Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Register Log in

[Albion] Attwell



Uh_huh_him

Uh_huh_him

Well-known member
Sep 28, 2011
12,435
JetsetJimbo said:
I totally understand why people resort to conspiratorial thinking like this, but I think this is a situation where Occam's Razor comes in useful. Plenty of other clubs have complaints about Attwell, and I'm betting we're not the only board with a thread about him.

He's just really, really bad at this and shouldn't be reffing at this level for that reason.
Click to expand...
Yeah this.

but that Spurs game was a different level of incompetence.
 






Uh_huh_him

Uh_huh_him

Well-known member
Sep 28, 2011
12,435
Deadly Danson said:
I'd add that I have now watched the red card incident back. The foul on Pedro just prior should have been a yellow, Baleba's foul definitely shouldn't so two decisions within 30 seconds. Surprise surprise Attwell went against Brighton on both. Funny how often that happens with him 🤔
Click to expand...
In fairness to him, in that Spurs game, he (correctly) gave the Welbeck goal, which VAR (incorrectly) ruled out for an assumed handball by MacAllister.
 








D

Dancin Ninja BHA

Well-known member
Jul 6, 2003
2,269
Deadly Danson said:
I'd add that I have now watched the red card incident back. The foul on Pedro just prior should have been a yellow, Baleba's foul definitely shouldn't so two decisions within 30 seconds. Surprise surprise Attwell went against Brighton on both. Funny how often that happens with him 🤔
Click to expand...
Controversial opinion I know from me, but I'm not even sure it's really a foul, let alone a yellow.

Pedro does his usual 'make a meal of a challenge' (to be fair most/all players do these days) and the ref waves play on. Admittedly I've only seen the incident once on Match of the Day and I can't be bothered to watch it back to confirm or deny (!) but on first viewing it looked to me that it wasn't really a foul, Pedro made a meal.
 








Bold Seagull

Bold Seagull

strong and stable with me, or...
Mar 18, 2010
30,514
Hove
Dancin Ninja BHA said:
Controversial opinion I know from me, but I'm not even sure it's really a foul, let alone a yellow.

Pedro does his usual 'make a meal of a challenge' (to be fair most/all players do these days) and the ref waves play on. Admittedly I've only seen the incident once on Match of the Day and I can't be bothered to watch it back to confirm or deny (!) but on first viewing it looked to me that it wasn't really a foul, Pedro made a meal.
Click to expand...
Pedro’s antics border on embarrassing to be honest. He’s not going to get some decisions because of so much play acting.

As for Baleba, I didn’t think it was a foul either.
 


Deadly Danson

Deadly Danson

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Oct 22, 2003
4,729
Brighton
Dancin Ninja BHA said:
Controversial opinion I know from me, but I'm not even sure it's really a foul, let alone a yellow.

Pedro does his usual 'make a meal of a challenge' (to be fair most/all players do these days) and the ref waves play on. Admittedly I've only seen the incident once on Match of the Day and I can't be bothered to watch it back to confirm or deny (!) but on first viewing it looked to me that it wasn't really a foul, Pedro made a meal.
Click to expand...
I see your point and it can be argued either way - the issue for me being, yet again, two contentious decisions in 30 seconds and, who'd have thunk it, Attwell comes down against us in both. Taken in isolation, it's just a decision which goes against us which happens, taken in context of this and other games it becomes a pattern.
 


HeaviestTed

HeaviestTed

I’m eating
NSC Patron
Mar 23, 2023
2,226
Eeyore said:
So, again, I sympathise with the ref and go into my bunker. It's clearly the wrong decision and could have had an impact on the match. But, like it or not, these things happen and will always happen.
Click to expand...
Great attitude - people make mistakes, luckily we still won so no real damage done and our next game is Southampton (not city who we needed baleba for )
 






D

Dancin Ninja BHA

Well-known member
Jul 6, 2003
2,269
Deadly Danson said:
I see your point and it can be argued either way - the issue for me being, yet again, two contentious decisions in 30 seconds and, who'd have thunk it, Attwell comes down against us in both. Taken in isolation, it's just a decision which goes against us which happens, taken in context of this and other games it becomes a pattern.
Click to expand...
Fair enough - sadly every team (well maybe not Citeh) have refs that their fans think are against them. It used to be Kevin f**king Friend for me, now Atwell after Spurs. Joke refs sadly
 


happypig

happypig

Staring at the rude boys
May 23, 2009
8,227
Eastbourne
Weststander said:
No. The nearby fans and players didn’t react. Cut the sound of the drama queen commentator and it was a nothing coming together.

The ref made the amateurish blunder of reacting to a player writhing in pain. Rather than instead seeing what actually happened. If in any doubt, don’t act.

Radio Sussex felt the fourth official was behind the error.
Click to expand...
Or, and bear with me here, he could have given a straight red which VAR would have asked him to look at and would be appealable if he still thought it a foul.
 




M

Mike Small

Well-known member
Dec 26, 2008
3,106
Bournemouth manager reaction doesn't help at all. Carlos goes for it with his wrong foot but still not even a foul. Attwell not refereeing the match but his own ego/smaller clubs. He actually looked angry at Baleba's challenge rather than being circumspect. Onwards and upwards. Carlos fresh for 2 games in less than 4 days.
 






TugWilson

TugWilson

I gotta admit that I`m a little bit confused
Dec 8, 2020
1,867
Dorset
Eeyore said:
Ref's eyes deceived him there. He seems more focused on Beleba coming across him, but it looks like a slip from the Bournemouth player. There's minimal contact if any.

It's interesting how in live time it does look like a yellow card offence, but when it's viewed close up there is doubt about it being even a foul. From the angle he has, the referee has seen a clear foul because it looks that way. It's also interesting that Radio Sussex said the instruction came from the fourth official concerning the card.

So, again, I sympathise with the ref and go into my bunker. It's clearly the wrong decision and could have had an impact on the match. But, like it or not, these things happen and will always happen.


View attachment 192815
Click to expand...
It did have an impact on the match they scored , at the least it affected our goal difference :shrug:
 




jcdenton08

jcdenton08

Offended Liver Sausage
NSC Patron
Oct 17, 2008
15,052
Dreadful referee, had another really poor game, but I’m being generous and putting it down to incompetence rather than malice
 


phoenix

phoenix

Well-known member
May 18, 2009
2,876
Eeyore said:
Referees make wrong decisions, it's part of the game. It doesn't make them a c****. And it's that sort of abuse that means there are less of them coming through. If you were called a c*** every time you made an error at work how would you respond ? I do suggest that if these things raise folk's blood pressure to the point of irrational outbursts then trainspotting may be a better pursuit.

Most of the errors supporters call refs out for actually aren't when viewed neutrally. Today it was an error. It happens.
Click to expand...
I do and always reply "well thank you" i like to be polite and give positive vibes.
 


You must log in or register to reply here.
Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports

Share this page


Top
Link Here