't it possible that Pep feels some kind of loyalty to the players and other ordinary club staff, with whom he's worked for so long and had so much success? He may well have serious doubts about City being in the PL next season, but nonetheless doesn't want to be seen as the first rat to jump ship. It's only a years extension after all.
 




ChickenDipper

Well-known member
Nov 8, 2024
348
So anyone actually know if there’s likely to be a points deduction for this season if they’re found guilty and what the indications are? I guess the dull one can offer an opinion on this. @El Presidente

It could be massive for us of course.
 


Change at Barnham

Well-known member
Aug 6, 2011
5,789
Bognor Regis
So anyone actually know if there’s likely to be a points deduction for this season if they’re found guilty and what the indications are? I guess the dull one can offer an opinion on this. @El Presidente

It could be massive for us of course.
The articles I've read seem to think that if any punishment is given out to City that they will immediately appeal against it.
Making it unlikely that any table this season will be affected.
(But no one knows)
 


ChickenDipper

Well-known member
Nov 8, 2024
348
The articles I've read seem to think that if any punishment is given out to City that they will immediately appeal against it.
Making it unlikely that any table this season will be affected.
(But no one knows)
I can just see a Europe place for us or even CL (you never know) being dependent on if the points deduction goes through after initially being given and us spending all Summer obsessing over it on here…!
 




WATFORD zero

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 10, 2003
28,711
I was driving along quite happily yesterday when some dullard came on R5 talking about the new United stadium. I started to glaze over and the next thing I remembered was hitting the kerb. I had to drive the rest of the way home with the windows wide open and aircon on full blast.

They really should broadcast a warning :mad:
 




bhafc99

Well-known member
Oct 14, 2003
7,596
Dubai

Man City WILL BE RELEGATED from Premier League, says Football Finance Expert​


Oh, please let this be correct…….👍
Sadly I think it’s more…

No-one HAS a clue what will happen or when
 






JBizzle

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2010
6,592
Seaford
No chance unfortunately,if they needed to be docked 45 points to be relegated they would receive a 44 point deduction and a don't do it again letter.
Be interesting to see how this plays out. If Serie A can relegate a titanic club like Juventus because of the Calciopoli scandal and the SPL can relegate one of their big two, Rangers, for their own financial problems, then a league as powerful as the PL can certainly relegate Man City to protect the integrity of the league.

As you say though, the question isn't "can they", more "will they"?
 
Last edited:


SAC

Well-known member
May 21, 2014
2,669
Man City are not Liverpool of Manchester United and are very replaceable in the PL, they really wont get any special treatment. The only thing (and it's a biggie) on their side is the financial clout. People seem to think that the PL or the FA (or someone else) want them in the PL, in reality the PL don't care who is in the PL (other than Man U and Liverpool).
 


Milano

Well-known member
Aug 15, 2012
4,287
Sussex but not by the sea
Man City are not Liverpool of Manchester United and are very replaceable in the PL, they really wont get any special treatment. The only thing (and it's a biggie) on their side is the financial clout. People seem to think that the PL or the FA (or someone else) want them in the PL, in reality the PL don't care who is in the PL (other than Man U and Liverpool).
I agree with this.
I'd add Arsenal to that 'untouchable' list, and annoyingly probably Chelsea too.
 




Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here