robinsonsgrin
Well-known member
Tonight's episode was excellent imho. I have read the books, watched the documentary and thought this episode captured it all very well indeed. Love the interjection of real footage.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[TV] SAS- Rogue Heroes….New drama
- Thread starter The Clamp
- Start date
Biscuit Barrel
Well-known member
I liked the first series, but think the second series is pretty poor.
I would happily shoot that Paddy bloke if he was in my regiment.
I would happily shoot that Paddy bloke if he was in my regiment.
For anyone watching the new series, episode 5 features much footage filmed at the Bluebell Railway
Is it PotG?
Thrifty non-licker
The Clamp
Well-known member
- Thread starter
- #66
He was a fantastic man. Which is why it’s so terrible they have made him so one dimensional and unlikeable in the series.
The new recruits are also unlikeable. Bad actors too.
But it’s Steven Knight who wrote Peaky Blinders, which is another f***ing awful program.
Both look like music videos. No depth.
And that bloody punk music. Ridiculous.
Why does Jack O Connell deliver every line as if it’s a hugely meaningful proclamation. In a rather odd Belfast accent.
I agree. I do wonder if the Peaky Blinders person has done any sig. background research into the formative years
of the Regiment. The tv series is just bloody boring.
portlock seagull
Well-known member
- Jul 28, 2003
- 18,140
From the (often repeated) trailer, I just can’t bring myself to watch it even though read several books on inc namesake title. It just comes across as total unauthentic bullshit style over substance rubbish. Seems current producers are too removed from ww2 / greatest generation to have any proper understanding of (or respect for). We’ve seen the last of the best films and programmes, anything new from this era is utter crap and also usually woked beyond credible.
The Clamp
Well-known member
- Thread starter
- #69
I really agree.
The source material and the documentary written and hosted by Macintyre was superb. It didn’t need this. It’s all flashy and hollow.
There’s a couple of scenes in one episode where they return home. They were quite well done.
but too little too late.
100%. I'd add to that and say that the series lacks any suspense, any credibility of the characters and seems to thrive on one man shouting and screaming all the fu****g time. Mayne was a strong character, but there were a load more who were equally strong, in different ways. That blond haired actor in it should try Eastenders or some plastic programme like it. It's cringeworthy.
I actually watched this before the drama on Prime (as you noted). Agree it tells the story in more depth.
sydney
tinky ****in winky
you would shoot the man widely regarded as the founder of the S.A.S ?
boik
Well-known member
The drama series is exactly that - dramatic . Every episode stresses that "This is not a history lesson".
portslade seagull
Well-known member
Cheers for that will watch it
SeagullinExile
Well-known member
I quite enjoyed it. It’s only a bit of fun. The opening titles make a point of saying it’s NOT a history lesson after all!
The Clamp
Well-known member
- Thread starter
- #79
It’s not the obvious inaccuracy that makes me dislike it .
It’s the ridiculous music, the poor pacing, the thinly fleshed out, one dimensional characters, the fact that they have made someone as briliant as Paddy Mayne into a shouty, dislikable thug. The bad acting. It’s a mess.
- Nov 15, 2006
- 5,054
What’s your take on Playing Nice? I thought the end was absolute SHITE!
In fact I thought the whole series was hard to take seriously in the way the two couples interacted.